2000 11 : ; ; ( : 100007) F114. 3 A 1006-9550 (2000) 11-0051 - 06 : ( ) (2)?? (3)? 19 70 20 : 60 60 60 : (1) 20 60 (bureaucratic authoritarianism) B - A 51
1973 9 ( 1998 10 16 2000 3 ) ( ) : : : ( 80 ) 1972 : 19641985 ; tion Oxford University Press 1997 p. 57. Oxford University Press 1992 pp. 180181. 1996 70 1996 167 52 Guillermo A. O Donnell : Modernization and B ureaucratic - A u2 thoritarianism : St udies in South A merican Politics Institute of Interna2 tional Studies University of California Press 1973. T. Skidmore and P. Smith : Modern L atin A merica fourth edi2 T. Skidmore and P. Smith : Modern L atin A merica third edition T. E. : ( ) 1996 166 T. E. : ( ) 168 T. E. : ( )
2000 11 60 ( Economic Planning Board ) 20 % : ( ) : 7??? (authoritarian) ( semi - aut horitari2 an) 70 80 (controlled) 1991 ( ) ( ) ( ) : (soft authori2 tarianism) (Asian - Style Democracy) : 114 (community) 1 91 Park Chung - Hee : To B uild A Nation Acropolis Books 1971 pp. 102107. : 1995 Tun - jen Cheng Stephan Haggard and David Kang : Instit u2 tions Economic Policy and Growth in the Republic of Korea and Taiw an Province of China UNCTAD 1996 p. 4. Yung - Myung Kim : Asian - Style Democracy : A Critique from East Asia Challenge No. 34 1998. : 1997 (political regimes ) ( regimes) ( methods) (J. Benson Durham :Economic Growth and Political Regimes Journal of E2 conomic Grow th March 1999 p. 81. ) Larry Diamond and Marc Plattner : The Global Resur2 gence of Democracy The Johns Hopkins University Press 1993. Seymour Martin Lipset :Some Social Requisites of Democracy : Economic Development and Political Legitimacy The A merican Political Science Review March 1959. 53
: ( ) ( ) ( ) : (1) ; (2) ; (3) 20 90 4 4 2 P 2 W2 P (power) (participation) 2 W ( wealth) (welfare) 4 :? (1) ; (2)? tional Bureau of Economic Research 1989. Perspective G. 361363 267 54 1955 : Jeffrey D. Sachs : Social Conf lict and Populist Policies in L atin A merica International Center f or Economic Growth Cambridge MA :Na2 J. Kurth :Industrial Change and Political Change : A European in David Collier : The New A uthoritarianism i n L ati n A meri2 ca Princeton University Press 1979. : 1996 5 81 : : ( ) 1993 Yung - Myung Kim : Asian - Style Democracy : A Critique from East Asia Challenge No. 34 1998. : ( ) 1997
2000 11 (strong state) (weak state) : ( ) (the centralized nature) 60 ( ) 60 %70 2/ 3 80 ( ) (developmentalist state) gλυ : Yung - Chul Park :Korea : (1) (2) (3) 1459. ( ) tions Pantheon 1968. gλυ W. : 1990 516 in R. Dornbusch and F. L. C. H. Helmers (eds. ) : The Open Economy : Tools f or Policymakers in Develop2 ing Count ries Oxford University Press 1988 p. 404. Yung - Chul Park :Korea in R. Dornbusch and F. L. C. H. Helmers (eds. ) : The Open Economy : Tools f or Policymakers in Develop2 ing Count ries Oxford University Press 1988 p. 340. James L. Dietz :Overcoming Underdevelopment : What Has Been Learned from the East Asian and Latin American Experiences? in James L. Dietz (ed. ) : L atin A mericas Economic Development : Conf ronting Crisis Lynne Rienner Publisher 1995 p. 192 ; M. Castells :Four Asian Tigers with a Dragon Head : A Comparative Analysis of the State Economy and Society in the Asian Pacific Rim in R. Henderson and J. Applebaum (eds. ) : State and Development i n the Asian Pacif ic Ri m Sage Publica2 tions 1992. Chalmers Johnson :The Interplay of State Social Class and World System in East Asian Development in Frederic C. Deyo (ed. ) : The Political Economy of the New Asian Indust rialism Cornell University Press 1987. David Felix :Import Substitution and Large Industrialization : Latin America and Asia Compared World Development No. 9 1989 p. Ted C. Lewellen :Dependency and Development : An Introduction to the Third World Bergin & Garvey 1995 p. 135. G. Myrdal : Asian Drama : A n Inquiry into the Poverty of Na2 Leroy Jones and Sakong Il : Government B usiness and En2 t repreneurship in Economic Development : The Korean Case Harvard Uni2 versity Press 1980. Economist August 26 1995 p. 19. 55
: 1995 8 ( ) ( ) 66 1929 70 80 ( PRONASOL) 1994 : 70 60 1994 : 1997 1 101 : [ :2000-06 - 15 ] [ :2000-07 - 15 ] 56 [ : ] Esther Wilson Hannon :The Politics of Mexican Free Trade and the North American Free Trade Agreement in Lowell S. Gustafson : Eco2 nomic Development under Democratic Regi mes : Neoliberalism in Latin America Praeger 1994 pp. 162163. Economist August 26 1995 p. 12. : : 1996 : ( ) 1990 : : : : 1997 1 101 1929 1946 1