nawili III sisxlis samartlis saqmeebi PART III CRIMINAL CASES

nawili III sisxlis samartlis saqmeebi PART III CRIMINAL CASES Sesavali Introduction................................................... 75 saqartvelos saerto sasamartloebsi sisxlis samartlis saqmeta ganxilvis dinamika Dynamic of hearing criminal cases at the Common Courts of Georgia................... 79 sisxlis samartlis saqmeta mozraobis dinamika danasaulis saxeebis mixedvit Dynamic of movement of criminal cases according to the types of crime................. 82 sisxlis samartlis saqmeebis mozraoba I instanciis sasamartloebis mixedvit Movement of criminal cases according to the Courts of First Instance.................. 85 sisxlis samartlis saqmeta saapelacio wesit gasacivreba Appeal of criminal cases.............................................88 sisxlis samartlis saqmeta intensivobis macvenebeli mosaxleobis 10000 kacze gaangarisebit Intensity index of criminal cases according to the calculation of 10000 citizens............. 90 Semosuli da ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli sisxlis samartlis saqmeebis dinamika Dynamic of filed and heard acquittal rendered judgments of criminal cases................ 91 Semosuli da ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli sisxlis samartlis saqmeta dinamika zogierti saxis danasaulis mixedvit Dynamic of filed and heard criminal cases by delivering judgments according to the other types of crime............................................ 92 msjavrdebulta raodenobis dinamika danasaulis saxeebis mixedvit Dynamic of quantity of sentenced minors according to the types of crime................. 104 nasamartlobis dinamika Dynamic of criminal record.......................................... 107 msjavrdebulta raodenoba sasjelis RonisZiebebis mixedvit Number of sentenced according to panel measures............................. 108 sasjelis RonisZiebaTa dinamika Dynamic of panel measures........................................... 109 Tavisuflebis arkvetis vadebis dinamika Dynamic for the terms of deprivation of liberty............................... 113 msjavrdebulta raodenoba sqesis, asakis, ganatlebis, saqmianobisa da warsuli nasamartlobis mixedvit Ssentenced composed according to age, gender, education, activity and past criminal record...... 114 msjavrdebulta Semadgenloba saqmianobis mixedvit Sentenced according to activity........................................ 116 msjavrdebulta Semadgenloba asakis mixedvit Staff of sentenced according to age...................................... 117 arasrulwlovan msjavrdebulta raodenobis dinamika danasaulis saxeebis mixedvit Dynamic of quantity of sentenced according to the types of crime..................... 118 arasrulwlovan msjavrdebulta ganawileba sqesis, asakisa da sasjelis RonisZiebebis mixedvit Sentenced minors distribution according to gender, age and panel measures............... 119

I instanciis sasamartlos mier saproceso SeTanxmebiT ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard on the ground of procedural agreement by the courts of first isnstance........... 120 saproceso SeTanxmebiT gamotanili ganacenebis dinamika Dynamic of judgemnts made on the ground of procedural agreement................... 120 I instanciis sasamartloebis mier ganxiluli sisxlis samartlis sxva saqmeebi Other criminal cases heard at the courts of first instance........................... 121 I instanciis sasamartloebis mier arkvetis RonisZiebebis Sefardeba On sentencing the measure of restriction by the courts of first instance.................... 122 I instanciis sasamartloebis mier arkvetis RonisZiebebis Sefardebis dinamika Dynamic of sentencing the measures of constraint by the cours of first instance.............. 123 arkvetis RonisZiebebis Sefardeba 2010 wlis Tveebis mixedvit On sentencing the preventive measures according to the months of 2008................. 124 arkvetis RonisZiebebis struqtura Structure of preventive measures........................................ 124 arkvetis RonisZiebebis Sefardebaze ganxiluli Suamdgomlobebis dinamika Dynamic of heard motions on sentencing the measures of restriction................... 125 I instanciis sasamartloebis mier ganxiluli arkvetis RonisZiebebze sagamoziebo organoebisa da advokatta mier Semotanili Suamdgomlobebi Motions heard by the courts of first instance filed by the investigation organs and attorneys.................................................... 126 saapelacio da kerzo sacivrebit Semosul sisxlis samartlis saqmeebze ganacenebis gadasinjvis Sedegebi Results of examination of judgments filed on criminal cases by appellate and private claims...... 128 sisxlis samartlis saqmeebze saapelacio sacivrebis mozraoba Movement of appellate claims on criminal cases.............................. 130 sisxlis samartlis saqmeebze kerzo saapelacio sacivrebis mozraoba Movement of private appellate claims on criminal cases........................... 131 saapelacio sacivrebis ganxilvis Sedegebi Results of hearing of appeals.......................................... 132 saapelacio sasamartloebsi sisxlis samartlis saqmeebze saapelacio sacivrebis ganxilvis Sedegebi prokuroris motxovnis mixedvit Results of appeals heard by the Chamber of Criminal Cases of Appellate Courts according to prosecutors request................................... 133 sisxlis samartlis saqmeebis sakasacio wesit gasacivrebis dinamika Dynamic of criminal cases filed by the rule of cassation........................... 134 uzenaesi sasamartlos sisxlis samartlis saqmeta palatasi sakasacio sacivrebis dasasvebobis Semowmeba Review of cassation claims for admissibility at the Chamber of Criminal Cases of the Supreme Court.................................................. 134 sisxlis samartlis saqmeebze sakasacio sacivrebis ganxilvis Sedegebi Results of hearing of cassation claims on criminal cases........................... 135 uzenaesi sasamartlos sisxlis samartlis saqmeta palatasi sakasacio sacivrebis ganxilvis Sedegebi prokuroris motxovnis mixedvit Results of hearing of cassation claims at the Chamber of Criminal Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia according to the prosecutors request.................. 136 sisxlis samartlis saqmeebze ganacenta stabilurobis macvenebeli saapelacio sasamartloebis mixedvit Stability index of judgments on criminal cases according to the Courts of Appeal............ 137

nawili III sisxlis samartlis saqmeebi Sesavali 2014 wels, 2013 weltan SedarebiT, I instanciis sasamartloebsi Semosuli sisxlis samartlis saqmeta raodenoba gaizarda 1459 saqmit, anu 9,8-iT da Seadgina 16335 saqme, xolo sul ganxilul saqmeta raodenoba gaizarda 1596 saqmit, anu 11,6-iT da Seadgina 15390 saqme. 12,9-iT, anu 13314 saqmidan 15026 saqmemde gaizarda ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebis raodenoba. 2014 wels, 2013 weltan SedarebiT, saproceso SeTanxmebiT Semosuli saqmeebis raodenoba Semcirda 22,5-iT, xolo saproceso SeTanxmebis safuzvelze ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi - 11,7- it. saproceso SeTanxmebis safuzvelze ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebis xvedriti wili sul ganacenis gamotanit ganxilul saqmeebsi gasuli wlis 89,1-dan Semcirda 2014 wlis 69,7-mde. 2014 wels msjavrdebuli 16776 piridan: _ Tavisuflebis arkveta Seefarda 5949 pirs (sul msjavrdebulta 35,5, 2013 wels 28,1); _ pirobiti msjavri - 7581 pirs (Sesabamisad, 45,2 da 57,0); _ jarima - 2722 pirs (16,2 da 12,1); _ sazogadoebisatvis sasargeblo Sroma 515 pirs (3,1 da 1,8). 2014 wels gamamartlebeli ganaceni gamotanilia 124 piris mimart, nawilobriv gamamartlebeli 144 piris mimart, saqme Sewyda 146 piris mimart. 2014 wels, 2013 weltan SedarebiT 3,9-iT gaizarda sagamoziebo organoebidan I instanciis sasamartloebsi arkvetis RonisZiebis Sefardebaze Semosuli Suamdgomlobebis raodenoba. giraos xvedritma wilma sul Sefardebul armkvet RonisZiebebSi Seadgina 60,2 (2013 wels 66,3). 2014 wels, 2013 weltan SedarebiT saapelacio sasamartloebsi Semosuli sacivrebis raodenoba gaizarda 107-iT, ganxiluli saqmeebi 102-iT. 2014 wels sul ganxilulia 1327 saapelacio sacivari (1,1-jer meti, vidre 2013 wels) 1583 piris mimart (1,2-jer meti). 75

2014 wels saapelacio sasamartloebis mier msjavrdebulta sasargeblod gamotanili ganacenebis (gancinebebis) xvedritma wilma Seadgina 17,7. 2013 weltan SedarebiT gaizarda (53,6-dan 74,1-mde) ucvlelad datovebuli ganacenebis xvedriti wili, Sesabamisad Semcirda gauqmebuli da Secvlili ganacenebis xvedriti wili (46,4-dan 25,9- mde). 2014 wels, 2013 weltan SedarebiT sakasacio instanciasi Semosuli sakasacio da kerzo (amnistiis saqmeebis garese) sacivrebis raodenoba gaizarda 1,4-jer, xolo ganxiluli sacivrebis raodenoba - 1,4-jer. ucvlelad datovebuli ganacenebis (gancinebebis) xvedriti wili 2013 wlis 80,0-dan gaizarda 2014 wlis 92,0-mde. 76

