27 26 Vol.27 No.26 Sep. 2007 2007 9 Proceedngs of the CSEE 2007 Chn.Soc.for Elec.Eng. 0258-803 (2007) 26-0065-07 TK23 A 470 0 ( 430074) Global Optmzaton of Thermal Power System Based on Structure Theory of Thermoeconomcs XIONG Je, HANG Chao, HAO Ha-bo, HENG Chu-guang (State Key Laboratory of Coal Combuston, Huazhong Unversty of Scence and Technology, Wuhan 430074, Hube Provnce, Chna) ABSTRACT: Based on the structure theory of thermoeconomcs, the thermoeconomc cost model and the global optmzaton model were establshed to globally optmze a 300MW pulverzed coal fred power plant. The Sequental Quadratc Programmng (SQP) mathematcal arthmetc was used to solve the optmzaton models of complex energy systems, n whch the global optmal solutons was obtaned by balancng the thermal effcency of system and the nvestment cost of each devce. The results show that the thermoeconomc optmzaton wll decrease 4 percent of the total nvestment cost of the energy system. And, the effect of the varaton of the external envronment parameters and the ndependent varables of system on the optmal solutons of the system was evaluated by usng the senstvty analyss methodology. The results ndcate that the external economc parameters nfluence the objectve functon and the optmal solutons more effectvely than the external thermal parameters. And then, the results of the senstvty analyss of the ndependent varables near the optmal solutons show that the optmal solutons obtaned nsure the energy system exhbts the globally mnmum total annual cost. KEY WORDS: thermoeconomcs; structure theory; thermal power system; exergetc cost; sequental quadratc programmng; global optmzaton 300MW (SQP) 4 (2006CB705807) Project Supported by Specal Fund of the Natonal Prorty Basc Research of Chna (2006CB705807). 0 () 2 [] El-Sayed Evans [2] ( [3] [4] [5] ) El-Sayed Evans
66 27 Uche [6] Lozano [7] [8-2] [3] [4-5] [-3,5] 300MW (SQP) N300 6.7/537/537 [2] [5] (F) (P) [6] [2] (B ) x l (B j ) [6] B =g (B,,B j, x l ) ([2,5-6] ) n P = ω + kjpj j= () kj = g / Bj = Bj / Pj P ω k j ( ) j B j j 2 () ( L ) (Levelzed cost$/s) [7] ϕ f L = = ξ (2) 3600H ϕh ξ(/s)f [7-8] L n F n j L c = p cf cf k j j j k P + P = + (3) j= j= c p c F ( B S W 3 ) ($/kj)k = L /P ($/kj) [,6-7,5,7] BOI SH RH FWH Turbne HP()IP() LP()Pump CWP()FWP( ) CP()CND GEN kb ks [2] kw c F k CND =ξ( CND + P CWP )/ P CND k =ξ /P ( )()P MPaT Kη B kwf RH ( 0.2)Q kwt TTD P t P s MPa a=6 a=4 W kwη T η Tr=0.95η Tr=0.85η P B kwt 0 KV w m/sη
26 67 Tab. Thermoeconomc cost equatons and the related nvestment equatons of the major devces n the system B-SH 0 c P,0 =kb 0 c F +ks 0 c FS,0 +k 0 RH 3 c P,3 =kb 3 c F +ks 3 c FS,3 +k 3 FWH -4,7-9 c P, =kb c FB, +ks c FS, +k Turbne,2,4-20 c P, =kb c FB, +ks c FS, +k BOI =740exp((0P 28)/50)[+5exp((T 866) /0.42)] [+((0.45 0.405)/(0.45 η)) 7 ]B 0.8 B-SH =( f RH ) BOI, RH =f RH BOI H = 0.02 3.3Q(/(T TTD +a)) 0. (0 P t ) 0.08 (0 P s ) 0.04 000 T j = 3000[+5exp((T 866)/0.42)][+(( η T r )/ ( η T )) 3 ]W 0.7 P Pump 6,23 c P, =kb c FB, +ks c FS, +k = 378[+(( 0.808)/( η P )) 3 ]B 0.7 CND 22 c P,22 =kb 22 c FB,22 +kw 22 c FW,22 +k 22 CND =(/T 0 ε){27[0.247+(/(3.24 V 0.8 w ))] In(/( ε))+38}(/( η))s GEN 24 c P,24 =kb 24 c P,26 +k 24 GEN =60W 0.95 T 0 (S n S out )/(h n h out )ε (T wo T w )/(T n T w )T wo T w T n S kww kw 2 () x () 2 x=(η BOI, η HP, η, η IP, η, η LP, η LP2, η, η, η LP5, η FWP, η