No. Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (MEMR), The Republic of Indonesia Study on The Optimal Electric Power Development and Operation in Indonesia FINAL REPORT (Attachment) August, 2002 Chubu Electric Power Co,. INC. The Institute of Energy Economics, Japan MPN JR 02-131
Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (MEMR), The Republic of Indonesia Study on The Optimal Electric Power Development and Operation in Indonesia FINAL REPORT (Attachment) August, 2002 Chubu Electric Power Co,. INC. The Institute of Energy Economics, Japan
Contents Attachment - A Tables and Figures on Transmission Planning and System Analysis...A-1 Attachment - B Model Manual for Electric Power Demand Forecasting Models...B-1 Attachment - C Wien Automatic System Planning (WASP) Package A Computer Code for Power Generating System Expansion Planning Version WASP-IV User s Manual...C-1
ATTACHMENT - A Tables and Figures on Transmission Planning and System Analysis A-1
Contents Table A-8.1.1 Data of Generators No.1... A-3 Table A-8.1.2 Data of Generators No.2... A-4 Table A-8.2.1 Data of Transmission lines (500kV) No.1... A-5 Table A-8.2.2 Data of Transmission lines (500kV) No.2... A-6 Table A-8.2.3 Data of Transmission lines (150kV) No.1... A-7 Table A-8.2.4 Data of Transmission lines (150kV) No.2... A-8 Table A-8.3 Data of Transformers... A-9 Table A-8.4.1 Power Flows of 500kV Substations for Short-term Planning... A-10 Table A-8.4.2 Power Flows of 500kV Substations for Long-term Planning... A-11 Figure A-8.1 AVR Data for Stability Analysis... A-12 Figure A-8.2.1 Governor Data for Stability Analysis (Hydro Power Station)... A-13 Figure A-8.2.2 Governor Data for Stability Analysis (Thermal Power Station)... A-14 Figure A-8.3.1-19 Result of Stability Analysis (Southern Transmission lines and Tanjung Jati B)...A-15~33 Figure A-8.4.1-2 Result of Stability Analysis (Muara Karang Repowering)...A-34~35 Figure A-8.5.1-3 Result of Stability Analysis (Muara Tawar Expansion or Extension)...A-36~38 Figure A-8.6.1-13 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (Long-term Planning)...A-39~51 A-2
Table A-8.1.1 Data of Generators No.1 A-3
Table A-8.1.2 Data of Generators No.2 A-4
Table A-8.2.1 Data of Transmission lines (500kV) No.1 A-5
Table A-8.2.2 Data of Transmission lines (500kV) No.2 A-6
Table A-8.2.3 Data of Transmission Lines (150kV) No.1 A-7
Table A-8.2.4 Data of Transmission Lines (150kV) No.2 A-8
Table A-8.3 Data of Transformers A-9
Table A-8.4.1 Power Flows of 500kV Substations for Short-term Planning A-10
Table A-8.4.2 Power Flows of 500kV Substations for Long-term Planning A-11
Figure A-8.1 AVR Data for Stability Analysis (Thyristor-type Excitation System(Self-Excitation System)) [Standard Data] G1 T1 G2 T2 UL1 LL1 G3 T3 UL2 LL2 G4 T4 1.0 0.0 1.0 0.1 100.0-100.0 150.0 0.0 5.0-5.0 0.05 0.2 EFS/G3 EA EAS UL1 UL2 A-12 EA + G 1 1+T 1 s + G 2 1+T 2 s G 4 s LL1 + + G 3 1+T 3 s LL2 EF 1+T 4 s EA : Terminal Voltage of Generator EAS : Setting of Terminal Voltage of Generator EF : Field Voltage EFS : Setting of Field Voltage
Figure A-8.2.1 Governor Data for Stability Analysis (Hydro Power Station) [Standard Data] K T1 T2 T3 T4 T5 T6 U L G (%) (s) (s) (s) (s) (s) (s) (pu) (pu) (s) 5.0 1.0 10.0 0.3 10.0-10.0-0.001 1.05 0.0 - Sg 100 1+GS 1+T 1 s (65M) TQTS + (77M) PLM LVG X SR + 1 T 2 1/T 3 1 s U A-13 1/T 6 L 1 1+T 4 s 1 1+T 5 s 1-K + + K
