Color Superconductivity: CFL and 2SC phases

Σχετικά έγγραφα
6.1. Dirac Equation. Hamiltonian. Dirac Eq.

Space-Time Symmetries

UV fixed-point structure of the 3d Thirring model

Example Sheet 3 Solutions

Problem Set 9 Solutions. θ + 1. θ 2 + cotθ ( ) sinθ e iφ is an eigenfunction of the ˆ L 2 operator. / θ 2. φ 2. sin 2 θ φ 2. ( ) = e iφ. = e iφ cosθ.

EE512: Error Control Coding

Phys460.nb Solution for the t-dependent Schrodinger s equation How did we find the solution? (not required)

Second Order Partial Differential Equations

CHAPTER 25 SOLVING EQUATIONS BY ITERATIVE METHODS

Απόκριση σε Μοναδιαία Ωστική Δύναμη (Unit Impulse) Απόκριση σε Δυνάμεις Αυθαίρετα Μεταβαλλόμενες με το Χρόνο. Απόστολος Σ.

Approximation of distance between locations on earth given by latitude and longitude

HOMEWORK 4 = G. In order to plot the stress versus the stretch we define a normalized stretch:

Concrete Mathematics Exercises from 30 September 2016

Higher Derivative Gravity Theories

The Standard Model. Antonio Pich. IFIC, CSIC Univ. Valencia

Matrices and Determinants

3.4 SUM AND DIFFERENCE FORMULAS. NOTE: cos(α+β) cos α + cos β cos(α-β) cos α -cos β

SCHOOL OF MATHEMATICAL SCIENCES G11LMA Linear Mathematics Examination Solutions

the total number of electrons passing through the lamp.

derivation of the Laplacian from rectangular to spherical coordinates

Exercises 10. Find a fundamental matrix of the given system of equations. Also find the fundamental matrix Φ(t) satisfying Φ(0) = I. 1.

Math221: HW# 1 solutions

Every set of first-order formulas is equivalent to an independent set

CHAPTER 48 APPLICATIONS OF MATRICES AND DETERMINANTS

Reminders: linear functions

Areas and Lengths in Polar Coordinates

Jesse Maassen and Mark Lundstrom Purdue University November 25, 2013

Derivation of Optical-Bloch Equations

Homework 3 Solutions

Lecture 2: Dirac notation and a review of linear algebra Read Sakurai chapter 1, Baym chatper 3

Section 8.3 Trigonometric Equations

Partial Trace and Partial Transpose

General 2 2 PT -Symmetric Matrices and Jordan Blocks 1

1 String with massive end-points

= {{D α, D α }, D α }. = [D α, 4iσ µ α α D α µ ] = 4iσ µ α α [Dα, D α ] µ.

ECE Spring Prof. David R. Jackson ECE Dept. Notes 2

Second Order RLC Filters

상대론적고에너지중이온충돌에서 제트입자와관련된제동복사 박가영 인하대학교 윤진희교수님, 권민정교수님

(1) Describe the process by which mercury atoms become excited in a fluorescent tube (3)

Non-Abelian Gauge Fields

Congruence Classes of Invertible Matrices of Order 3 over F 2

9.09. # 1. Area inside the oval limaçon r = cos θ. To graph, start with θ = 0 so r = 6. Compute dr

D Alembert s Solution to the Wave Equation

Homework 8 Model Solution Section

b. Use the parametrization from (a) to compute the area of S a as S a ds. Be sure to substitute for ds!

ANSWERSHEET (TOPIC = DIFFERENTIAL CALCULUS) COLLECTION #2. h 0 h h 0 h h 0 ( ) g k = g 0 + g 1 + g g 2009 =?

