Pollution haven hypothesis and Environmental impacts of foreign direct investment: The Case of Industrial Emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) in Chinese provinces Jie He To cite this version: Jie He. Pollution haven hypothesis and Environmental impacts of foreign direct investment: The Case of Industrial Emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) in Chinese provinces. 2005.06. 2011. HAL Id: halshs-00564699 https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00564699 Submitted on 9 Feb 2011 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés.
Document de travail de la série Etudes et Documents Ec 2005.06 Pollution haven hypothesis and Environmental impacts of foreign direct investment: The Case of Industrial Emission of Sulfur Dioxide (SO 2 ) in Chinese provinces Jie HE CERDI Université d Auvergne 65 Boulevard de F. Mitterrand 63000 Clermont-Ferrand France Tel: 00.33.4.73.17.74.23 Fax: 00.33.4.73.17.74.28 Email: Jie.HE@u-clermont1.fr (Feb 9 th 2005) 38 p.
! # $ %& $ '( % ) '( % * +, '( % --&&, $. $ /0 $ 1 / $ 2 '( %
!# $ % &' # 34 +&&- 5 6 ' 1 (7 1 (7 3%--84 %--9 :9: 6' ; 38< 6'4 6 ' 38-6'4 %: :-- 6' 3''. %--84 +&<= + 5 +&&9.! (7 3%--84 $! $ 3 + 4 > $ %: 1! +&=-$ 1 +&&-$
%?9! $ 7 0 1 37014 @ + * A ' $ A 1! $ # 3'( % 4 %& +&&8%--+ # # ;BB.. 3+&&=4 ' # 3+&&C4!! ; B 3;BB4 # ' 9 # # ' : ' C +
$' ( )! B $ # /$ % # / $ $ / $ 9. $ * * 3+&&<4 5 <-, D $ % #. 3+&=: +&==+&=&4 ; E 3+&&+4 ; ' 3+&&%4 F 3+&&% +&&C4. 3+&&C4 E F 3%--+4 F 3%---4 ' * 3%--+4 G E 3%--%4 F B 3%--94 B 6' # # B # ; E 3+&&+4 B * 3%--%4. B 7 > 3%--94 HI $ B B D 9 # G E 3%--%4 %% 6'
3 +&<& ; +&=< > +&=+ 4 # (7 3J +&&:4 ' / $ K 0 30 F +&&:) G L +&&&4 # / $ 3J +&&:4 $ / $ # ( /$ 3 +&&%4 ( / $ MN 3B * +&&<4 ; M N >
8 ; ) 1 37 > +&&<) 4 # $! 3 F B +&&<4) B # # 3 4 3 4 3! 4 ; 3+&&:4 ( 3! 4 3 4 1 8 7 > 3+&&<4 HI $ D B
( 3F %--+) %--% F * %--94 3# %--%) F %--8 F OE %--84 3# P %--84 ' $ ( /$ $ ( $ # 3+&&8+&&<4 1 3%--+4 # # ; $ F E 3%---4! *