Figure A-8.2.2 Governor Data for Stability Analysis (Thermal Power Station) [Standard Data] K T1 T2 T3 T4 T5 T6 U L G (%) (pu) (s) (s) (s) (s) (s) (s) (pu) (pu) (s) 4.0 0.3 0.2 0.2 5.0 0.25 9.0-0.001 1.05 0.0 0.0 A-14 Sg 100 1+GS 1+T 1 s (65M) TQTS + (77M) PLM LVG X SR + 1 T 2 1/T 3 1 s U P TH W CV W HT 1/T 6 L Cross Sec 1 1+T 4 s 1 1+T 5 s 1-K + + K
Figure A-8.3.1 [2002] No southern 500kV transmission lines (1600MW) A-15
Figure A-8.3.2 [2002] No southern 500kV transmission (1500MW) A-16
Figure A-8.3.3 [2002] Operation of one circuit between Paiton and Klaten (1400MW) A-17
Figure A-8.3.4 [2002] Operation of one circuit between Paiton and Klaten (1300MW) A-18
Figure A-8.3.5 [2003] Operation of two circuits between Paiton and Klaten (1400MW) A-19
Figure A-8.3.6 [2003] Operation of two circuits between Paiton and Klaten (1300MW) A-20
Figure A-8.3.7 [2003] After double pi connection at Cirebon (1500MW) A-21
Figure A-8.3.8 [2003] After double pi connection at Cirebon (1400MW) A-22
Figure A-8.3.9 [2004] Operation of entire southern 500kV transmission lines (1655MW) A-23
Figure A-8.3.10 [2005] Operation of Tanjung Jati B Connected to the northern line (Krian - Ungaran) A-24
Figure A-8.3.11 [2005] Operation of Tanjung Jati B Connected to the northern line (Tanjung Jati B - Ungaran) A-25
Figure A-8.3.12 [2005] Operation of Tanjung Jati B; Connected to the northern line, (Krian - Ungaran) Generation shut down (Paiton 610MW, T.J.-B 660MW) A-26
Figure A-8.3.13 [2005] Operation of Tanjung Jati B; Connected to the northern line, (Tanjung Jati B - Ungaran) Generation shut down (Paiton 610MW, T.J.-B 660MW) A-27
Figure A-8.3.14 [2005] Operation of Tanjung Jati B: Connected to Ungaran A-28
Figure A-8.3.15 [2005] Operation of Tanjung Jati B : Connected to Ungaran A-29
Figure A-8.3.16 [2005] Delay of southern transmission lines and operation of Tanjung Jati B: Connected to Ungaran (T.J.B660MW UNGARAN-CIREBON1800MW) A-30
Figure A-8.3.17 [2005] Delay of southern transmission lines and operation of Tanjung jati B: Connected to Ungaran (T.J.B660MW UNGARAN-CIREBON1700MW) A-31
Figure A-8.3.18 [2005] Delay of southern transmission lines and operation of Tanjung Jati B: Connected to Ungaran (T.J.B 1320MW UNGARAN-CIREBON 1900MW) A-32
Figure A-8.3.19 [2005] Delay of southern transmission lines and operation of Tanjung Jati B: Connected to Ungaran (T.J.B 1320MW UNGARAN-CIREBON 1800MW) A-33
Figure A-8.4.1 Muara Karang Repowering (off-peak) A-34
Figure A-8.4.2 Muara Karang Repowering (off-peak) A-35
Figure A-8.5.1 Muara Tawar Block Expansion [2007] A-36
Figure A-8.5.2 Muara Tawar Block Extension [2007] A-37
Figure A-8.5.3 Muara Tawar Block Expansion and Extension[2007](Without measure) A-38
Figure A-8.6.1 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2010 Balance Case) Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2005 Muara Tawar A-39 Bekasi Kembangan Cawang 26 22 23 32 Tambun Suralaya Cibinong 27 25 32 37 Balaraja Gandul 36 24 Depok Cilegon 33 28 31 34 Saguling Cibatu Cirata Bandung Selatan 28 Tasikmalaya Rawalo ST22 20 Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B CC31 22 17 Nimbang 16 Gresik 21 24 27 23 Grati Krian 25 Surabaya Selatan 15 28 Paiton Kapal 7 20 16 20 14 18 Klaten Kediri ST11 17 ST21
Figure A-8.6.2 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2010 West Case Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2005 Muara Tawar A-40 29 ST12 Suralaya 34 33 Cilegon 29 Balaraja Kembangan 25 39 Gandul Cawang Depok Cibinong 43 42 24 Bekasi 28 36 Tambun 34 29 32 35 Saguling Cibatu Cirata Bandung Selatan 28 Tasikmalaya Rawalo ST22 17 Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B CC31 21 14 Nimbang 16 Gresik 20 22 25 22 Krian Grati Surabaya Selatan 15 24 26 Paiton Kapal 7 20 14 14 19 14 ST13 21 Klaten Kediri ST11
