ر # "م(' &. (٣٨%,- + ٩٢ صص ١-٩ ترد ن لد ٢٢7١-٧٢٨6.4!" #$/ 2! - &' ( )*+% 1 01-2 -%.+, %# &"$!"# -1 %# &"$!"# ( -2 %# &"$!"# - 191./&0 25:*+ ( 192"(55:*+ 2"#4 ".E#. " C@ 0.(++< = >(?0 @5 $ A 6(?B* >A67 896# :"; IE E0 EL# >ME#E"0 E0 E EE EF"$ "EG H I 0 JK >AF A67 E ="E4E EO "E(H NE PE# :"; 0.(/A M( *+.#.#/ N *?896# ME" %E#=5 ME" EF#=0/E(*5 ME" SE E "EG E ME" Q(ER5 C >A!6! B( E.E#E0A!.(0 (&0!#"@.( 8A UK V& M" =0/>%/@. #"$ #! = S: X# S: Y(Z >A2 0 *W< 8*?.# M( E!#"@ >= (&0 < (F"\ 0 I](&?5 0#!6 896# [6 (+? P(?B* :) 1 5-1 %#=5 67 :"; 71 67E E:"; ([6 (+? P(?B* = ).(R5 "(B= #"# >"7A ^O & I/(/W5= 6# E(F"\ E+ I](&E?5!E6.((5 S 67 I/(/W5 ;0.0 [6 (+? P(?B* >"#E4 ceo #MEE0 "(bre5 IEL.E# /5.0 ak >A=0 A! U(WK5 A!..(R5 "(B= "6/ B( # E 67E ee.((5 0 f75" [6 (+?!#"@ P(?B* 67 :"; P#d5" I/(/W5 >=ECE5" >%E/@ %E#=5 =0 =A "(g (*5 I](&?5 (F"\.((5 0#!6 S 1 I756 & hesam.najmi@gmail.com ; najmi@ind.iust.ac.ir :6("6*?4 [
% _`a,b cرop 8 ز RST8 د U % V " WX YZ[ % \ "/ Uز^[ @A B رو % C DEFG >? = % و :; 9 ر 8 ن HIJ % K 8LM c"ew >E#=!E= E #MA EA!.E?0 E# I](&E?5 he: @!=.0 V& F#=0 (:.0/"#4!6 I 5 A! "((j5i ME"/5 EF#=0 EB (*5 >A(*F "0 Q"#= k >#= >A!= "( A >ME#"0 0! >"0 A" k"< S.[1] F# >"(/ 8 >A(+F 0 " E?#= f(e< >EA(E?: EZ IEM*!5 [6 P(?B* N" "@ E#<5 de# E0 EAE $=5 0 (Z?#= f(< $# =." W: >WZ > $"0 ;+ IoW< >%/@ Nn? A" ( C#W5 0 4 "E$.[2] E #/ JE (+? ; 0 IoW< F#=0 (: = S: = 5 >WZ $# = >EA67E :"; i (+? P(?B* 67 "6/ #M?0 I"(bR5 [6 P(?B* 67 :"; 8 E (&0"#= E0 E@5 E0.EE E (&0"#= ="E0 C@ A = @ I 0 [6 (+? P(?B* IE E896# I 0 #0 [6 (+? 6(?B* 67 :"; #K4 ^O A #MA SE E ";E.E# E0i F"$ "G +F 896#! 0 5 896# e.#.[5-] "($ 6(E5 ^OE >"E7A ^OE) E0 #"# po = 6# f75">= (&0S#?>=896# "E(B= E:"; >=E896# # 67 :"; 0.(R5 rk >=896# Nq >"0(5(/ ^O I/(/EW5 >=EE896#.E P#d5"E ^OE E+F >=EE896# /@ = [6 (+?.(R5 E 5E(/ ^OE E0 E# >E@ #"#E E 6(5 ^O I/(/W5 0 67 :"; >"7A E 8 67E P# :"; 0 "L: *+.[6] F"$ "G >/ >=896#! 0 5 0#"(? E=0/>%E/@ %E#=5 E(*5 ME" SE E E"4 [E6 (+E? 6(?B* 896# <O E0 E*+ E. #"$ #*W< 8 I 0 N *+.#.( 8A.0 V& F#=0 67E E896# E:"; >"E0.E EF"$ "EZ E"0 el I(0 "2K0 : "#= p" E0 VE&8 /E?Z.E E#V K0 ^(< O "(H >M#"0 P# [6/(+? P(?B*.F# tw 5 I& (4 >"($B( 0 B 4 K0 "4 (* MFV" = J 0 N S: 2 5 2 E#4 "E0 I](&E?5 0E#!E6 aek >EAN S P(?B* >A67 :"; (= @ I(0 " (0 I](&?5 0#!6 "(G >AN = JK e AN.#. K( ^(< O >M#"0!E#@.E S < (F"\ 0 > 8 >AN "(G "5(u(4 >AN 5 < (F"\ 0 cea 0 [6 P(?B* 67 :"; >"0 K( ^(< O>M#"0 N P# (1999)!6/A.[7] E E E"4 $"0 IoW< (: >A(*F 0 & 5 *+.#.# #MA >= SZ: E(J( ee.(e 8EA EL+5 E(OZ VE [E6 P(E?B* 67E E:"; E& SE = E6# E0 x E EF#=0 67E PE# el.#.f"$"g 0(2005)" Q?(*. $"0 IoW<