Variational Wavefunction for the Helium Atom

Problem Set 3: Solutions

Inverse trigonometric functions & General Solution of Trigonometric Equations

ω ω ω ω ω ω+2 ω ω+2 + ω ω ω ω+2 + ω ω+1 ω ω+2 2 ω ω ω ω ω ω ω ω+1 ω ω2 ω ω2 + ω ω ω2 + ω ω ω ω2 + ω ω+1 ω ω2 + ω ω+1 + ω ω ω ω2 + ω

Tridiagonal matrices. Gérard MEURANT. October, 2008

C.S. 430 Assignment 6, Sample Solutions

Hartree-Fock Theory. Solving electronic structure problem on computers

Symmetric Stress-Energy Tensor

forms This gives Remark 1. How to remember the above formulas: Substituting these into the equation we obtain with

CRASH COURSE IN PRECALCULUS

[1] P Q. Fig. 3.1

Phys624 Quantization of Scalar Fields II Homework 3. Homework 3 Solutions. 3.1: U(1) symmetry for complex scalar

Exercises to Statistics of Material Fatigue No. 5

( y) Partial Differential Equations

MATH423 String Theory Solutions 4. = 0 τ = f(s). (1) dτ ds = dxµ dτ f (s) (2) dτ 2 [f (s)] 2 + dxµ. dτ f (s) (3)

Partial Differential Equations in Biology The boundary element method. March 26, 2013

Areas and Lengths in Polar Coordinates

4.6 Autoregressive Moving Average Model ARMA(1,1)

Econ 2110: Fall 2008 Suggested Solutions to Problem Set 8 questions or comments to Dan Fetter 1

Section 9.2 Polar Equations and Graphs

MA 342N Assignment 1 Due 24 February 2016

The Simply Typed Lambda Calculus

Neutrino emissivities in quark matter

Example 1: THE ELECTRIC DIPOLE

Answer sheet: Third Midterm for Math 2339

Integrals in cylindrical, spherical coordinates (Sect. 15.7)

What happens when two or more waves overlap in a certain region of space at the same time?

DERIVATION OF MILES EQUATION FOR AN APPLIED FORCE Revision C

On a four-dimensional hyperbolic manifold with finite volume

Lecture 2. Soundness and completeness of propositional logic

Statistical Inference I Locally most powerful tests

Section 7.6 Double and Half Angle Formulas

= λ 1 1 e. = λ 1 =12. has the properties e 1. e 3,V(Y

Finite Field Problems: Solutions

Assalamu `alaikum wr. wb.

Mean-Variance Analysis

Finite difference method for 2-D heat equation

Chapter 6: Systems of Linear Differential. be continuous functions on the interval

Capacitors - Capacitance, Charge and Potential Difference

Forced Pendulum Numerical approach

DESIGN OF MACHINERY SOLUTION MANUAL h in h 4 0.

Solutions to the Schrodinger equation atomic orbitals. Ψ 1 s Ψ 2 s Ψ 2 px Ψ 2 py Ψ 2 pz

Srednicki Chapter 55

Solar Neutrinos: Fluxes

Pg The perimeter is P = 3x The area of a triangle is. where b is the base, h is the height. In our case b = x, then the area is

Durbin-Levinson recursive method

Other Test Constructions: Likelihood Ratio & Bayes Tests

Strain gauge and rosettes

ST5224: Advanced Statistical Theory II

2 Composition. Invertible Mappings

k A = [k, k]( )[a 1, a 2 ] = [ka 1,ka 2 ] 4For the division of two intervals of confidence in R +

( ) 2 and compare to M.

Overview. Transition Semantics. Configurations and the transition relation. Executions and computation

Parametrized Surfaces

Transcript:

Color Superconductivity: CFL and SC phases Introduction Hierarchies of effective lagrangians Effective theory at the Fermi surface (HDET) Symmetries of the superconductive phases 1

Introduction Ideas about CS back in 1975 (Collins & Perry-1975, Barrois-1977, Frautschi-1978). Only in 1998 (Alford, Rajagopal & Wilczek; ; Rapp, Schafer, Schuryak & Velkovsky) ) a real progress. The phase structure of QCD at high-density depends on the number of flavors with mass m < µ. Two most interesting cases: N f =, 3. 3 Due to asymptotic freedom quarks are almost free at high density and we expect difermion condensation in the color channel 3 *.