! *' # $ # %: % '( % %--+ : 9- # ;0 * ;0 '( % # '( %! ; 1 '( % >5 ' 5 Q '( % '( % 3 % 4 9 '( % 7 6! ( : # +&&-
# 3 9 4 +',( - '( % 1 3+&&=4 > M N '( % :! 3+4 3%4 394 384 3:4 Ω τ!
# # #!! #!!# $ %!! &Ω τ ' #(& #% )!#&! &!% *& &+ %,& Ω!&!& )-! & $+ &!%!&#&#&!# &!.% & &+ & % Ω >. #! $ +#&!)/ #!&!)0&+!) +!#!#)&&*$+ ) #0 *& # +! #! #) % < τ #! 3+&=94! 3%4! #! 3%4! 3C4 $
! δ ' 2 F > F E > E 7 > 7 1 3+&=94 $ $ $ #! 3C4! 3%4 1! 3%4 $ # %!! 2 $ # 394 # M N τ * &' τ () &' () #
#! 384! 1! 3FR +&&8) ' ' +&&:4 * 5 $ # $ 7+ S- # 3T 4 0 ) T S- ; *)#!! 7! 3:4 # 3+&&:4 1 3%--+4! $ ' τ + F * τ + / $ 1 $ T +
8 #! ( 3 8 4 # # # +, --. /, ----- 0,..1 2, --- 3, 3U4 34 3U4
# 5 * 2 # 2 1!! *! # (. 3+V4 3:V4! 3<4 3E 4 34 8 9 2 3 4 # $ # # # 5 U (# %(# % $#%& # $ &&'( # (# #+./ # #+% - #, # )(*+ 3<4
0 #,2 3 (%2(,% (# (%2(,% 1,2 (# 0 #+% - (# ()/&% ( (#, %& 1,2 # 0 * : # # $ #! # 3 : 4.' 4 # $ +&&8%--+ $ #! ' $ %: $ # +&&% +&&8%--+ $
CERDI, Etudes et Documents, Ec 2005.06 +5!# # '( %! '( % # 3#'04 1 +&&- ' '( % # M N ; $ '( % # '( % C * ;0 # 4 4 4 6 +9 5 6) '( % +9 +&&+ <= 6! C > B E # B ' 3%---4 '(% < # +9 3 2 7 ' T +&=&%--%4
3E?F4 # 3+&&8 +&&:4 1 3%--+4 3%--94 3%--84! 6 3E?F4 3%---4 > 3%--94 $ M N 3 %---4 # +9 +9 &=, ;0 1 /$ $ 37 > +&&<) E F +&&&) ' * %--+ F %--- 4 > $ # M# 7 Q 3#7Q4N 6 7! M =-, N 3 +&&&4 1 +&&-$ = E F 3%--%4 5
#7Q * 3%--%4!! =-, # '( % $ #! +&&- $ $! 1! 3:V4 /5 7!# # # +&&- 0 #
$ # + 1 3 # + 4 # 5. # ( (.! ;BB.. 3+&&=4! 1 > 3+&=%4 1. 3+&&+4 # 1 1. 3+&&+4 #! 8 : 79 7965 5 ε * 55 : : 8: ; 7979 : 65 5: # 5 #.. 3+&&=4 1 > 3+&=%4 1. 3+&&+4
:../ : 1 > 3+&=%4.. 1. 3+&&+4 : % 9 8 W + 1. $.. 3+&&=4 M# ;BB 1.N 3. %--94! # :./.0 8 / + +./..0.0..2 8 /. + # 1 #'554 4 5! * ; B B 3;BB4 > ;BB.. ;BB F. P 3+&CC4 ' # 3+&&C4
! ;BB # ' # 3+&&C4 ;BB! 3 # % 4 # % # B # > 3+&<=4 J! 1!! #! ;BB # # % '( % ; #
'(! & # # -C&9 3E 4 ; % -%9+ -%9+ -C&9X-+C, ;0 +, +, -98:,$ ;0 $ ( +, ;0 -:-:, # 3+&&:4 -C9: # # :, +- # # 1 # & +- δ?3+uδ4x--8& δx--:
> $ ( +, -+9+, $ # # % $ * 3+-%<4 $ 3-+<C4 # 7E $ 3> %--94 $ +&&- * * 3+&&C4 *. 3%---4 1 ( # # M N MN $ * # # # ++. 234(&
#! '! '( % #! * $ # 3Y--+%4! / $ $ 3 C 4 C '( % # +,$ '( % --&&, # /'
'( % *? 2! # $ %& $ '( % 1 3%--+4 '( % * +, '( % --&&, $. $ / N 1 '( % / $ 0 1 # > +&=% J 7 +=2 C<=% 1 *. B' # %--+ # ; # 7A 1 7 &+3842 =<<&-=
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