تردن (١٣٩٢) ٣٨ ١-٩.(E(5 >"E0 EO "(H N P# #0(2007)!6/A [[8] ^(< >M#"0 N P# # SE0Z E6.EE"4 [E6 P(E?B* 67 P# c"w IoW< >%/@ M" S<.[9] E0E!!$E = E c"ew IoEW< #" /(Z.((5 >"0 N #5 *+.# @5 E& 5 z"f @ (+? P(?B* 67! 896# /( 67 P# (2007)!6/A ".[1] " :"; i 0#!6 [6 P(?B* (: >%/@ M" (2008) ME# V c"; P(?B* I!$ A"F?0 +: P(?B* 67 :"; >"0 E(: M" >%/@ M" 0 %#=5 M" VH 0 K( ^(< >M#"0 FA F" (4 N P# (2001)./uE?(F.[10] E "EZ @5 I"(/5 7 @& 5 (: ak >A*: = 7*i/# F"E C@ 5 "6# 0?#+!M/A 896# ; 0 P(?B* 67 :";! E@ >EAaL %F 0 5!"0 (2007)!6/A /*."$ A #MA &@5 S0Z #@ "E# E6#.[] A#K( ^(< O >M#"0 P/ 0 "5V *(2001)./u?(F *+ (2008) xe E* *+ "4 [6 (+? P(?B* 67 896# :"; 0 0 0 5o+ = ME" E+ EA (+E?!E#"@ %E#=5 ME" E+ A 7("5 S(&?5 e P# = *+.#. E J ># IoW< P(?B* 67 :"; >"0 & "0 [6!#"@ >%/@ X#E VE&8 EK0.E p"! >A$d#!(0 >& (4N V K0.[4] >"E($EB( *+.# >&. A ^#" 5! S(<5 #MB5 "/A 0>& (4 N (#5 >"0 >. A B 4 K0 C*Z >0 I+(+<5 >"0 I& (4 :+; < 8+#9 SEE E > E 8 #oe E 8 67 P# "0 [6/(+? 6(?B* 896# 67.E#.E0E V& M" =0/>%/@ M"!#" M" %#=5 M" F#=0/(*5 M" />%E/@ M" A %#=5 M" A!=A ; 0 5 @ +*0 >A!6 = "0*? >EAo E/5 >%E/@.(E 8EA!#"E >EL+5S >L VM* z"f 0 67.#. 0 =0 ME" E5!E0 E0b >"E "EA = E $"0 >oe + = A$!#" S<!0 0b $"0 E >M#"0 N P# I 0 P# "A (F"\ = A$ +*0 (*5 M" > %/@ M" V& E=0/>%E/@ M" %#=5 M" S< 5 S N >A@". N K( ^(< E@" "E#. E0E E VH =0/>%/@ M" 0 #=5 M".( 8A V& M".0 A #MA >= SZ: ca 0 67 @ I](&?5 /5.(0 (&0!#"@ + N
% _`a,b cرop 8 ز RST8 د U % V " WX YZ[ % \ "/ Uز^[ @A B رو % C DEFG >? = % و :; 9 ر 8 ن HIJ % K 8LM. [6/(+?.(5"(B= 67.1= @?- 1-.F#=0 (*5 M" +*0 >A!6 /B I.%#=5 M" +*0 >A!6 /B.!#" 0b >A!6.=0 >%/@ M" +*0 >A!6 /B.V& +*0 >A!6 /B. 0 N %#=5 M" =0/>%/@ M" 7("5 I 0 5 +*0 + /B.Ao V]Z /B k+o!#" >L+5 J K L M E P @A 2- : dkp k+o!#" f5 Ao $"0 }". p>o >"0 V& }" f : r kp : sp. i!6 F#=0/(*5 M" Q(5 0b #MA. j!6 %#=5 M" Q(5 0b #MA : fi : o j. i!6 =0/>%/@ M" Q(5 0b #MA. m!6 V& M" Q(5 0b #MA.e!6 =0/>%/@ M" %#=5 M" VH "b #@ F" #MA!M(.j%#=5 M" 0 i!6 F#=0/(*5 M" = pnw< : "A S+ S/: #MA. k>" M" 0 j!6 %#=5 M" = pnw< : "A S+ S/: #MA : hl : a m : f e : cxijp : cu jkp. i!6 F#=0/(*5 M" = J%#=5 M" 0 pnw< : "A S+ S/: #MA : cqklp 4
تردن (١٣٩٢) ٣٨ ١-٩!6 =0/>%/@ M" = if#=0/(*5 M" 0 pnw< : "A S+ S/: #MA. l!6 =0/>%/@ M" = mv& M" 0 pnw< : "A S+ S/: #MA. l=0. p pnw< >"0. i!6 %Z F#=0/(*5 M" >"0 (*5 (F"\. l j!6 %Z%#=5 M" (F"\ NW< >"0 i!6 =0/>%/@ M" (F"\ m!6 V& M" (F"\ i!6 %Z F#=0/(*5 M" >"0 F#=0 (F"\ : cplip : ctlmp : cawip : cay jp : cazlp : cavmp : carip B-9 )@C- A B-9 )@C1--. j%#=5 M" 0 if#=0/(*5 M" = S/: pnw< +. k >" M" 0 j%#=5 M" = S/: PNW< + />%/@ M" 0 k!6 %Z!#" = S/: $=0 pnw< + i F#=0 /(*5 M" 0 l =0/>%/@ M" =?A F#=0 S0Z pnw< +. mv& M" 0. S/: l=0/>%/@ M" = pnw< >AL"Z +. Q(5 j : xijp : u jkp : Qklp : Plip : T lmp $ B-9 C--2!6 %#=5 M" "$:1.0 =0 i!6 F#=0 (*5 M" "$:1. Q(5 l. Q(5 j!6 %#=5 M" "$:1!6 =0/>%/@ M" "$:1 ZJ j w i y j z l 5