Consider the possible pairings at very high density 0 ψ ψ 0 α ia β jb α, β color; i, j flavor; a,b spin Antisymmetry in spin (a,b) for better use of the Fermi surface Antisymmetry in color (α, β) β for attraction Antisymmetry in flavor (i,j) for Pauli principle 3

s p s p Only possible pairings LL and RR For µ >> m u, m d, m s Favorite state for N f = 3, CFL (color-flavor locking) (Alford, Rajagopal & Wilczek 1999) 0 ψ ψ 0 =- 0 ψ ψ 0 ε ε α β α β αβc il jl ir jr ijc Symmetry breaking pattern SU(3) SU(3) SU(3) SU(3) c L R c+l+r 4

Why CFL? 0 ψ ψ 0 ε ε α β αβc il jl ijc 0 ψ ψ 0 ε ε α β αβc ir jr ijc 5

What happens going down with µ?? If µ << m s, we get 3 colors and flavors (SC) 0 ψ α ψ β 0 = ε αβ3 ε il jl ij SU(3) c SU() L SU() R SU() c SU() L SU() R However, if µ is in the intermediate region we face a situation with fermions having different Fermi surfaces (see later). Then other phases could be important (LOFF, etc.) 6

Difficulties with lattice calculations Define euclidean variables: x ix, x x 4 i i 0 E E γ γ, γ iγ 4 i i 0 E E Dirac operator with chemical potential D( µ ) = γ D +µγ µ µ 4 E E E At µ = 0 D(0) = -D(0) γ5d(0)γ 5 =-D(0) Eigenvalues of D(0) pure immaginary λ 5 If eigenvector of D(0), eigenvector with eigenvalue - λ γ λ 7

det[d(0)] = ( λ)( λ ) > 0 For µ not zero the argument does not apply and one cannot use the sampling method for evaluating the determinant. However for isospin chemical potential and two degenerate flavors one can still prove the positivity. For finite baryon density no lattice calculation available except for small µ and close to the critical line (Fodor and Katz) 8

Hierarchies of effective lagrangians Integrating out heavy degrees of freedom we have two scales. The gap and a cutoff, δ above which we integrate out. Therefore: two different effective theories, 9 L HDET and L Golds

L HDET is the effective theory of the fermions close to the Fermi surface. It corresponds to the Polchinski description. The condensation is taken into account by the introduction of a mean field corresponding to a Majorana mass. The d.o.f.. are quasi-particles, holes and gauge fields. This holds for energies up to the cutoff. L Golds describes the low energy modes (E<<( ), as Goldstone bosons, ungapped fermions and holes and massless gauge fields,, depending on the breaking scheme. 10

Effective theory at the Fermi surface (HDET) Starting point: L QCD 1 a aµν LQCD =ψidψ FµνF +µψγ0ψ, a = 1,,8 4 a a µ a λa Dµ = µ + igsaµ T, D =γ µ D, T = at asymptotic µ >> Λ QCD, (p +µγ ) ψ (p) = 0 (p +µ ) ψ (p) = α p ψ(p) 0 0 0 0 (p +µ ) = p p = E ± = µ± p 11

Introduce the projectors: P =, v v = = = p ± 1±α vf E(p) p ˆ F p p p= p p= p and decomposing: µ v F p= µ v + F F Hψ + =α ψ+ H ψ = ( µ+α ) ψ States ψ + close to the FS States ψ decouple for large µ F 1

Field-theoretical version: µ µ µ p =µ v + = v +, = ( v)v µ µ 0 v = (0,v), v = 1, = (, ) 4 d.of. 0,,v 4 dp ip x (x) e (p) 4 ψ = ψ ( π) Choosing v p = 0 Separation of light and heavy d.o.f. light d.o.f. µ δ p µ+δ, δ + δ heavyd.o.f. p µ δ, p µ +δ, δ, +δ 13

Separation of light and heavy d.o.f. heavy light light δ heavy 14

Momentum integration for the light fields 4 +δ + dp µ dvµ d dω d d = ( π) ( π) 4 π π ( π) 4 4 0 δ The Fourier decomposition becomes dv i v x ψ (x) = e µ ψ v( x) 4π µ d i x ψv(x) = e ψ v( ) π ( π) ψ () v ψ(p) ( ) For any fixed v, -dim theory v 1 v 15