2014 weli 2013 weli mateba (kleba) # saqme piri saqme piri saqme piri saqme piri case person case person case person case person 1 2 3 2 3 6 7 8 9 1. I instancia I INSTANCE 1.1. ganxilulia Number of cases heard mat Soris: AAmong them : ganacenis gamotanit By delivering judgment: m.s. saproceso SeTanxmebiT Among them by plea bargaining 15390 15026 10476 69.7 17391 16903 11805 69.8 13794 13314 11858 89.1 15901 15240 13533 88.8 1596 1712-1382 1490 1663-1728 11.6 12.9-11.7 9.4 10.9-12.8 1.2. Sewyda saqartvelos saerto sasamartloebsi sisxlis samartlis saqmeta ganxilvis dinamika are terminated dabrunda damatebit ZiebaSi were returned to additional investigation sul ganxiluli saqmeebidan ganxilulia arsebitad Out of heard cases are heard in essence DYNAMIC OF CRIMINAL CASES HEARD AT THE COMMON COURTS OF GEORGIA 105 259 4655 mat Soris: AAmong them : gamotanilia gamamartlebeli ganaceni Verdict of not guilty rendered 76 1.6 124 2.4 37 2.0 70 3.2 39 54 gamotanilia nawilobriv gamamartlebeli ganaceni Verdict of not guilty rendered partially 90 1.9 144 2.7 42 2.3 50 2.3 48 94 Sewyda are terminated 2.3 146 2.8 357 19.7 499 22.6-252 -353 146 342 357 123 499 162-252 -353-70.6 136 5244 1813 2206 2842 180 1,1-jer meti 3038 156.8 105.4 1,1-jer meti -70.7 1,1-jer meti 137.7 77.1 1,6-jer meti 105-70.6-70.7 77

1 2 3 2 3 6 7 8 9 1.3. monacemebi nasamartlobis Sesaxeb Data on Criminal Record msjavrdebulia sentenced mat Soris: Tavisuflebis arkveta deprivation of liberty 14947 5143 16776 5949 13275 3701 15166 4264 1672 1442 1610 1685 12.6 39.0 10.6 39.5 34.4 35.5 27.9 28.1 pirobiti msjavri conditional sentence 6820 45.6 7581 45.2 7570 57.0 8639 57.0-750 jarima fine 2493 16.7 2722 16.2 1656 12.5 1831 12.1 837 sazogadoebisatvis sasargeblo Sroma Socially useful labor 484 3.2 515 3.1 237 1.8 277 1.8 2. saapelacio instancia APPELLATE INSTANCE 2.1. ganxilulia saapelacio sacivrit Cases heard by appellate claims mat Soris: Among them : - gauqmda gamamtyunebeli ganaceni da gamotanilia gamamartlebeli ganaceni - acquittal verdict was nullified and approved verdict of guilty - Sewyda - were terminated - Seumsubuqda sasjeli - punishment was facilitated sul Total 1327 1583 21 213 17.9 17.6 31.7 32.7 3 237 24 3 252 279 637 11 4 187 202 736 14 4 690 10-1 35 891 247 238 847 10-1 38 50.5 104.2 108.3 90.9 71.4-25.0 17.3 gagrzeleba continued 48.7 85.9 115.1-25.0 223 26 29 13.9 13.0 241-1058 -9.9-12.2 15.8 78

gagrzeleba continued 1 2 3 2 3 6 7 8 9 sul gauqmda da Seicvala were cancelled and changed 358 27.0 417 26.3 366 57.5 422 57.3-8 -5-2.2-1.2 stabiluria 2,5-jer 2,7-jer 969 1166 271 314 698 852 are stable meti meti 73.0 73.7 42.5 42.7 2.2. ganxilulia saqme kerzo saapelacio sacivrit Cases heard by private appellate claims 45 46 40 43 5 3 12.5 7.0 3. sakasacio instancia 3.1. CASSATION INSTANCE ganxilulia sakasacio sacivrit (amnistiis saqmeebis garese) 2,5-jer 2,7-jer 374 463 107 125 267 338 Number of cases heard by the cassation instance (without meti meti amnesty cases) mat Soris: AAmong them : - gauqmda gamamtyunebeli ganaceni da gamotanilia gamamartlebeli ganaceni - acquittal verdict was nullified and approved verdict of guilty - Seicvala kvalifikacia da sasjeli - was changed qualification and punishment 3 8 3 11 2 5 2 5 3 6 60.0 120.0 - Seicvala sasjeli - was changed the punishment 10 11 9 12 1-1 11.1-8.3 sul Total 21 25 16 19 5 6 31.3 31.6 5.6 5.4 15.0 15.2 sul gauqmda da Seicvala were cancelled and changed 31 37 20 25 11 12 55.0 48.0 8.3 8.0 18.7 20.0 stabiluria 2,9-jer 3,3-jer 343 426 87 100 256 326 are stable meti meti 91.7 92.0 81.3 80.0 3.2. ganxilulia saqme kerzo sakasacio sacivrit Case heard by private cassation claim 37 37 1959 1959-1922 -1922-98.1-98.1 79

Semovida Filed damtavrda Completed m.s.ganacenis gamotanit Among them by delivering the verdict Semovida Filed damtavrda Completed m.s.ganacenis gamotanit Among them by delivering the verdict Semovida Filed damtavrda Completed m.s.ganacenis gamotanit Among them by delivering the verdict Semovida Filed damtavrda Completed m.s.ganacenis gamotanit Among them by delivering the verdict Semovida Filed damtavrda Completed m.s.ganacenis gamotanit Among them by delivering the verdict Semovida Filed damtavrda Completed m.s.ganacenis gamotanit Among them by delivering the verdict sisxlis samartlis saqmeta mozraobis dinamika danasaulis saxeebis mixedvit DYNAMIC OF MOVEMENT OF CRIMINAL CASES ACCORDING TO THE TYPES OF CRIME 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 danasaulis saxeebi Types of Crime 1 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 20 21 22 20 21 22 20 sul 15483 15911 15592 15766 16909 16641 14264 14584 14539 9133 9120 8992 14876 13794 13314 16335 15390 15026 Total mat Soris: Among them: danasauli adamianis winaarmdeg 979 992 896 927 1096 981 1003 1056 1049 906 887 874 1013 949 903 1512 1403 1348 Crimes against people ganzrax mkvleloba 280 275 273 228 294 291 251 260 258 220 213 211 188 180 175 137 143 141 Intentional homicide ganzrax mkvleloba damamzimebel garemoebasi ganzrax mkvleloba uecari, Zlieri sulieri arelvebis mdgomareobasi mkvleloba aucilebeli mogeriebis farglebis gadacilebit 109 105 102 84 114 111 57 82 81 33 31 30 31 28 26 28 32 31 1 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 3 3 3 Intentional homicide in aggravating circumstances Intentional homicide in sudden heat of passion Homicide by exceeding the limits of necessary self-defense sicocxlis mospoba gaufrtxileblobit 10 10 10 13 13 13 9 10 10 12 12 12 5 4 3 12 8 8 Manslaughter through negligence janmrtelobis ganzrax mzime dazianeba 95 102 98 119 140 138 89 88 88 64 67 66 121 105 104 176 166 165 janmrtelobis ganzrax naklebad mzime dazianeba janmrtelobis dazianeba sasikvdilo SedegiT 101 87 76 106 113 98 82 85 84 60 59 58 86 87 79 90 80 75 Inflicting intentional serious damage to health Inflicting less serious intentional damage to health Damage to health resulted in death cema Zaladoba 93 90 28 123 135 51 260 261 260 322 312 307 397 377 358 865 786 744 Beating Torture gaupatiureba 34 41 38 34 37 37 22 25 25 31 31 31 26 28 25 12 15 15 Rape sqesobrivi Tavisuflebisa da xelseuxeblobis winaarmdeg mimartuli sxva danasauli 57 53 52 40 46 45 54 55 55 34 35 35 36 33 33 50 45 44 Other crimes directed at sexual liberty and integrity Tavisuflebis ukanono arkveta 70 79 78 54 62 62 56 60 60 29 33 33 34 29 29 33 30 30 Illegal deprivation of liberty mzevlad xelsi Cagdeba sxva danasauli adamianis uflebebisa da Tavisuflebis winaarmdeg 127 146 137 124 140 133 123 130 128 101 94 91 89 78 71 108 97 94 Taking hostages Other crime against human rights and freedom 80