% _`a,b cرop 8 ز RST8 د U % V " WX YZ[ % \ "/ Uز^[ @A B رو % C DEFG >? = % و :; 9 ر 8 ن HIJ % K 8LM. Q(5 m!6 V& M" "$ :1 v m :+; <4- Min z = f iw i + o j y j + hlz l + amv m f ez ey e + cx ijpx ijp i I j J l L m M e E p P i I j J s.t. + cu jkpu jkp + cqklpqklp + ctlmpt lmp p P j J k K p P k K l L p P l L m M + cplip Plip p P l L i I U jkp = dkp j J Qklp = rkp dkp l L xijp = u jkp i I k K Tlmp = s p Qklp m M k K ( 1 ) P = s Q li p kl i I k K j J x w caw ijp i ip k K k K j J p P l L l L i I, (1) (2) () (4) (5) (6) (7) xijp y jcay jp i I u jkp y jcay jp k K Qklp zlcazlp k K Tlmp vmcavmp l L Plip wi carip l L j J, j J, l L, m M, i I, (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) 6
تردن (١٣٩٢) ٣٨ ١-٩ Tlmp + Plip Zlcazlp m M i I Pli l L β xijp j J { } w i, y j, z l, v m, 1 x ijp, U jkp, Qklp, Tlmp, Plip E #MAi"E E (/ l L, i i, i I j J l L m M SE+ S/: >A #MA I](&?5 0b >A #MA S A #MA ( N.# ca %05.A "Z @5 =0/>%/@ %#=5 M" VH = S: #@F" E $"0 >EL+5 VE/5 E EL!#"E /A >L+5.(/~5 V V >A#< %E#=5 EF#=0/E(*5 ME".(E0!E#"@ QoE0 E 5 V&8 >A#<. >%/@!#" E(F"\ E A!E 14E5 7 >EA#E< (1) (14) (15) (16).E E.(/~5!#" M" V& =0/>%/@ E E >"($E@ EF( "+E ME" E0 (*5 IoW< S/: = 0 I](&?5 <. 0*?P# "J >A"((j J "(H >A"(j A! 16 514 #< #&.E E#"$!E(0"E((j r"l I 0"#= i0 O "(H ca %05 "E#= IE E0 cea %05 (#/J Q e feze ye e E /@! <5 #@ "((j P# = /@.#!" O >"0 :( >==0 Qe = ZeYe e E e { 1, } Q = e E Min z = f iw i + o j y j + hlz l + amv m f eqe + cx ijpx ijp i I j J l L m M e E p P i I j J + cu jkpu jkp + cqklpqklp + ctlmpt lmp p P j J k K p P k K l L p P l L m M + cplip Plip p P l L i I 7
% _`a,b cرop 8 ز RST8 د U % V " WX YZ[ % \ "/ Uز^[ @A B رو % C DEFG >? = % و :; 9 ر 8 ن HIJ % K 8LM.#"0E 0 i!e PE# E0 SE#/5 Z e "$ & 5 "$ "Z"0 Q e Q e 2Q e Z e + Y e e E E+ ie0e >=EE (/ IE E0 cea %0E5.#S(* 0 ZeYe.(0 +O O0 a#"5 "#= I 0 #<. 1+ Q e i 0 P# + "A Y e = +4 >& E (4*E?>"E0 E (&0 I 0 N (* MF V" 0! S: > Nq P# #0 /?Z.#.[11]E0E N >A"4 (*5 8 "#/(2) N@ *? 0 "(0(1) N@.(#/# EL# >=EE (&0 MEF V"E E0 NE Q9E ie $ E(*5 EF >A"4 MATLABMF V" = J 0 2/60/78 NE cea %0E5 >"0 MF V" f5 /*?= S: (&0 r@.#"$ S:(Lingo8.0) E: aek "#E+! = E $ EA "EZ"0 V >(: (*5 M" & 5 ;.(/A.#"$ V] o 2 5 1 < (80-250) 6# (0/75-0/9) 6# ( 0/15-0/25) 6# ( 450000-800000) 6# ( 250000-500000) 6# ( 250000-500000) 6# ( 200000-450000) 6# ( 95000-150000) 6# ( 4-12) 6# ( 600-1500) 6# ( 400-1000) 6#."$ N V V %#=5 M" 0 V N e >o (: (*5 M" 5 %#=5 M" 5 >" + 5 =0 > %/@ M" 5 V& M" 5 "4 d kp r kp s p f i a h m l o j f e cplip, ct lmp cxijp, cu jkp, cq klp, caw ip cay jp a# 1 2 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 / *? 0.1; N >A"4 +.2; 8