In order to decouple the states corresponding to to E Momenta dv µ i v x ψ (x) = e [ ψ (x) +ψ (x)] + 4π µ d ψ ψ = ψ π ( π) i x (x) P v(x) P e ± ± ± v( ) substituting inside LQCD and using Momenta from the Fermi sphere 4 µ dv d dx ψ (x) ψ (x) = ψ v() ψv() π 4 π ( π) 16

Proof: 4 µ dv F dv ' F d d ' dx ψ (x) ψ (x) = i π 4π 4 π ( π) ( π) i( π) δ ' +µ v' µ v ψ ( ') ψ ( ) ( ) 4 4 v' v Using: 4 4 ( ) ' v' v π δ +µ µ = ( ) ( ) ' 4 v' v = π δ πδ One gets easily the result. ( ) ( ) π µ 17

4 dv d x ψ (id +µγ0) ψ ψ+ iv D ψ + +ψ (µ+ iv D) ψ + ( ψ+ id ψ + h.c.) 4π µ µ V = (1,v), V = (1, v) γ = γ γ γ = γ γ µ 0 µ µ µ (,(v )v), ψ γψ = V ψ γψ = V ψψ µ µ + + + + ψψ µ µ ψ γψ =ψγψ µ µ + + ψ γψ =ψγψ µ µ + + Eqs.. of motion: 0 iv Dψ + + iγ D ψ = 0 0 (µ + iv D) ψ + iγ D ψ + = 0 18

At the leading order in µ: iv Dψ = 0 ψ = + 0 At the same order: L D dv = ψ iv Dψ 4π + + Propagator: 1 V p +µγ = (p +µ ) p V (T( ψψ)) 0 1 (p 0 +µ ) γ p γ V 1 µ 0 0 V 1 0 0 = γ (1 α v) = P + γ ( T( ψ ψ) ) 19

Integrating out the heavy d.o.f. For the heavy d.o.f.. we can formally repeat the same steps leading to: 4 dv d x ψ (id +µγ0) ψ ψ+ iv D ψ + +ψ (µ+ iv D) ψ + ( ψ+ id ψ + h.c.) 4π Eliminating the E - fields one would get the non-local lagrangian: dv 1 = ψ ψ ψ ψ 4π µ+ iv D µν µν 1 µ ν ν µ P = g V V + V V µν LD + iv D + P + Dµ Dν + 0

Decomposing ψ =ψ +ψ h + + + one gets h h LD = LD + LD + LD dv LD = ψ+ iv Dψ+ 4π h dv h µν 1 h LD = + iv D + P + Dµ Dν + h 4 ψ ψ ψ ψ + π iv D µ+ h dv h h µν h 1 h LD = ψ+ iv Dψ+ P ψ+ Dµ Dν ψ+ 4π µ+ iv D When integrating out the heavy fields 1

Contribute only if some gluons are hard, but suppressed by asymptotic freedom This contribution from L h D gives the bare Meissner mass

HDET in the condensed phase Assume A B ψ Cψ = (A, B AB (A, B collective indices) due to the attractive interaction: G A B C D LI = εabε V ab ABCDψaψbψa ψ b 4 V = V, V = V = V * ABCD CDAB ABCD BACD ABDC Decompose 3

L I = L + cond G CD* AT B G Lcond = VABCDΓ ψ Cψ VABCDΓ 4 4 G Lint = VABCD ψ ψ Γ ψ ψ 4 We define L int Cψ AB C D* ( AT C B AB )( C C D* +Γ CD* ) G G = V Γ, = V Γ CD * * CD* AB CDAB AB CDAB 1 1 L = ψ Cψ ψ Cψ * AT B A B* cond AB AB ψ and neglect L int. Therefore 4

dv 1 L = ψ iv Dψ +ψ iv Dψ + ψ Cψ ψ Cψ π A B A B * AT B A B D + + AB + AB + 4 AB ψ (x) ψ ( ± v,x) ± + Nambu-Gor kov basis L ψ A A 1 + χ = A* Cψ dv iv D = χ χ π A AB AB B D * 4 AB iv D AB S( ) 1 V = (V )(V ) V (, = 0) 5

From the definition: G = V ψ C ψ * C D* AB ABCD one derives the gap equation (e.g. via functional formalism) * dv µ d * 1 AB = igv ABCD CE 4 ππ ( π) D ED 1 1 D (V )(V ) AB = AB 6