gagrzeleba continued 1 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 20 21 22 20 21 22 20 ekonomikuri danasauli 4472 4677 4583 5041 5420 5353 5530 5665 5641 3641 3714 3656 3875 3670 3539 4452 4051 3949 Economic crimes qurdoba 2571 2753 2703 2836 3061 3026 3182 3231 3218 2092 2080 2058 2789 2616 2569 2994 2845 2782 Theft Zarcva 350 394 386 287 338 334 255 276 276 167 165 164 262 237 235 270 250 249 Plundering yacaroba 266 307 300 182 250 241 129 155 151 94 89 84 159 159 155 131 119 119 Robbery TaRliToba 653 635 621 863 896 883 969 1002 999 775 812 801 247 292 237 386 264 249 Fraud gamozalva 30 31 31 32 32 32 36 39 39 23 27 27 18 14 13 19 16 16 Extortion mitviseba an gaflangva 199 197 196 200 227 226 240 241 240 137 158 155 120 88 84 201 147 144 Misappropriation or embezzlement avtomobilis an... martlsawinaarmdego daufleba misakutrebis miznis garese 1 1 3 2 falsifikacia 18 17 17 22 23 23 5 7 7 3 3 3 15 14 13 Falsification aqcizuri saqonlis aqcizuri markis garese gamosveba, Senaxva, realizacia an gadazidva yalbi fulis an fasiani qaraldis damzadeba an gasareba 11 11 11 50 45 45 36 40 40 18 18 18 24 18 18 26 28 28 20 16 16 22 30 29 11 10 10 8 10 10 10 7 6 14 13 13 Taking possession of a motor car or other motor vehicle unlawfully without intent to misappropriate Production, storing, sale or carriage of excise goods subject to marking without an excise mark Making or realization of false money or securities sabajo wesis darrveva 52 49 49 77 69 69 95 97 97 38 43 43 65 60 60 64 67 64 Violation of customs rule gadasaxadisatvis Tavis arideba 21 13 11 77 40 40 97 98 97 36 45 39 13 16 13 32 14 13 Tax avoidance sxva ekonomikuri danasauli 281 253 241 393 406 403 475 469 467 250 264 254 168 163 149 300 274 259 Other economic crimes danasauli sazogadoebrivi usisroebisa da wesrigis winaarmdeg * 7675 7822 7745 6487 7005 6966 4978 5075 5069 3150 3074 3046 8315 7547 7336 8176 7946 7821 qurduli samyaros wevroba 10 9 9 11 7 7 8 10 10 2 3 3 14 4 3 10 17 17 banditizmi 1 1 1 2 2 Banditism cecxlsasroli iararis... martlsawinaarmdego SeZena, Senaxva, tareba, damzadeba, gadazidva an gasareba iararis... martlsawinaarmdego daufleba misakutrebis miznit an gamozalva 695 722 716 685 719 714 653 670 669 340 347 338 545 540 515 539 509 501 6 7 7 8 7 7 4 6 6 3 4 4 5 5 5 3 2 2 xulignoba 395 432 422 364 408 403 400 398 397 256 250 244 121 138 115 102 96 91 Hooliganism narkotikebis ukanono damzadeba, warmoeba, SeZena, Senaxva, gadazidva, gadagzavna an gasareba 1910 1885 1872 1796 2032 2019 1482 1520 1518 854 864 862 2687 2361 2337 2277 2219 2204 Crime against public security and order* Involvement in criminal underworld Unlawful purchasing, storage, keeping, manufacturing, carriage or sale of firearms Taking possession of a gun with the intent of misappropriation or extortion Illegal making, production, purchasing, storing, trafficking, shipment or sale of narcotics 81

gagrzeleba continued 1 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 20 21 22 20 21 22 17 saqartvelosi narkotikebis ukanonod Semotana, gadatana an tranzitit saertasoriso gadazidva 89 104 104 99 107 107 25 28 28 14 15 15 56 50 49 97 87 86 Illegal entry, carriage or international shipment through transit of narcotics to Georgia narkotikuli sasualebebis moxmareba 3486 3691 3659 2450 2525 2516 1486 1515 1515 938 862 857 4087 3653 3553 4119 4065 4002 Consumption of narcotic substances sxva narkotikuli danasauli 94 83 82 108 115 115 118 123 122 93 93 93 179 171 170 178 176 173 Other drug-related crimes transportis mozraobis usafrtxoebis an eqspluataciis wesis darrveva danasauli garemos dacvisa da bunebrivi resursebit sargeblobis wesis winaarmdeg xe-bucqnaris ukanonod gacexva; tyis an nargavis dazianeba an ganadgureba sxva danasauli garemos dacvisa da bunebis resursebit sargeblobis wesis winaarmdeg danasauli saxelmwifos winaarmdeg * saxelmwifo Ralati sabotaji 989 888 873 966 1083 1076 802 805 804 650 636 630 621 625 589 851 775 745 24 21 21 32 31 31 70 76 76 15 13 13 71 66 62 141 135 127 12 11 11 8 10 10 9 10 10 4 3 3 51 46 45 70 69 65 12 10 10 24 21 21 61 66 66 11 10 10 20 20 17 71 66 62 Violation of transport safety or operating rules Crime against the rules of environment protection and the consumption of natural resources Illegal cutting of trees and scrubs; damage or ruining of forest or plantings Other crime against the rule of environment protection and the use of natural resources 228 223 219 277 264 262 208 219 218 86 109 96 147 136 125 96 77 74 Crime against state* terorizmi 1 1 1 8 4 4 2 4 4 1 2 2 Terrorism samsaxurebrivi uflebamosilebis borotad gamoyeneba da gadameteba High treason 64 65 62 66 74 72 53 51 51 27 35 26 45 41 34 28 22 21 Abuse or exceeding of authority qrtamis areba, qrtamis micema 97 83 83 140 128 128 88 95 94 40 48 47 62 55 53 43 40 39 Accepting bribe, giving bribe sxva samoxeleo danasauli 66 74 73 71 62 62 59 69 69 17 22 19 40 40 38 24 13 12 Other crimes related to public officials danasauli sasamartlo xelisuflebis winaarmdeg danasauli samxedro samsaxuris winaarmdeg 306 335 328 630 669 662 441 456 455 246 219 218 195 195 179 610 512 499 Crime against the judiciary 308 364 362 123 149 149 79 88 88 57 62 62 84 81 81 54 52 50 Crime against military authority dezertiroba 43 57 57 7 9 9 2 3 3 2 3 3 5 4 4 7 7 6 Defection sxva samxedro danasauli 265 307 305 116 140 140 77 85 85 55 59 59 79 77 77 47 45 44 Other military crime sxva danasauli 1491 1477 1438 2249 2275 2237 1955 1949 1943 1032 1042 1027 1176 1150 1089 1294 1214 1158 Other crimes * SeniSvna: imis gamo, rom statistikuri angarisgebis formebi ar itvaliswinebs sazogadoebrivi usisroebisa da wesrigis winaarmdeg danasaulisa da saxelmwifos winaarmdeg danasaulis kategoriebsi sxva saxis danasauls, kategoriebis mixedvit mocemul cxrilebsi arnisnuli kategoriebis monacemebi warmoadgens mxolod mocemuli danasaulis saxeebis mnisvnelobebis jams. arnisnuli kategoriebis sxva danasauli mocemulia cxrilebis bolo striqonsi _ `sxva danasauli~. * Note: Since statistical reporting forms do not envisage other types of crime under the categories of crimes against public security and order and the crime against state, in tables broken down by categories present only sum of given types of crime. The indicated categories of other crimes are given at the bottom line of the table. Sabotage 82

gansaxilveli iyo Cases to be heard m.s. Semovida saangariso periodsi Among them were filed in the period of report sul damtavrda Total number of completed cases ganxilulia ganacenis gamotanit Judgment of acquittal rendered Sewyvetilia warmoebit Terminated daubrunda gamoziebas Was returned to additional investigation gagzavnilia acilebis wesit sxva sasamartlosi Sent according to the challenging rule gadacemulia qvemdebareobit Transmitted by the rule of subordination daumtavrebel saqmeta sul gansaxilvel saqmeebsi of inncompleted cases among ones to be heard sisxlis samartlis saqmeta mozraoba I instanciis sasamartloebis mixedvit (2014 weli) MOVEMENT OF CRIMINAL CASES ACCORDING TO THE COURTS OF FIRST INSTANCE (2014) mat Soris Among them sasamartlo Court saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme saqme Case Case Case Case Case Case 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 sul TOTAL FOR 18388 16335 15406 83.8 15026 97.5 105 0.7 259 1.7 2 0.01 14 0.1 15 saqartvelosi GEORGIA mat Soris: Among them: Tbilisis saqalaqo 8623 7605 6987 81.0 6808 97.4 57 0.8 116 1.7 6 0.09 17 Tbilisi City ozurgetis gs 352 306 299 84.9 292 97.7 4 1.3 2 0.7 1 0.3 14 Ozurgeti GC lancxutis ms Lanchkhuti MC Coxatauris ms Chokhatauri MC sul guriis sasamartloebi 352 306 299 84.9 292 97.7 4 1.3 2 0.7 1 0.3 14 Total for Guria qutaisis saqalaqo 1188 1012 1026 86.4 997 97.2 5 0.5 22 2.1 2 0.2 13 Kutaisi City tyibulis ms Tkibuli MC wyaltubos ms Tskaltubo MC bardatis ms Baghdati MC samtrediis gs 159 145 142 89.3 136 95.8 1 0.7 5 3.5 9 Samtredia GC xonis ms 4 4 4 100.0 4 100.0 Khoni MC vanis ms Vani MC zestafonis gs 171 167 153 89.5 153 100.0 11 Zestaponi GC Terjolis ms Terjola MC xaragaulis ms Kharagauli MC sacxeris gs 124 112 114 91.9 111 97.4 1 0.9 1 0.9 1 0.9 6 Sachkhere GC WiaTuris ms Chiatura MC sul imeretis sasamartloebi 1646 1440 1439 87.4 1401 97.4 7 0.5 28 1.9 1 0.1 2 0.1 12 Total for Imereti Telavis gs 395 336 295 74.7 278 94.2 7 2.4 10 3.4 24 Telavi GC axmetis ms Akhmeta MC gurjaanis gs 455 427 417 91.6 409 98.1 2 0.5 6 1.4 8 Gurjaani GC lagodexis ms Lagodekhi MC yvarlis ms Kvareli MC 83