; * > %--- 7 1 7 3D D4 0> P T 6 ; JB J B +&&: P' 2 5!! I $I I +&&:384 2 C&+-% 3 4 ; ; 1 E +&&+ 7 1 P 1 # 1 P.7 * 0 P 9&+8 B1 ; ; B 1. E +&&9 7 P 1 # 1 0 374 # 6 ' YB # 1 B# 0 B1 ; ; +&&: 0 2 * A 2 ; * 374 # 7 ' 6 0 > J +&<= ' # 7 7 8C2 +%:++%<+ > > ;. +&=+ 7 0 ; >B 0 0 0 1DE 374 7 6' 7 * ::<: > J 3%--94 7 $ '( % 72 ' * 0 7 6I $1 > B E # B ' %--- 7 7 2 #5. > 7 7 7 C2 C9=9 > > 7. F * +&&% # # 02 ; 0 # # 0 1 7 =%3%42 8<=8=+ J 1. ' 0 0 P 0 P ' +&&: 7 6' B2 * 7 # 6'A J 7 F GGG2 +9%+C9 J 1 1F ( +&&C 7 0 B2 1 0 ; B. ; * E * 1 F +&&& 7 6 ' P7. P <9C& B1 E * 1 F +&&& 0 1 6' ' P.7 * 0 <9C& B1 E * 1 F %--+ 0 1 6' ' # 7 ' FGGGD 3842 C&+<-9 F OE %--8 1 # # #2 # * 9%3:42 =%&=:- F > J +&== 0 ' # * 0 6 0 %<% F E %--- /$ 5 0 %&2 :&<& F 1 +&&% 7 B$ 2 7 B P T 6 F 1 +&&C 7 B$ F 2 7 B J 0 7 C%2 :%& F G G F 0 %--+ 0 ' B ' 7 ' %:2 9-:9%+ F J1 T %--- # 7 7 J 7 7 B 8-2 +%- F G * %--9 # 0A 7 0 9%2 &8:&:9 F +&&8 # 7 2 # 7 7 ; # F J 7 7 B %<2 +C9+=8 F 7. * > > +&&% 7 7 B # 2 +&C-+&== 2 0 F 374 # 7 P +:& *. * B B * +&&< ' 0 >A * 7 +&C:+&&: 2 0 (7 7 3+&&&4 # P B F 0 ' +&&% # 7 0 2 > # 1 E 1 0 ::% (7 %--8 # J %--8 (7 0 0 B7 F +&&: # 1 P 7 J 7 0 &2 &<++= F +&&% 2 /.$ P T 6 F C<2 +%+-+%:8 ; 7 # +&&< ' ;2 1 ; 7! 1 * %:3+-42 +C-&+C%:
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
&' 1 #' ' ' ' 2 ' 2!' 1% 1 '( % +--- %9% :--:&& 9C<99- +C=&+ +<C--:< ;0 +- & T +&&- %9% <9&-- C=+-- %&<- 9:9--- Ω ' %9% %8=-- :8%= +89C= 88%8= τ 1 '( % %9% --C- --8- --++ -%8< ' +- & T +&&- 1% %9% 988-9 C:%C< --8-8=---- %-9 --+& -+:+ -99< -:&C %-9 -+++ --98 --:& -%:+ %-9 --8+ -+9- -%:8 -<-: %-9 --&C -<-9 -=8& =-<< %-9-98% -9<: ---- 8:&9!1% +- & T +&&- %9% +%&--- +%9--- +9+-- <:8--- ' %9% 989888 %:-8%= +&C-9 +--%--- 0 % %9% 9:&%%- 8%:-== C-=8 %<--+&C!1% %9% --9% --8: --98 -%<: %-9 --8C --8% --9- -+<C %-9 --9% --C% -9-- --=C %-9 --+% --%C --&& -+=& 3 3+4 # ) = 3+&&8%--+4 3%4# 3 +&&-4 B * 3+&&&4 394 %--- <9, %--- ' T * 5 384 ;0
1 $' ;BB %& = - ( -+<& 3-+<:4 F -9<8VVV 3----4 F --%+ +C+=VVV 3-<C+4 3----4 F -+:9VVV 3----4 F -+&8VVV )4'4&$555 3----4 4'44&% F -++&VVV 3---+4 4'$+$5 +-%<VVV 4'46*% 3----4 4'*47555 4'44&% )4'&&.555 --%+ 4'44&% 3-%:-4 -+9:VVV 3----4 4'*+.555 4'444% -C&8VVV 3---%4 -+<+VVV 3----4 4'&*&555 4'444% --<% 3-%:%4 -+%:VV 3--++4 3-%<C4 -C8% 3-%::4 > +-8+ +%:- =8= +9++ ++=+ 34 3--9=4 3--:%4 3--<:4 3--++4 3--+&4 > :<+ <+C -&= +89-9:9 34 3-%%%4 3-9-<4 3-&+94 3---C4 3-8<94 1 38< -:<%VVV 3----4-8+=+VVV 3----4 -+%<V 3--C%4-88:VVV 3----4 -:%%VVV 3----4 J 3' 4 -<+= %-8 +- +< 3+VVV &&, VV &:, V &-, % 1! ;BB! *$ 9 #! >! 8 1 * 3%--%4 0%=%%=9 #%!2 = 8<< ((( X98W#) X+%WP * 8< Y-: : # J ;BB B J +%8&9X-<+= +<8 % ' ; %+- 3 4 % +C-&< +--- C < '(%!