Four-fermi interaction one-gluon exchange inspired Fierz using: L I 3 G 16 a µ a = ψγµ λ ψψγ λ ψ 8 a a ( λ ) αβ( λ ) δγ = (3 δαγδβδ δαβδγδ) a= 1 3 µ ( σµ ) ab ( σ ) dc = εac εbd µ µ σ = (1, σ), σ = (1, σ) G α β γ δ LI = V( αi)( βj)( γk)( δ) ψiψψ j k ψ 4 V = (3 δ δ δ δ ) δ δ ( αi)( βj)( γk)( δ) αδ βγ αγ βδ ik j 7

In the SC case = =ε ε ( αi)( βj) αβ3 ij dv d 4iG 4 π π ( π ) µ 0 δ G µ = ρ d ξ, ρ= 4 0 ξ + π 4 pairing fermions 8

G determined at T = 0. 0 M,, constituent mass ~ 400 MeV Λ 3 dp 1 1= 8G ( π ) p + M 0 3 with Λ=µ+δ For µ= 400 500 MeV, Λ= 800 MeV, M = 400 MeV = 33 88 MeV SC Similar values for CFL. 9

Gap equation in QCD 3 1 g cos θ (p 0) = dq 0 d(cos θ ) + 1π 1 cos θ+ G /( µ ) 1 1 + cos θ (q ) + 1 cosθ+ F/( µ ) q + (q ) 0 0 0 30

Hard-loop approximation F= m D electric G 5/ 4 5 b = 56π g Nf π q0 = md 4 q magnetic q q 0 µ (p ) = dq log 0 g µ m N π D = f For small momenta magnetic gluons are unscreened and dominate giving a further logarithmic divergence g b (q 0) 0 0 18 π p0 q 0 q 0 + (q 0) 31

Results: g b (p 0) 0sin log 3 π p 0 = bµ e 0 3π g g 1 (log( δ/ )) δe c c/g 5 µ>10 GeV from the double log To be trusted only for but, if extrapolated at 400-500 MeV,, gives values for the gap similar to the ones found using a 4-fermi interaction. However condensation arises at asymptotic values of µ. 3

Symmetries of superconducting phases Consider again the 3 flavors, u,d,s and the group theoretical structure of the two difermion condensate: α ia ψ ψ β jb [(3,3 ) (3,3 )] = (3,3 ) (6,6 ) * * c L(R) c L(R) S c L(R) c L(R) 33

implying in general α β αβi α β β α il jl iji 6 i j i j ψ ψ = ε ε + ( δ δ +δ δ ) = α β β α α β β α i j i j 6 i j i j = ( δ δ δδ ) + ( δ δ +δδ ) = α β β α 6 i j 6 i j = ( + ) δ δ + ( ) δ δ In NJL case with cutoff 800 MeV, constituent mass 400 MeV and µ = 400 MeV = 85.3MeV, = 1.3MeV 6 34

Original symmetry: GQCD = SU(3) c SU(3) L SU(3) R U(1) B U(1) A broken to G = SU(3) Z Z CFL c+ L+ R anomalous anomalous # Goldstones 3 8+ 1+ 1 8= 8+ 8+ 1+ 1= 17+ 1 massive 8 give mass to the gluons and 8+1 are true massless Goldstone bosons 35

Notice: Breaking of U(1) B makes the CFL phase superfluid The CFL condensate is not gauge invariant, but consider X =ε ε ( ψ ψ ), Y =ε ε ( ψ ψ ) k ijk α β k ijk α β γ αβγ il jl γ αβγ ir jr Σ = (Y X) = (Y ) X i i j * i j j α α α Σ is gauge invariant and breaks the global part of G QCD. Also det(x), det(y) break U(1) U(1) Z Z break B A 36

U(1) is broken by the anomaly but induced by a 6-6 A fermion operator irrelevant at the Fermi surface. Its contribution is parametrically small and we expect a very light NGB (massless at infinite chemical potential) Spectrum of the CFL phase Choose the basis: 1 ψ = λ ψ 9 α α i ( A) i A= 1 A λ A = 1,,8 Gell Mann matrices A λ 9 =λ 0 = 1 3 [ ] Tr λ λ = δ A B AB 37