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 sirnaris gs 328 263 228 69.5 224 98.2 2 0.9 2 0.9 30 Sighnaghi GC sagarejos ms Sagarejo MC dedofliswyaros ms Dedoplistskaro MC sul kaxetis sasamartloebi 1178 1026 940 79.8 911 96.9 11 1.2 18 1.9 19 Total for Kakheti mcxetis gs 430 409 388 90.2 383 98.7 1 0.3 4 1.0 10 Mtskheta GC dusetis ms Dusheti MC TianeTis ms Tianeti MC yazbegis ms Kazbegi MC axalgoris ms Akhalgori MC sul mcxetamtianetis 430 409 388 90.2 383 98.7 1 0.3 4 1.0 10 Total for Mtskheta- Mtianeti sasamartloebi ambrolauris gs 33 30 32 97.0 32 100.0 3 Ambrolauri GC onis ms Oni MC cageris gs 22 17 19 86.4 19 100.0 9 Tsageri GC lentexis ms 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Lentekhi MC sul rawa-lecxumisa da qvemo svanetis sasamartloebi 56 48 52 92.9 52 100.0 5 Total for Racha- Lechkhumi and Kvemo Svaneti fotis saqalaqo 227 210 216 95.2 212 98.1 1 0.5 3 1.4 4 Poti City xobis ms Khobi MC senakis gs 188 175 179 95.2 177 98.9 2 1.1 4 Senaki GC abasis ms 18 18 18 100.0 18 100.0 Abasha MC martvilis ms 26 26 26 100.0 26 100.0 Martvili MC zugdidis gs 932 889 905 97.1 892 98.6 3 0.3 10 1.1 3 Zugdidi GC mestiis ms 3 3 3 100.0 3 100.0 Mestia MC walenjixis ms Tsalenjikha MC Cxorowyus ms Chkhorotsku MC sul samegrelosa da zemo svanetis sasamartloebi 1394 1321 1347 96.6 1328 98.6 4 0.3 15 1.1 3 Total for Samegrelo and Zemo Svaneti axalcixis gs 386 369 348 90.2 322 92.5 3 0.9 22 6.3 1 0.3 9 Akhaltsikhe DC adigenis ms 5 5 5 100.0 5 100.0 Adigeni DC aspinzis ms 3 3 3 100.0 3 100.0 Aspindza DC borjomis ms 13 13 13 100.0 13 100.0 Borjomi DC 84

gagrzeleba continued 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 axalqalaqis gs 93 89 70 75.3 61 87.1 1 1.4 8 11.4 24 Akhalkalaki GC ninowmindis ms 6 6 6 100.0 6 100.0 Ninotsminda MC sul samcxejavaxetis sasamartloebi 506 485 445 87.9 410 92.1 4 0.9 30 6.7 1 0.2 11 Total for Samtskhe- Javakheti goris gs 702 595 528 75.2 498 94.3 1 0.2 27 5.1 2 0.4 23 Gori GC kaspis ms Kaspi MC xasuris gs 192 176 150 78.1 147 98.0 2 1.3 1 0.7 22 Khashuri GC qarelis ms Kareli MC sul Sida qartlis 894 771 678 75.8 645 95.1 3 0.4 27 4.0 1 0.1 2 0.3 23 Total for Shida Kartli sasamartloebi rustavis saqalaqo 861 800 762 88.5 747 98.0 5 0.7 10 1.3 11 Rustavi City gardabnis ms Gardabani MC bolnisis gs 260 258 238 91.5 235 98.7 3 1.3 7 Bolnisi GC marneulis ms Marneuli MC dmanisis ms Dmanisi MC TeTriwyaros gs 104 100 97 93.3 96 99.0 1 1.0 7 Tetritskaro GC walkis ms Tsalka MC sul qvemo qartlis 1225 1158 1097 89.6 1078 98.3 5 0.5 13 1.2 1 0.1 10 Total for Kvemo Kartli sasamartloebi batumis saqalaqo 1789 1491 1460 81.6 1447 99.1 7 0.5 5 0.3 1 0.1 17 Batumi City qobuletis ms Kobuleti MC xelvacauris gs 294 274 273 92.9 270 98.9 2 0.7 1 0.4 6 Khelvachauri GC xulos ms Khulo MC qedis ms Keda MC Suaxevis ms Shuakhevi MC sul awaris sasamartloebi 2083 1765 1733 83.2 1717 99.1 9 0.5 6 0.3 1 0.1 16 Total for Adjara soxumis saqalaqo Sokhumi City gali-gulrifsis rs 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Gali-Gulripshi DC sul afxazetis sasamartloebi 1 1 1 100.0 1 100.0 Total for Abkhazia 85

sisxlis samartlis saqmeta saapelacio wesit gasacivreba sasamartlos dasaxeleba ganxilulia ganacenit (saqme) Examined with judgment (case) (2014 weli) APPEAL OF CRIMINAL CASES gasacivrda dacvis mxaris mier Filed by defense Court 1 2 3 4 5 sul 15026 988 6.6 Total 1 Tbilisis saqalaqo 6808 446 6.6 Tbilisi City 2 batumis saqalaqo 1447 122 8.4 Batumi City 3 qutaisis saqalaqo 997 97 9.7 Kutaisi City 4 goris gs 498 41 8.2 Gori GC 5 xelvacauris gs 270 15 5.6 Khelvachauri GC 6 rustavis saqalaqo 747 35 4.7 Rustavi City 7 axalcixis gs 322 10 3.1 Akhaltsikhe GC 8 zugdidis gs 892 43 4.8 Zugdidi GC 9 Telavis gs 278 11 4.0 Telavi GC 10 mcxetis gs 383 20 5.2 Mtskheta GC 11 bolnisis gs 235 11 4.7 Bolnisi GC 12 zestafonis gs 153 32 20.9 Zestaponi GC 13 samtrediis gs 136 1 0.7 Samtredia GC 14 xasuris gs 147 11 7.5 Khashuri GC 15 ozurgetis gs 292 4 1.4 Ozurgeti GC 16 senakis gs 177 14 7.9 Senaki GC 17 fotis saqalaqo 212 16 7.5 Poti City 18 gurjaanis gs 409 Gurjaani GC 19 sacxeris gs 111 19 17.1 Sachkhere GC 86

gagrzeleba continued 1 2 3 4 5 20 axalqalaqis gs 61 1 1.6 Akhalkalaki GC 21 sirnaris gs 224 35 15.6 Sighnaghi GC 22 martvilis ms 26 Martvili MC 23 xonis ms 4 Khoni MC 24 abasis ms 18 Abasha MC 25 cageris gs 19 2 10.5 Tsageri GC 26 TeTriwyaros gs 96 1 1.0 Tetritskaro GC 27 ambrolauris gs 32 Ambrolauri GC 28 lentexis ms 1 Lentekhi MC 29 mestiis ms 3 Mestia MC 30 borjomis ms 13 Borjomi MC 31 ninowmindis ms 6 Ninotsminda MC 32 galis rs 1 1 100.0 Gali RC 33 adigenis ms 5 Adigeni MC 34 aspinzis ms 3 Aspindza MC 87

sisxlis samartlis saqmeta intensivobis macvenebeli mosaxleobis 10000 kacze gaangarisebit INTENSITY INDEX OF CRIMINAL CASES ACCORDING TO THE CALCULATION OF 10000 CITIZENS regioni Region 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 sul saqartvelo TOTAL FOR GEORGIA 36 43 35 35 36 32 20 33 36 Tbilisi Tbilisi 47 61 58 58 64 56 37 58 65 guria Guria 29 28 20 20 19 23 12 14 22 imereti Imereti 28 31 26 25 23 21 11 22 20 kaxeti Kakheti 33 30 20 23 25 24 15 25 25 mcxeta-mtianeti Mtskheta-Mtianeti 43 39 26 30 30 37 24 39 38 rawa-lecxumi da qvemo svaneti Racha-Lechkhumi and Kvemo Svaneti samegrelo-zemo svaneti Samegrelo-zemo svaneti 33 29 19 18 22 16 28 31 21 21 21 17 10 10 17 20 10 28 samcxe-javaxeti Samtskhe-Javakheti 42 42 27 29 25 30 14 24 23 Sida qartli Shida Kartli 36 29 30 27 24 24 19 25 25 qvemo qartli Kvemo Kartli 24 52 31 29 27 21 12 22 23 afxazetis a/r* Aphkhazia Aut. Republic* awaris a/r Achara Aut. Republic 44 62 42 44 38 33 23 38 45 * mosaxleobis raodenobis ararsebobis gamo, mocemuli macvenebeli gaangarisebuli ar aris * Due to absence of quantity of population, the given index isn't calculated 88