Figure A-8.6.3 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2010 West Case Depok -Cibinong CB-off Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2005 Muara Tawar A-41 29 ST12 Suralaya 34 33 Cilegon 26 Balaraja Kembangan 20 27 Gandul Cawang Depok Cibinong 29 25 20 Bekasi 22 27 Tambun 30 26 28 30 Saguling Cibatu Cirata Bandung Selatan 26 Tasikmalaya Rawalo ST22 17 Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B CC31 21 14 Nimbang 16 Gresik 20 22 25 22 Krian Grati Surabaya Selatan 15 24 26 Paiton Kapal 7 18 13 13 19 14 ST13 17 Klaten Kediri ST11
Figure A-8.6.4 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2010 East Case) Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2005 Muara Tawar A-42 Bekasi Kembangan Cawang 24 21 22 30 Tambun Suralaya Cibinong 26 24 29 34 Balaraja Gandul 32 24 Depok Cilegon 31 27 29 31 Saguling Cibatu Cirata Bandung Selatan 26 Tasikmalaya Rawalo ST22 15 Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B 16 Nimbang 16 Gresik 21 20 25 24 Krian Grati 28 Surabaya Selatan 16 CC41 25 34 Paiton Kapal 7 30 ST41 21 20 20 15 Klaten Kediri 18 ST21 16 ST31
Figure A-8.6.5 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2010 Heavy-East Case: with measures ) Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2005 Muara Tawar A-43 Suralaya 25 23 Balaraja 23 Cilegon Bekasi Kembangan Cawang 23 20 21 28 Tambun Cibinong 28 32 Gandul Saguling 30 Depok 27 25 28 30 Cibatu Cirata Bandung Selatan 23 A23 15 Tasikmalaya Rawalo Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B CC31 22 16 Nimbang 17 Gresik 22 16 26 25 A41 15 Krian Grati Surabaya Selatan 18 32 29 CC41 47 Paiton Kapal 8 41 ST42 15 19 27 16 Klaten Kediri 15 ST31
Figure A-8.6.6 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2015 Balance Case Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2010 Sumatra Muara Tawar A-44 30 ST12 Suralaya 35 34 Cilegon 30 Balaraja Kembangan 26 42 Gandul Cawang Depok 26 29 A11 Cibinong 48 47 Bekasi 30 41 Tambun 38 39 32 37 42 Saguling Upper Cisocan A22 Cibatu Cirata Bandung Selatan 32 Tasikmalaya 27 A21 Rawalo ST22 Tanjung Jati B CC31 17 ST31 20 26 16 Ngimbang 18 Gresik 25 32 25 26 Cirebon Krian A31 Ungaran 23 Grati Surabaya Selatan 17 32 29 ST42 37 Paiton Kapal 7 33 ST41 20 26 25 18 21 15 ST13 21 Klaten Kediri ST11 19 20 ST23 ST21
Figure A-8.6.7 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2015 Balance Case Depok -Cibinong CB-off) Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2010 Sumatra Muara Tawar A-45 Kembangan 21 Cawang 23 Bekasi 26 35 30 Cibatu ST22 Tanjung Jati B CC31 17 ST31 20 26 16 Ngimbang Gresik 23 30 ST12 Suralaya 35 34 Cilegon 28 Balaraja 31 Gandul 23 A11 Depok Cibinong 35 30 33 Tambun 38 35 40 Saguling Upper Cisocan A22 Cirata Bandung Selatan 31 Tasikmalaya 27 A21 Rawalo 25 32 25 26 Cirebon Krian A31 Ungaran 18 Grati Surabaya Selatan 17 32 29 ST42 37 Paiton Kapal 7 33 ST41 19 26 25 18 21 15 ST13 19 Klaten Kediri ST11 19 20 ST23 ST21
Figure A-8.6.8 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2015 West Case Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2010 Sumatra Muara Tawar A-46 29 ST12 Suralaya 34 31 Cilegon 31 Balaraja Kembangan 28 46 Gandul Cawang Depok 27 31 A11 Cibinong 54 53 Bekasi 32 43 Tambun 39 41 33 37 43 Upper Cisocan A22 Cibatu Cirata Saguling Bandung Selatan 32 Tasikmalaya 28 A21 Rawalo ST22 Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B CC31 17 ST31 20 26 16 Ngimbang 17 Gresik 22 25 32 25 24 A31 Krian Grati 16 26 Surabaya Selatan 31 Paiton Kapal 7 21 23 23 17 21 15 ST13 22 20 Klaten Kediri ST11 ST15 22 ST14 19 ST21