Inverting: 1 1 [ ] A i α ψ = ( λa) αψ i = Tr λaψ αi 1 = λ λ ε ε = ε ( ) A I B I ψψ A B i j αβi T ( A) α( B) β iji Tr λελ I I ε ε = We get T Ig I g Tr[g] A B ψψ quasi-fermions ( ε I) αβ =ε αβ I for any 3x3 matrix g = δ A1,,8 = = A A AB 9 ε (p) = (v ) + A A = A = 9 = A 38

gluons Expected m g F g NG coupling constant but wave function renormalization effects important (see later) NG bosons Acquire mass through quark masses except for the one related to the breaking of U(1) B 39

NG boson masses quadratic in m q since the approximate invariance (Z ) L (Z ) R: ψl(r) ψl(r) and quark mass term: ψ Mψ + L R h.c. M M Notice: anomaly breaks (Z ) L (Z ) R through instantons,, producing a chiral condensate (6 fermions -> > ), but of order (Λ QCD /µ) 8 40

In-medium electric charge D a µ ψ= µ ψ igµ Taψ iψqa µ The condensate breaks U(1) em but leaves invariant a combination of Q and T 8. CFL vacuum: Define: SU(3) c X = Y =δ i i i α α α 1 1 QSU(3) T c 8 = diag,, + = Q 3 3 3 3 Q = Q 1 1 Q= Q 1 1 Q QX XQ Q δ δ Q = 0 αβ βi αj ji leaves invariant the ground state 41

Eigs(Q) = 0, ± 1 Integers as in the Han-Nambu model A = A cosθ G sinθ g 8 µ µ µ µ = A sin θ+ G cos θ µ µ new interaction: rotated fields g g T 1+ ea 1 Q eqa + ggt 8 s µ 8 µ µ s µ e gs tan θ=, e = ecos θ, gs = 3 g cosθ s 3 ( ) ( T = cos θ Q 1+ sin θ) 1 Q 4

The rotated photon remains massless, whereas the rotated gluons acquires a mass through the Meissner effect A piece of CFL material for massless quarks would respond to an em field only through NGB: bosonic metal For quarks with equal masses, no light modes: transparent insulator For different masses one needs non zero density of electrons or a kaon condensate leading to massless excitations 43

In the SC case, new Q and B are conserved 1 1 1 Q = Q 1 1 T 8 =, 1 1 (1,, ) 3 3 3 6 1 1 1 1 1 B = B T 8 =,,,, = (0,0,1) 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 u α, α= 1, d α, α= 1, u d 3 3 Q B 1/ 0-1/ 0 1 1 0 1 44

Spectrum of the SC phase Remember =ε ε ( αi)( βj) αβ3 ij No Goldstone bosons α ψi α= 1, gapped ψ ungapped 3 i SU(3) c SU() 8 3 = 5 massive gluons c (equal gap) Light modes: 3 ψ i + 3gluons(M = 0) 45

+1 flavors µ m, µ m,m It could happen s u d µ m,m m,m,m u d s <µ< m u d s Phase transition expected E =µ= p + M p = µ M F F F M > M 1 The radius of the Fermi sphere decrases with the mass 46

Simple model: pf = µ m 1 s, pf =µ pf 1 3 pf 3 Ω = dp dp unpair p m p ( π) + µ + ( π) µ ( ) ( ) s 3 3 0 0 pf comm p dp ( ) dp µ Ω pair = p + ms µ + ( p µ ) ( π) ( π) 4π 3 Fcomm 3 3 3 0 0 Ω pair = 0 p =µ F ms µ comm pf 4 comm 1 Ωpair Ωunpair s µ 16π ( m 4 4 ) condensation energy Condensation if: m µ> s 47

Notice that the transition must be first order because for being in the pairing phase > m s 0 µ (Minimal value of the gap to get condensation) 48

Effective lagrangians Effective lagrangian for the CFL phase Effective lagrangian for the SC phase 49