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 7007 7370 7309 7017 7601 7358 9176 9075 8670 8373 9133 8992 9933 11974 13602 13314 14264 14539 15849 15367 14876 15026 15483 15592 15766 16641 16335 17526 17639 Semosuli da ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli sisxlis samartlis saqmeebis dinamika D DYNAMIC OF FILED AND HEARD ACQUITTAL RENDERED JUDGMENTS OF CRIMINAL CASES 20000 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases 18927 ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 16000 12000 8000 4000 0 wlebi Years 89

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 134 175 173 165 173 201 231 216 219 246 230 253 253 241 319 313 307 314 308 339 409 389 376 404 479 482 551 523 505 675 sisxlis samartlis saqmeta mozraobis dinamika zogierti saxis danasaulis mixedvit ganzrax mkvleloba DUNMADYNAMIC OF CRIMINAL CASES ACCORDING TO OTHER CRIMES INTENTIONAL HOMICIDE 800 700 600 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 500 400 300 200 100 0 wlebi YYears 90

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 8 16 29 31 29 33 29 33 30 34 41 39 43 42 48 54 56 62 60 67 70 70 78 107 123 136 143 167 176 Tavisuflebis ukanono arkveta da mzevlad xelsi Cagdeba ILLIGAL DEPRIVATION OF LIBERTY AND TAKING HOSTAGES 200 180 160 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 190 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 wlebi Years 91

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 1339 1296 1433 1615 1688 1709 1623 1958 2086 1818 2092 2228 2058 2596 2571 2569 2765 2735 2703 2836 2789 2782 2994 3168 3088 3026 3247 3182 3218 3454 4000 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases qurdoba THEFT ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 3000 2000 1000 0 wlei Years 92

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 167 164 177 210 215 203 233 235 257 245 259 255 262 249 276 270 287 315 334 354 350 404 386 443 515 544 551 541 582 609 Zarcva PLUNDERING 700 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 wlebi Years 93

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 94 84 129 131 119 149 153 169 151 159 155 181 182 224 222 230 255 241 266 286 300 300 369 407 415 553 567 665 745 yacaroba ROBBERY 800 600 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 629 400 200 0 wlebiy Years 94

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 297 338 322 302 356 340 338 382 370 469 506 495 501 515 545 539 646 693 687 685 653 702 705 692 669 702 695 716 714 781 cecxlsasroli iararis... martlsawinaarmdego SeZena, Senaxva, tareba, damzadeba, gadagzavna an gasareba UNLAWFUL PURCHASING, STORAGE, KEEPING, MANUFACTURING, CARRIAGE OR SALE OF FIREARMS 1000 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 800 600 400 200 0 wlebi Years 95

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 121 102 91 115 234 262 257 267 256 244 288 322 325 309 312 364 397 389 395 403 400 397 422 486 534 603 631 625 623 800 Semosuli saqmeebi FFiled cases xulignoba HOOLIGANISM 761 ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 600 400 200 0 wlebi Years 96

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 735 868 825 779 701 827 788 854 862 1048 1174 1171 1149 1393 1531 1482 1518 1669 1610 1631 1578 1711 1910 1872 1796 2019 2337 2277 2204 2687 3000 narkotikuli sasualebebis ukanono damzadeba, warmoeba, SeZena, Senaxva, gadazidva da gasareba ILLIGAL MAKING, PRODUCTION, PURCHASING, STORING, TRAFFICKING, SHIPMENT OR SALE OF Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 wlebi YYears 97

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 234 262 229 249 315 297 297 296 296 337 383 497 589 619 650 630 621 745 792 802 804 844 885 868 873 851 989 966 1095 1076 transportis mozraobis usafrtxoebis an eqspluataciis wesis darrveva VIOLATION OF TRANSPORT SAFETY OR OPERATING RULES 1200 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 900 600 300 0 wlebi Years 98

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 6 8 9 11 15 19 18 24 29 35 36 39 44 40 43 48 47 53 62 84 83 86 88 97 94 108 105 111 128 140 meqrtameoba BRIBERY 160 140 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 weli Years 99

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 21 27 26 28 39 34 49 46 48 45 53 51 60 64 62 73 71 66 72 98 106 115 162 158 180 197 222 231 261 254 Tanamdebobrivi danasauli AUTHORITY CRIME 300 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 250 200 150 100 50 0 wleb 100

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 57 54 50 62 79 88 84 81 136 123 149 184 209 207 293 308 335 328 339 378 364 362 395 432 414 452 500 572 600 750 Semosuli saqmeebi Filed cases samxedro danasauli ganacenis gamotanit ganxiluli saqmeebi Cases heard by making verdict 695 600 450 300 150 0 wlebi 101

sul msjavrdebulia Total convicted Tavisuflebis arkveta Deprivation of liberty pirobiti msjavri Conditional sentence jarima Fine sul msjavrdebulia Total convicted Tavisuflebis arkveta Deprivation of liberty pirobiti msjavri Conditional sentence jarima Fine sul msjavrdebulia Total convicted Tavisuflebis arkveta Deprivation of liberty pirobiti msjavri Conditional sentence jarima Fine msjavrdebulta raodenobis dinamika danasaulis saxeebis mixedvit DYNAMIC OF QUANTITY OF CONVICTED MINORS ACCORDING TO THE TYPES OF CRIME 2012 2013 2014 m.s.seefardat, Among m.s.seefardat, Among m.s.seefardat, Among them charged them charged them charged danasaulis saxeebi Types of Cime 1 14 15 16 17 14 15 16 17 14 15 16 17 18 s u l 10922 40.3 48.6 7.1 15166 28.1 57.0 12.2 16776 35.5 45.2 16.2 Total mat Soris: Among them: danasauli adamianis winaarmdeg 1002 42.8 24.6 19.7 1092 33.9 26.7 22.4 1610 26.9 21.2 31.7 Crimes against people ganzrax mkvleloba 207 97.1 2.9 159 100.0 0.0 0.0 123 98.4 1.6 0.0 Intentional homicide ganzrax mkvleloba damamzimebel garemoebasi ganzrax mkvleloba uecari, Zlieri sulieri arelvebis mdgomareobasi mkvleloba aucilebeli mogeriebis farglebis gadacilebit sicocxlis mospoba gaufrtxileblobit janmrtelobis ganzrax mzime dazianeba janmrtelobis ganzrax naklebad mzime dazianeba 32 96.9 3.1 31 93.5 0.0 3.2 37 100.0 0.0 0.0 1 100.0 0.0 0.0 1 100.0 0.0 0.0 2 100.0 0.0 0.0 1 100.0 0.0 0.0 Intentional homicide in aggravating circumstances Intentional homicide in sudden heat of passion Homicide by exceeding the limits of necessary self-defense 12 58.3 41.7 5 80.0 20.0 0.0 11 81.8 18.2 0.0 Manslaughter through negligence 77 72.7 26.0 1.3 117 46.2 53.0 0.0 185 49.7 49.7 0.5 71 36.6 57.7 1.4 93 14.0 76.3 8.6 85 12.9 77.6 9.4 cema wameba 341 1.8 9.7 54.5 431 0.9 10.0 47.6 857 1.6 8.6 52.2 Beating Torture gaupatiureba 34 79.4 17.6 2.9 21 95.2 4.8 0.0 14 100.0 0.0 0.0 Rape sqesobrivi Tavisuflebisa da xelseuxeblobis winaarmdeg mimartuli sxva danasauli 36 33.3 58.3 5.6 37 54.1 40.5 5.4 49 53.1 32.7 14.3 Inflicting intentional serious damage to health Inflicting less serious intentional damage to health Other crimes directed at sexual liberty and integrity Tavisuflebis ukanono arkveta 84 32.1 67.9 82 32.9 64.6 2.4 82 47.6 52.4 0.0 Illegal deprivation of liberty sxva danasauli adamianis uflebebisa da Tavisuflebis winaarmdeg 108 33.3 51.9 5.6 113 32.7 40.7 23.9 165 41.2 27.9 28.5 Other crime against human rights and freedom 102