60!# 50 40 30 20 10 0 1979-1983 1985 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003
<5< <5< <5< <5 < #(,-&#. 5(# 5(# 5(# 5(# $ % '' 5 5 5 5 )&&% & &#.. 5 5 5 5 678# $ % %&' #()*) $ % $ % %++ 9:,;6(%
16291.2 SHANGAI $9==,> 9?87$9=5 9?87$9= @ >?@AAABC:AAAD:A E : FC>F:D 29.9789 NINGXIA SHANXI ;'=,>5 9?87$9=@ C;@?DAAA E : F:F:D BEIJING TIANJIN INNER MO SHANGAI TIANJIN ZHEJIANG SHANDONG LIAONING JIANGSU GUANGDON FUJIAN HEBEI SHANDONG GUIZHOU SHAANXI LIAONING GUANGXI Sichuan+ GANSU ZHEJIANG JIANGSU GUANGDON 1709.91 HEILONGJ HEBEI JILIN HUBEI XINJIANG INNER ANHUI MO QINGHAI SHANXI HENAN JIANGXI HUNAN YUNNAN NINGXIA Sichuan+ SHAANXIGUANGXI GANSU GUIZHOU hainan 1.40695 85.4767 fdi_gdp FDIK/GDP-GDPPC 2.42249 XINJIANG HUNAN HENANHUBEI YUNNAN JILIN JIANGXI ANHUI HEILONGJ QINGHAI BEIJING FUJIAN hainan 1.40695 85.4767 fdi_gdp SO2PC-FDIK/GDP 29.9789 NINGXIA SHANXI ;'=,> $9==,@ C:BCCAAA E : F:F:D 85.4767 hainan GUANGDON 9?8>5 A+)@ :@:CCAA E : F;F:D TIANJIN FUJIAN INNER MO TIANJIN SHANGAI SHANGAI HEBEI GUIZHOU SHAANXI GUANGXI Sichuan+ GANSU SHANDONG LIAONING JIANGSU GUANGDON ZHEJIANG BEIJING JIANGSU 2.42249 XINJIANG HUNAN HENAN HUBEI YUNNAN JILIN JIANGXI ANHUI HEILONGJ QINGHAI hainan FUJIAN BEIJING 1709.91 16291.2 gdppc SO2PC-GDPPC.014059.15409 envregso2 FDIK-Env Regulation (*'8( 8# $ $44&% 1.40695 GUANGXI SHANDONG LIAONING SHAANXI HUBEI HUNAN Sichuan+ JIANGXI HEBEI ANHUI SHANXI HENAN NINGXIAINNER GUIZHOU MO XINJIANG YUNNAN GANSU QINGHAI ZHEJIANG JILIN HEILONGJ
+!#!τ /01 2 9?) ) # /2?!&Ω /'2 30#(4'
8# %4 4 4 #( 5. 9 && ;&!+ ' 7 6 '/2 ' 01 7! # $ > @ @ #,2 # $#%& # #,2 # : @ #+./ # 9( '#('
%4 4 4 #( 5. 9 && ;&!+ <.! ' +:5 7 % +%3% +9+95 +%%5 6 <>< '/2,& &! +:+; +:5 ++3+5 ' 5 <>< 01 7 % 4+9 +9;5 ++<+5 % +:+; ++5 +++:5! #I > ::J @ BJ 5 CJ 5 ;J > DDJ $#%& 1, #+./ #, : %& <#'#(' B!.!
!'(&79*% 3+&=94 > 2 > + 6 2 ' 2 * K 99 2 $ # C