Effective lagrangian for the CFL phase NG fields as the phases of the condensates in the (3,3) representation k ijk α β * k ijk α β * γ =εαβγε ψilψ jl γ =εαβγε ψirψjr X, Y Quarks and X, Y transform as ψ e g ψ g, ψ e g ψ g i( α+β) T i( α β) T L c L L R c R R iα iβ c c L,R L,R B A g SU(3), g SU(3), e U(1), e U(1) X g Xg e, Y g Yg e T i( α+β ) T i( α β ) c L c R 50

Since X, Y U(3) The number of NG fields is #X + #Y = (1+ 8) + (1+ 8) = 18 8 of these fields give mass to the gluons. There are only 10 physical NG bosons corresponding to the breaking of the global symmetry (we consider also the NGB associated to U(1) A ) SU(3) L SU(3) R U(1) V U(1) A SU(3) L+ R Z Z 51

Better use fields belonging to SU(3). Define and d X = X = det(x) i( Xˆ e = transforming as e ϕ+θ) 6i( ϕ+θ) Xˆ g Xˆ d Y T c g L ϕ ϕ α = Y = i( ϕ θ) Ŷe det(y) = Ŷ g e Ŷ T c g R θ θ β 6i( ϕ θ) The breaking of the global symmetry can be described by the gauge invariant order parameters ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ i (Y j )*X i Σ= Y + X, d, d j α α X Y Σ = 5

Σ, d X, d Y are 10 fields describing the physical NG bosons. Also Σ T R g L g Σ shows that Σ T transforms as the usual chiral field. Consider the currents: ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ µ µ µ µ µ µ JX = XD X = X( X + X g ) = X X + g µ ˆ µ ˆ ˆ µ ˆ ˆ µ ˆ µ ˆ µ JY = YD Y = Y( Y + Y g ) = Y Y + g µ µ a g = igsgat J g J g µ µ X,Y c X,Y c 53

Most general lagrangian up to two derivatives invariant under G, the space rotation group O(3) and Parity (R.C. & Gatto 1999) P: (X Y,J J, ϕ ϕ, θ θ) X F ( ) ( ) T 0 0 FT 0 0 1 1 L= Tr JX J Y α T Tr JX + J Y + ( ϕ 0 ) + ( θ 0 ) + 4 4 F ( ) ( ) S FS 0 0 v ϕ v θ + Tr JX J Y +α S Tr JX + J Y ϕ θ 4 4 F ( ) ( ) T FT L= Tr Xˆ 0X ˆ Yˆ 0Y ˆ αt Tr Xˆ 0X ˆ + Yˆ 0Y ˆ + g 0 + 4 4 F ( ) ( ) S ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ FS ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ Tr X X Y Y S Tr + +α X X + Y Y + g + 4 4 1 1 v ϕ v θ + ( 0ϕ ) + ( 0θ) ϕ θ 54 Y

Using SU(3) c gauge invariance we can choose: ˆ = ˆ = X Y e i Π T /F T Expanding at the second order in the fields ( a v L ) 0Π + ( 0ϕ ) + ( 0θ) Π ϕ θ F v 1 1 1 v a ϕ vθ S = FT Gluons acquire Debye and Meissner masses (not the rest masses, see later) m =α gf, m =α gf =α vgf D T s T s S s S S s T a a 55

Low energy theory supposed to be valid at energies << gap. Since we will see that gluons have masses of order they can be decoupled F ( ) ( ) T FT L= Tr Xˆ 0X ˆ Yˆ 0Y ˆ αt Tr Xˆ 0X ˆ + Yˆ 0Y ˆ + g 0 + 4 4 F ( ) ( ) S ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ FS ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ Tr X X Y Y S Tr + +α X X + Y Y + g + 4 4 1 1 v ϕ v θ + ( 0ϕ ) + ( 0θ) ϕ θ 1 g X ˆ X ˆ Y ˆ Y ˆ µ = µ + µ ( ) 56

we get the gauge invariant result: ~ χ-lagrangian F ( ) T + + LNGB = Tr t t v Tr 4 Σ Σ Σ Σ 1 1 ϕ ϕ θ θ ( ) ( ( ) t ) v ϕ ( t ) v θ Σ = YX ˆ + ˆ 57