gagrzeleba continued 1 14 15 16 17 14 15 16 17 14 15 16 17 18 ekonomikuri danasauli 4586 48.1 47.8 1.6 4,365 38.8 54.7 5.3 4,744 42.5 49.1 8.0 Economic crimes qurdoba 2545 42.8 52.5 1.3 3112 34.5 62.4 1.9 3307 41.0 54.2 4.7 Theft Zarcva 199 66.8 30.2 0.5 285 68.1 30.2 1.1 292 72.9 24.7 2.4 Plundering yacaroba 135 100.0 255 98.0 2.0 7.8 181 96.7 3.3 0.0 Robbery TaRliToba 962 58.3 39.8 1.1 288 38.2 46.2 6.9 294 47.6 43.5 7.8 Fraud gamozalva 38 78.9 21.1 10 40.0 60.0 0.0 37 62.2 32.4 5.4 Extortion mitviseba an gaflangva 200 44.0 51.0 3.5 98 22.4 63.3 13.3 167 20.4 62.3 16.8 Misappropriation or embezzlement avtomobilis an sxva meqanikuri satransporto sasualebis martlsawinaarmdego daufleba misakutrebis miznis garese falsifikacia 10 20.0 80.0 20 5.0 70.0 25.0 Falsification markirebas daqvemdebarebuli aqcizuri saqonlis aqcizuri markis garese gamosveba, Senaxva, realizacia an gadazidva yalbi fulis an fasiani qaraldis damzadeba an gasareba 26 46.2 50.0 3.8 26 0.0 69.2 30.8 31 0.0 58.1 41.9 15 100.0 9 88.9 11.1 0.0 21 85.7 9.5 4.8 Taking possession of a motor car or other motor vehicle unlawfully without intent to misappropriate Production, storing, sale or carriage of excise goods subject to marking without an excise mark Making or realization of false money or securities sabajo wesis darrveva 78 57.7 41.0 1.3 72 0.0 18.1 81.9 80 7.5 35.0 57.5 Violation of customs rule gadasaxadisatvis Tavis arideba 42 57.1 42.9 12 33.3 41.7 8.3 13 46.2 7.7 46.2 Tax avoidance sxva ekonomikuri danasauli 336 22.3 68.5 6.3 198 13.6 58.1 24.2 301 14.3 51.2 30.6 Other economic crimes danasauli sazogadoebrivi usisroebisa da wesrigis winaarmdeg * 3508 36.0 55.2 4.6 7823 23.9 64.3 10.5 8147 36.3 47.8 14.1 Crime against public security and order* qurduli samyaros wevroba 7 100.0 5 100.0 52 98.1 1.9 0.0 Involvement in criminal underworld banditizmi cecxlsasroli iararis... martlsawinaarmdego SeZena, Senaxva, tareba, damzadeba, gadazidva an gasareba iararis... martlsawinaarmdego daufleba misakutrebis miznit an gamozalva 347 29.7 61.1 7.8 533 17.8 66.6 15.2 529 26.7 57.5 15.9 4 100.0 6 33.3 66.7 2 100.0 0.0 0.0 Banditism xulignoba 434 33.9 59.2 3.2 235 12.8 59.1 17.4 152 38.2 46.7 11.8 Hooliganism narkotikebis ukanono damzadeba... gadazidva, gadagzavna an gasareba 1100 54.4 44.5 1.1 2660 44.8 53.4 1.0 2354 64.4 34.1 1.6 Unlawful purchasing, storage, keeping, manufacturing, carriage or sale of firearms Taking possession of a gun with the intent of misappropriation or extortion Illegal making, production, purchasing, storing, trafficking, shipment or sale of narcotics 103

gagrzeleba continued 1 14 15 16 17 14 15 16 17 14 15 16 17 18 saqartvelosi narkotikebis ukanono Semotana, gadatana an tranzitit saertasoriso gadazidva 16 87.5 12.5 52 40.4 19.2 40.4 132 59.1 7.6 33.3 Illegal entry, carriage or international shipment through transit of narcotics to Georgia narkotikebis moxmareba 861 25.6 70.3 3.6 3570 12.2 71.7 14.9 4003 24.3 52.0 20.1 Consumption of narcotic substances sxva narkotikuli danasauli 103 62.1 36.9 174 18.4 73.6 8.0 177 35.0 41.8 23.2 Other drug-related crimes transportis mozraobis usafrtxoebis an eqspluataciis wesis darrveva danasauli garemos dacvisa da bunebrivi resursebit sargeblobis wesis winaarmdeg * xe-bucqnaris ukanonod gacexva; tyis an nargavis dazianeba an ganadgureba bunebis resursebit sargeblobis wesis winaarmdeg danasauli saxelmwifos winaarmdeg * 636 16.8 52.5 11.9 588 9.4 69.7 18.0 746 10.1 74.1 15.5 18 72.2 5.6 79 1.3 70.9 27.8 144 0.0 75.0 22.9 Violation of transport safety or operating rules Crime against the rules of environment protection and the consumption of natural resources 3 66.7 0.0 47 87.2 12.8 66 1.5 66.7 31.8 Illegal cutting of trees and scrubs; damage or ruining of forest or plantings 15 73.3 6.7 32 3.1 46.9 50.0 78 2.6 82.1 15.4 environment protection and the use of natural resources 136 41.9 55.1 2.9 151 21.9 57.6 19.9 106 38.7 49.1 11.3 Crime against State* saxelmwifo Ralati High treason sabotaji 1 Sabotage teroristuli aqti 4 50.0 50.0 1 0.0 100.0 0.0 Terrorism samsaxurebrivi uflebamosilebis borotad gamoyeneba da gadameteba 37 27.0 73.0 42 23.8 61.9 14.3 30 40.0 50.0 6.7 Abuse or exceeding of authority qrtamis areba, qrtamis micema 75 56.0 42.7 1.3 62 37.1 56.5 6.5 46 60.9 39.1 0.0 Accepting bribe, giving bribe sxva samoxeleo danasauli 20 15.0 70.0 15.0 46 0.0 56.5 43.5 29 3.4 62.1 34.5 Other crimes related to public officials danasauli sasamartlo xelisuflebis winaarmdeg danasauli samxedro samsaxuris winaarmdeg 273 27.5 64.5 7.0 221 34.8 43.4 20.4 545 42.6 33.6 21.5 Crime against the judiciary 62 56.5 38.7 3.2 84 15.5 83.3 0.0 51 33.3 60.8 5.9 Crime against military authority dezertiroba 3 100.0 5 100.0 7 100.0 0.0 0.0 Defection sxva samxedro danasauli 59 54.2 40.7 3.4 79 10.1 88.6 44 22.7 70.5 6.8 Other military crime sxva danasauli 1337 25.3 48.1 23.9 1351 15.5 46.1 33.8 1429 17.7 44.6 36.7 Other crimes * _ SeniSvna ixilet 84-e See the remark on the page 84 104

sul msjavrdebulia Total convicted Tavisuflebis arkveta Deprivation of liberty pirobiti msjavri Conditional sentence jarima Fine tusaroba Imprisonment gamasworebeli labor Tanamdebobis dakavebis an saqmianobis uflebis CamorTmeva Fired from the sazogadoebisatvis sasargeblo Sroma Socially useful work gatavisuflda amnistiit an sxva safuzvlit Released by amnesty or other grounds gadaido ganacenis arsruleba Execution of the judgment was suspended sxva sasjeli Other punishment nasamartlobis dinamika DYNAMIC OF CRIMINAL RECORD mat Soris miesajatamong Among them were charged wlebi YYears samusao Correctional piri piri piri piri piri piri piri piri piri piri person person person person person person person person person person 2001 8897 2708 30.4 3528 39.7 2344 26.3 25 0.3 76 0.9 6 0.1 3 0.03 46 0.5 50 0.6 111 1.25 2002 8579 2474 28.8 3600 42.0 2394 27.9 21 0.2 38 0.4 7 0.1 12 0.1 23 0.3 10 0.12 2003 8110 2324 28.7 3550 43.8 2129 26.3 24 0.3 41 0.5 1 0.01 1 0.01 17 0.2 13 0.2 10 0.12 2004 9071 3172 35.0 3588 39.6 2177 24.0 18 0.2 66 0.7 1 0.01 16 0.2 27 0.3 6 0.07 2005 9168 3525 38.4 3755 41.0 1657 18.1 9 0.1 183 2.0 6 0.1 3 0.03 18 0.2 2 0.02 10 0.11 2006 16911 7930 46.9 7002 41.4 1820 10.8 9 0.1 66 0.4 2 0.01 10 0.1 65 0.4 3 0.02 4 0.02 2007 21170 9788 46.2 9585 45.3 828 3.9 X 7 0.03 2 0.01 19 0.1 934 4.4 7 0.03 2008 20804 8846 42.5 10601 51.0 1010 4.9 X 3 0.01 1 0.00 26 0.1 309 1.5 7 0.03 1 0.00 2009 18354 8384 45.7 8599 46.9 1324 7.2 X 11 0.1 29 0.2 4 0.02 3 0.02 2010 19940 9135 45.8 9484 47.6 1296 6.5 X 3 0.02 6 0.03 9 0.05 4 0.02 3 0.02 2011 18153 7454 41.1 9498 52.3 1118 6.2 X 1 0.01 2 0.01 77 0.4 1 0.01 2 0.01 2012 10922 4406 40.3 5305 48.6 778 7.1 X 6 0.05 424 3.9 2 0.02 1 0.01 2013 15166 4264 28.1 8639 57.0 1831 12.1 X 2 0.01 277 1.8 153 1.01 2014 16776 5949 35.5 7581 45.2 2722 16.2 X 1 0.01 515 3.1 8 0.05 105