Figure A-8.6.9 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2015 West Case Depok -Cibinong CB-off, Upper-Cisokan bus-tie CB-off) Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2010 Sumatra Muara Tawar A-47 31 ST12 Suralaya 36 35 Cilegon 29 Balaraja Kembangan 22 32 Gandul Cawang Depok 24 24 A11 Cibinong 37 31 Bekasi 27 34 Tambun 35 29 32 35 27 Upper Cisocan 13 A22 Cibatu Cirata Saguling Bandung Selatan 29 Tasikmalaya 26 A21 Rawalo ST22 Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B CC31 17 ST31 20 26 16 Ngimbang 17 Gresik 22 25 32 25 24 A31 Krian Grati 16 26 Surabaya Selata 31 Paiton Kapal 7 19 17 20 17 21 15 ST13 19 17 Klaten Kediri ST11 ST15 20 ST14 18 ST21
Figure A-8.6.10 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2015 East Case) Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2010 A-48 30 ST12 Suralaya Sumatra 34 33 Cilegon 18 29 Balaraja Kembangan 25 41 Gandul Cawang Depok 26 28 A11 Cibinong 46 44 Bekasi 30 39 Tambun 38 Muara Tawar 38 32 36 41 Saguling Upper Cisocan 27 A22 Cibatu Cirata Bandung Selatan 30 Tasikmalaya 27 25 A21 ST22 Rawalo Tanjung Jati B 16 Cirebon Ungaran 17 ST31 Ngimbang Gresik 24 22 16 16 26 25 21 29 24 29 A31 ST43 19 Krian Grati 33 Surabaya Selatan 18 29 CC41 Paiton 40 Kapal 7 36 ST41 ST13 19 Klaten Kediri ST11 20 21 20 ST23 ST21 ST32
Figure A-8.6.11 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2015 East Case Depok -Cibinong CB-off ) Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2010 A-49 30 ST12 Suralaya Sumatra 34 33 Cilegon 16 27 Balaraja Kembangan 20 28 Gandul Cawang Depok 23 22 A11 Cibinong 34 27 Bekasi 26 33 Tambun 37 Muara Tawar 35 30 34 39 Saguling Upper Cisocan 27 A22 Cibatu Cirata Bandung Selatan 29 Tasikmalaya 27 25 A21 ST22 Rawalo Tanjung Jati B 16 Cirebon Ungaran 17 ST31 Ngimbang Gresik 24 22 16 16 26 25 21 29 24 29 A31 ST43 19 Krian Grati 33 Surabaya Selatan 18 29 CC41 Paiton 40 Kapal 7 36 ST41 ST13 16 Klaten Kediri ST11 20 21 20 ST23 ST21 ST32
Figure A-8.6.12 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2015 Heavy-East Case : with measures Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2010 Sumatra Muara Tawar ST43 A-50 Suralaya 32 27 Balaraja 28 31 Cilegon ST12 Bekasi Kembangan Cawang 27 22 24 24 A11 35 Tambun Cibinong 33 40 Gandul 37 37 Depok 33 30 35 42 Upper Cisocan A22 26 Cibatu Cirata Saguling Bandung Selatan 29 Tasikmalaya 25 A23 20 Rawalo ST22 14 Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B CC31 26 17 Ngimbang Gresik 23 35 17 26 25 20 32 23 30 A31 19 A41 21 Krian Grati 34 Surabaya Selatan 18 31 CC41 49 Paiton Kapal 8 42 ST41 Klaten 16 Kediri 19 19 18 30 ST44 ST23 ST21 ST32 ST33
Figure A-8.6.13 Result of Short Circuit Analysis (2015 Heavy-East Case Upper-Cisokan bus-tie CB-off: with measures) Unit : ka The circles show the power stations, and the rectangles show the substations. The thick lines show the new facilities after 2010 Sumatra Muara Tawar ST43 A-51 Suralaya 32 27 Balaraja 28 31 Cilegon ST12 Bekasi Kembangan Cawang 27 22 24 24 A11 35 Tambun Cibinong 33 40 Gandul 37 28 Depok 14 33 29 33 38 Upper Cisocan A22 22 Cibatu Cirata Saguling Bandung Selatan 28 Tasikmalaya 23 A23 19 Rawalo ST22 14 Cirebon Ungaran Tanjung Jati B CC31 26 17 Ngimbang Gresik 22 35 17 26 25 19 32 23 30 A31 19 A41 21 Krian Grati 34 Surabaya Selatan 18 31 CC41 49 Paiton Kapal 8 42 ST41 Klaten 16 Kediri 17 18 17 30 ST44 ST23 ST21 ST32 ST33