تردن (١٣٩٢) ٣٨ ١-٩ < ( 250-700) 6# ( 150-400) 6# ( 600-1500) 6# "4 caz lp cav mp car ip a# 12 1 14 9G 5H!#A )$ % 5 NE PE# E*+.E# [6 6(?B* >A(*F.(R5 "(B= #"# 67 >A #MA (/A 0 NE.E E#[6 (+? 896# 6(?B* 67 P# :"; >"0 ^(< O >M#"0 E# EO "E(H NE $E(u(4 A >"0.( 8A.0 *W< 8 I 0 *+.# # S#E75 EO >ME# "0 N P# 0 S#75 N! 0 #@ #< P# "(j P#!" FL 0 E >E = E"0 E "Eg CE*O E0 @50. S: LingoMF V" = J 0 #"$ : S#g p" 0 "($ "Z @5 5 5 I+(+<5. $"0 IoW< >L+5 (OZ V <*.>/ &@ :"; >= 896#.Z 0 S#? >"0 >A2# I! [1] Uster, H., Easwaran, G., ElifAkcali, E., Silaetinkaya, S., (2007). Benders decomposition with alternative multiple cuts for a multi-product closed-loop supply chain network design model. Naval Research Logistic. [2] Meade, L., Sarkis, J., Presley, A., (2007). The theory and practice of reverse logistics. International Journal of Logistics systems and Management. [] Fleischmann, M., Beullens, P., Bloemhof-ruwaard, J. M., Wassenhove, L., (2001). The impact of product recovery on logistics network design. Production and Operations Management. [4] Lee, D., Dong, M., (2008). A heuristic approach to logistics network design for end-of-lease computer products recovery. Transportation Research Part E. [5] Verstrepen, S., Cruijssen, F., de Brito, M., Dullaert, W., (2007). An exploratory analysis of reverse logistics in Flanders. European Journal of Transport and Infrastructure Research. [6] Shen, Z. M., (2007). Integrated supply chain design models: a survey and future research directions. Journal of Industrial and Management Optimization. [7] Jayaraman, V., Guige, Jr., Srivastava, R., (1999). A closed-loop logistics model for remanufacturing. Journal of the Operational Research Society. [8] Listes, O., Dekker, R., (2005). A stochastic approach to a case study for product recovery network design. European Journal of Operational Research. [9] Aras, N., Aksen, D., Tanugur, A. G., (2007). Locating collection centers for incentive- dependent returns under a pick-up policy with capacitated vehicles. European Journal of Operational Research. [10] Ko, H. J., Evans, G. W., (2007). A genetic-based heuristic for the dynamic integrated forward/reverse logistics network for PLs. Computers & Operations Research. 9