1010 1324 1296 1118 778 1831 2722 4406 4264 5949 5305 7454 7581 8846 8384 9135 8599 9484 8639 9484 10922 10601 15166 16776 18354 18153 20804 19940 msjavrdebulta raodenoba sasjelis RonisZiebebis mixedvit BENUMBER OF CONVICTED PERSONS ACCORDING TO PANEL MEASURES NUM 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 msjavrdebuli Convicted Tavisuflebis arkvetad Deprivation of liberty pirobiti msjavri Conditional Sentence jarima FFine 2008 weli 2009 weli 2010 weli 2011 weli 2012 weli 2013 weli 2014 weli 106

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 50 sasjelis RonisZiebaTa dinamika, procentobit Tavisuflebis arkvetad DYNAMIC OF PANEL MEASURES, BY PERCENTAGE DEPRIVATION OF LIBERTY 45 40 38.4 46.9 46.2 42.5 45.7 45.8 41.1 40.3 35 35.4 35.0 35.5 30 30.4 28.8 28.7 28.1 25 20 15 10 5 0 weli Years 107

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 60 pirobiti msjavri CONDITIONAL SENTENCE 57.0 50 40 39.5 39.7 42.0 43.8 39.6 41.0 41.4 45.3 51.0 46.9 47.6 52.3 48.6 45.2 30 20 10 0 weli Years 108

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 30 jarima FINE 26.3 27.9 26.3 25 24.0 20 15 18.1 16.2 12.0 12.1 10 10.8 5 3.9 4.9 7.2 6.5 6.2 7.1 0 weli Years 109

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 10 gantavisuflda amnistiit an sxva safuzvlit RELEASED BY AMNESTY OR ON OTHER GROUNDS 8 6 4.4 4 2 1.5 1.0 1.0 0 weli Years 0.5 0.5 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.4 110 0.2 0.1 0.0 0.0

0.2 0 1.1 0.6 0.6 1.3 0.5 2.7 2.1 1.5 1.1 1.4 0.9 4.7 4.5 6.8 6.2 8.2 12.3 15 18.7 17.7 22.3 30 32.5 35.6 34.3 38.6 38 40.5 40 41.3 41.9 43.9 48.7 1.5 0.7 1.0 0.5 0.6 0.1 0.3 4.6 4.0 3.1 1.9 3.1 2.2 2.4 1.0 6.1 8.3 9.8 8.0 17.1 18.9 18.2 22.8 22.3 20.7 22.6 26.3 29.0 28.8 27.8 36.7 40.2 51.2 50.0 53.2 52.8 Tavisuflebis arkvetis vadebis dinamika, procentobit DYNAMIC FOR THE TERMS OF DEPRIVATION OF LIBERTY, BY PERSENTAGE 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 wlebi Years 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 Tavisuflebis arkvetis vadebi Terms of deprivation of liberty 0 wlebi Years 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 1 wlis CaTvliT Including one year 10-dan 15 wlis CaTvliT From 10 to 15 years Tavisuflebis arkvetis vadebi 1-dan 5 wlis CaTvliT From 1 to 5 years 15-dan 20 wlis CaTvliT From 15 to 20 years Terms of deprivation of liberty 5-dan 10 wlis CaTvliT From 5 to 10 years 20-dan 30 wlis CaTvliT From 20 to 30 years 111

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 piri piri piri piri piri piri piri persen persen persen persen persen persen persen 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 sul msjavrdebuli 20804 100 18354 100 19940 100 18153 100 10922 100 15166 100 16776 100 TOTAL CONVICTED PERSONS mat Soris: mamakaci 19678 94.6 17271 94.1 18514 92.8 16590 91.4 10077 92.3 14605 96.3 16058 95.7 Among them: men danasauli Cadenilia: qali 1126 5.4 1083 5.9 1426 7.2 1563 8.6 845 7.7 561 3.7 718 4.3 women Crime comitted: alkoholur simtvralesi 831 4.0 514 2.8 690 3.5 384 2.1 190 1.7 158 1.0 132 0.8 under alcoholic intoxication narkotikul simtvralesi 4614 22.2 1112 6.1 2499 12.5 1446 8.0 1104 10.1 1202 7.9 540 3.2 under narcotic intoxication jgufsi 4426 21.3 3511 19.1 3785 19.0 1746 9.6 848 7.8 701 4.6 510 3.0 in group soflad 4393 21.1 3559 19.4 3634 18.2 3359 18.5 1960 17.9 2503 16.5 2624 15.6 in village sxva saxelmwifos moqalaqis mier msjavrdebulta asaki: 204 1.0 381 2.1 407 2.0 301 1.7 238 2.2 313 2.1 396 2.4 by the other States' citizen Age of convicted person: 14-17 wlis 1166 5.6 803 4.4 883 4.4 669 3.7 475 4.3 456 3.0 381 2.3 from 14 to 17 18-24 wlis 4638 22.3 4027 21.9 4184 21.0 3623 20.0 2127 19.5 2720 17.9 3160 18.8 from 18 to 24 25-29 wlis 3817 18.3 3301 18.0 3210 16.1 2866 15.8 1832 16.8 2726 18.0 3207 19.1 from 25 to 29 30-49 wlis 9483 45.6 8565 46.7 9442 47.4 8400 46.3 4979 45.6 7698 50.8 8324 49.6 from 30 to 49 50 wlis da zevit 1700 8.2 1658 9.0 2221 11.1 2595 14.3 1509 13.8 1566 10.3 1704 10.2 from 50 up ganatleba: msjavrdebulta Semadgenloba sqesis, asakis, ganatlebis, saqmianobisa da warsuli nasamartlobis mixedvit CONVICTED PERSONS COMPOSED ACCORDING TO AGE, GENDER, EDUCATION, ACTIVITY AND PAST CRIMINAL RECORD Education: arasruli sasualo 1267 6.1 1158 6.3 1457 7.3 998 5.5 645 5.9 678 4.5 651 3.9 incomplete middle sasualo 14486 69.6 12552 68.4 12746 63.9 14755 81.3 8003 73.3 12026 79.3 13801 82.3 middle umarlesi 4934 23.7 4580 25.0 5681 28.5 2362 13.0 2246 20.6 2428 16.0 2302 13.7 high msjavrdebulta saqmianoba: musa 237 1.1 221 1.2 189 0.9 144 0.8 86 0.8 69 0.5 64 0.4 labourer Activity of convicted person: glexi (fermeri) 30 0.1 5 0.0 16 0.1 47 0.3 18 0.2 37 0.2 18 0.1 peasant (farmer) sajaro mosamsaxure 399 1.9 317 1.7 447 2.2 370 2.0 152 1.4 216 1.4 182 1.1 civil servant 112

gagrzeleba continued 1 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 14 15 14 15 16 komerciuli an sxva servant of commercial 522 2.5 694 3.8 1293 6.5 1501 8.3 914 8.4 561 3.7 488 2.9 organizaciis mosamsaxure or other organization kerzo mewarme 225 1.1 294 1.6 542 2.7 454 2.5 190 1.7 161 1.1 127 0.8 private entrepreneur moswavle, studenti 676 3.2 558 3.0 715 3.6 517 2.8 264 2.4 216 1.4 127 0.8 student sxva momusave 1651 7.9 1774 9.7 1394 7.0 1351 7.4 734 6.7 634 4.2 514 3.1 other worker pensioneri 186 0.9 174 0.9 197 1.0 214 1.2 111 1.0 67 0.4 79 0.5 pensioner umusevari 16737 80.5 14099 76.8 15017 75.3 13545 74.6 8450 77.4 13202 87.0 15175 90.5 unemployed Tavisuflebis arkvetis adgilas myofi nasamartloba: mouxsneli an gauqarwylebeli nasamartlobis mqone msjavrdebulebi 2266 10.9 3042 16.6 3350 16.8 1443 7.9 596 5.5 788 5.2 1028 6.1 being in deprivation of liberty Criminal Record: Convicted person with prior criminal conviction, whose criminal record is neither expunged nor lifted mat Soris: erti nasamartloba 2014 88.9 2759 90.7 2966 88.5 1328 92.0 544 91.3 708 89.8 939 91.3 Among them: one criminal record ori nasamartloba 201 8.9 223 7.3 300 9.0 101 7.0 44 7.4 61 7.7 61 5.9 two criminal records sami da meti three or more 51 2.3 60 2.0 84 2.5 14 1.0 8 1.3 19 2.4 28 2.7 nasamartloba criminal records nasamartlobis mqone msjavrdebulebi, romlebic warsulsi gatavisuflebuli iyvnen sasjelis moxdisagan 141 0.7 218 1.2 130 0.7 10 0.1 3 0.03 3 0.02 2 0.01 234 1.1 225 1.2 252 1.3 74 0.4 22 0.2 42 0.3 53 0.3 Convicted persons with criminal record who were released from serving the sentence in past mat Soris: sasjelis moxdis gamo 63 26.9 180 80.0 214 84.9 66 89.2 19 86.4 37 88.1 46 86.8 Among them: serving the sentence pirobit vadamde 130 55.6 45 20.0 38 15.1 8 10.8 3 13.6 5 11.9 7 13.2 by conditional sentence 113

1.2 1.1 1.1 1.0 0.7 0.5 1.7 2.2 2.0 1.4 1.4 1.1 3.8 3.0 3.6 2.8 2.4 1.4 0.8 3.7 6.5 4.8 4.2 3.1 8.3 8.4 7.0 7.4 6.7 9.7 74.6 76.8 75.3 77.4 87 90.5 msjavrdebulta Semadgenloba saqmianobis mixedvit, procentobit CONVICTED PERSONS COMPOSED ACCORDING TO ACTIVITY, BY PERCENTAGE 100 2009 weli 2011 weli 2013 weli 2010 weli 2012 weli 2014 weli 80 60 40 20 0 musa da glexi Worker, peasant (farmer) sajaro mosamsaxure Civil servant komerciuli an sxva organizaciis momusave da kerzo mewarme Servant of Commercial or other organization and pivate 114 entrepreneur moswavle, studenti Student sxva momusave Other employee umusevariu Unemployed

50 welze zevit msjavrdebulta Semadgenloba asakis mixedvit, procentobit CONVICTED PERSONS COMPOSED ACCORDING TO AGE, BY PERCENTAGE 2009 weli 9.0 4.4 14-17 wlis 21.9 18-24 wlis 50 welze zevit 11.1 2010 weli 4.4 14-17 wlis 21.0 18-24 wlis 30-49 wlis 46.7 18.0 25-29 wlis 30-49 wlis 47.4 16.1 25-29 wlis 2011 weli 2012 weli 50 welze zevit 14-17 wlis 50 welze zevit 14-17 wlis 14.3 3.7 20.0 18-24 wlis 13.8 4.3 19.5 18-24 wlis 46.3 15.8 25-29 wlis 45.6 16.8 25-29 wlis 30-49 wlis 30-49 wlis 2013 weli 2014 weli 50 welze zevit 14-17 wlis 50 welze zevit 14-17 wlis 10.3 3.0 17.9 18-24 wlis 10.2 2.3 18.8 18-24 wlis 30-49 wlis 50.8 18.0 25-29 wlis 49.6 19.1 25-29 wlis 30-49 wlis 115

msjavrdebulia Convicted m.s. Seefarda Tavisuflebis arkveta Among them charged with deprivation of liberty msjavrdebulia Convicted m.s. Seefarda Tavisuflebis arkveta Among them charged with deprivation of liberty msjavrdebulia Convicted m.s. Seefarda Tavisuflebis arkveta Among them charged with deprivation of liberty msjavrdebulia Convicted m.s. Seefarda Tavisuflebis arkveta Among them charged with deprivation of liberty msjavrdebulia Convicted m.s. Seefarda Tavisuflebis arkveta Among them charged with deprivation of liberty arasrulwlovan msjavrdebulta raodenobis dinamika danasaulis saxeebis mixedvit DYNAMIC OF QUANTITY OF CONVICTED MINORS ACCORDING TO THE TYPES OF CRIME 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 danasaulis saxeebi Types of Crime sul 883 296 33.5 669 190 28.4 475 129 27.2 456 117 25.7 381 104 27.3 TOTAL qurdoba 403 113 28.0 364 77 21.2 271 63 23.2 293 68 23.2 229 53 23.1 Theft Zarcva 32 22 68.8 27 13 48.1 26 9 34.6 35 12 34.3 36 14 38.9 Plundering yacaroba 49 44 89.8 23 20 87.0 14 14 100.0 24 21 87.5 17 14 82.4 Robbery TaRliToba 5 2 40.0 12 4 33.3 11 2 18.2 4 4 Fraud ganzrax mkvleloba 40 38 95.0 28 28 100.0 17 16 94.1 7 7 100.0 6 5 83.3 Intentional homicide janmrtelobis ganzrax mzime dazianeba 10 7 70.0 13 9 69.2 4 2 50.0 8 3 37.5 8 2 25.0 gaupatiureba 3 3 100.0 1 1 100.0 2 2 100.0 Rape Inflicting intentional serious damage to health xulignoba 37 10 27.0 40 8 20.0 17 1 5.9 7 1 14.3 Hooliganism danasauli dakavsirebuli narkomaniastan 27 10 37.0 17 3 17.6 14 3 21.4 20 1 5.0 22 5 22.7 Drug related crime sxva danasauli 277 47 17.0 144 27 18.8 101 19 18.8 56 2 3.6 59 11 18.6 Other crimes 116

arasrulwlovan msjavrdebulta ganawileba sqesis, asakisa da sasjelis RonisZiebebis mixedvit DISTRIBUTIONOF CONVICTED MINORS ACCORDING TO GENDER, AGE AND PANEL MEASURES sul arasrulwlovani msjavrdebuli 2008 2009 2010 2011 piri piri piri piri person person 1166 100 803 100 883 100 669 100 475 100 456 100 381 100 TOTAL OF CONVICTED MINORS mat Soris: vaji 1119 96.0 767 95.5 853 96.6 638 95.4 450 94.7 443 97.1 365 95.8 Among them: Boys gogona 47 4.0 36 4.5 30 3.4 31 4.6 25 5.3 13 2.9 16 4.2 Girls 14-15 wlis 299 25.6 206 25.7 226 25.6 201 30 129 27.2 126 27.6 113 29.7 from 14 to 15 16-17 wlis 865 74.2 597 74.3 657 74.4 468 70 346 72.8 330 72.4 268 70.3 from 16 to 17 ar musaobs, ar swavlobs 652 55.9 392 48.8 396 44.8 349 52.2 275 57.9 307 67.3 288 75.6 danasauli Cadenilia: not involved in working and studying Crime is committed: alkoholur 28 2.4 24 3.0 24 2.7 10 1.5 under alcoholic 2 0.4 4 0.9 2 0.5 simtvralesi intoxication narkotikul 12 1.0 3 0.4 2 0.2 7 1.0 simtvralesi jgufsi 505 43.3 336 41.8 298 33.7 158 23.6 77 16.2 69 15.1 46 12.1 in group 2012 piri 3 0.6 4 2013 piri 0.9 2014 piri under narcotic intoxication sasjelis RonisZiebani: Tavisuflebis arkveta 381 32.7 272 33.9 296 33.5 190 28.4 129 27.2 117 25.7 104 27.3 Penal measures: Deprivation of liberty gamasworebeli samusao Correctional labour pirobiti msjavri 724 62.1 427 53.2 416 47.1 405 60.5 290 61.1 298 65.4 253 66.4 Conditional sentence gadaedo ganacenis Execution of the judgment arsruleba was suspended sxva sasjeli 61 5.2 104 13.0 171 19.4 74 11.1 56 11.8 41 9.0 24 6.3 Other penalties 117

I instanciis sasamartloebis mier saproceso SeTanxmebiT ganxiluli saqmeebi CASES HEARD ON THE GROUND OF PROCEDURAL AGREEMENT BY THE COURTS OF FIRST INSTANCE k a t e g o r i a Category Semosuli saproceso SeTanxmebebi: Filed procedural agreements: - sabraldebo daskvnis garese - Without accusation saqme piri saqme piri saqme piri Case Person Case Person Case Person 5532 2014 2013 metoba(+), nakleboba(-) 5960 7140 7798 22,5-iT naklebi 22,5-less 23,6- it naklebi 23,6-less - sabraldebo daskvnit 5,4-iT meti 2,8-iT meti 5062 5988 4801 5825 5,4- times 2,8-times - With accusation more more gamotanilia ganaceni saproceso SeTanxmebiT Judgment made on the ground of procedural agreement 10476 11805 11858 13533 11,7-iT naklebi 11,7-less 12,8-iT naklebi 12,8- less uari etqva da daubrunda prokuraturas sabraldebo daskvnis gadasawyvetad Was rejected and returned to Procuracy Office for accusation 123 149 71 76 73,2-iT meti 73,2-times more 96,1-iT meti 96,1-times more saproceso SeTanxmebiT gamotanili ganacenebis dinamika DYNAMIC OF JUDIGMENTS MADE ON THE CROUND OF PROCEDURAL AGREEMENT 14000 11858 (89,1) 10476 (69,7) 7000 0 2013 weli 2014 weli 118