BFPT, η CP, T TTDFWH-FWH7,T SH ) BFPT η BOI η η=(h n h out )/(h n h out )h n h out h out T SH () 2 2 () () x(y ) F Γ($/s) 2 Tab. 2 The value ranges of the major varables / / 2.8 T TTD 2.8 0T SH 550 0 <η < 0<η BOI< Fg. mn x F F e (x, y) r m P s Schematc dagram of global optmzaton Γ = Γ + Γ = cf F + ξ F e m r (4) = r= x = (x, x 2,, x n ) hj ( x, y) = 0, j =,..., J (5) gk ( x, y) 0, k =,..., K y=(y, y 2,,y l )() 2 F = F( x, y), =,..., e (6) r = r( x, y), r =,..., m F (x, y) 2 (F 0 F 3 )F (x, y) r (x, y) ( )(x, y) h j (x, y)( ) [5] g k (x, y) 2 ( ) x x* y 3 SQP Rodrguez-Toral [9] SQP
68 27 SQP SQP f(x) λ µ L(x, λ, µ) Spellucc [20] SQP SQP 4 4. 3 [7,7-8] 4 5 c P 2 4 ( 4 ) 23 /% 3 3 5 7 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 20 22 24 2 Fg. 2 Varaton of the unt thermoeconomcs cost of the product n each component due to the optmzaton 70 /% 50 30 0 0 2 4 6 8 0 2 4 6 8 20 22 24 3 Fg. 3 Varaton of the nvestment cost of each component due to the optmzaton 3 Tab. 3 The values of the external envronment parameters n the system optmzaton W net =300MW 20 c F =2 0 6 $/kj ϕ =.06 H=8000h f=8.2% Tab. 4 4 Results of the global optmzaton x 0 x * η BOI 0.9802 0.90496 η HP 0.82624 0.84407 η 0.90949 0.90204 η IP 0.90779 0.9063 η 0.93463 0.9044 η LP 0.89003 0.970 η LP2 0.976 0.84340 η 0.93839 0.92082 η 0.90426 0.987 η LP5 0.78556 0.806 η FWP 0.78963 0.84939 η BFPT 0.79889 0.79880 η CP 0.80000 0.82343 T TTDFWH /.70000 2.80000 T TTDFWH2 / 0.00000.5643 T TTDFWH3 / 0.00000.90529 T TTDFWH4 / 2.80000 0.2269 T TTDFWH5 / 2.80000 0.92037 T TTDFWH6 / 2.80000 0.73309 T TTDFWH7 / 2.80000 0.4055 T SH / 537.00000 547.6642 /($/s) 2.403237 2.3688085 /(0 8 $).4923.357657 5 Tab. 5 Results of thermoeconomcs cost analyss under the optmal condtons /$ /$ c P /(0 6 $/kj) c P (0 6 $/kj) FWH7 36349.44 497402.38 3.988 3.663 2 FWH6 080873.03 203748.44 0.08 9.840 3 FWH5 94759.34 022862.47 8.936 8.765 4 FWH4 453323.80 449677.56 8.594 8.433 5 DTR 733233.94 587852.0 8.682 8.65 6 FWP 33396.4 520306.30.584.357 7 FWH3 32489.86 469952.65 7.654 7.657 8 FWH2 202960.79 789952.00 7.58 7.09 9 FWH 588756.4 26279.09 6.999 6.948 0 B-SH 5666269.9 5279927.47 5.630 5.60 HP 8403.55 9585385.08 7.537 7.465 2 4277300.3 42267.53 7.522 7.449 3 RH 7659036.8 798899.20 5.243 5.96 4 IP 6207245.3 6363669.60 7.422 7.383 5 6947359.56 5333705.55 7.480 7.272 6 LP 324693.95 360437. 7.656 7.575 7 LP2 53972.65 4524265.35 7.507 7.7 8 724786.76 6023293.83 7.665 7.6 9 367976.4 3744453.54 7.784 7.708 20 LP5 493279.4 5440794.3 8.980 8.827 2 BFPT 20384.32 883227.57 9.572 9.565 22 CND 3654896.49 363866.59 0.422 0.48 23 CP 44472.4 53422.63 0.938 0.70 24 GEN 958305.63 9658234.53 8.07 7.896
26 69 4.2 2 ( ) 4 4 4 Γ Γ 3 /($/s) /($/s) 3.2 3.0 2.8 2.6 0 8.4.39.37 2.4.35 0 0 20 30 40 50 /% (a) 0 8 2.9 2.8 2.7 2.6 2.5 2.0.8.6.4 2.4 0 0 20 30 40 50 /% (b) /$ /$ /($/s) 2.70 2.60 2.50 2.40 0 8.360.350.340.330 6000 6500 7000 7500 8000 /h (d) 4 Fg. 4 Senstvty analyss of the external envronment parameters on the annual cost and the total nvestment cost Γ /H ((2))Γ 5 4 BOIIP /% /% 0.928 0.924 0.920 0.96 0.92 0.908 0.904 0.922 0.98 0.94 0.90 0.906 0.902 0.898 0.894 LP IP 0 0 20 30 40 50 /% (a) IP LP 0 0 20 30 40 50 /% (b) /$ /($/s) 0 8.5 2.4 2.2 2.0.8.3..6 0.9.4 60 200 240 280 320 /MW (c) /$ /% 0.920 LP 0.95 0.90 0.905 0.900 IP 0.895 60 200 240 280 /MW (c)
70 27 /% 0.922 0.98 0.94 0.90 0.906 0.902 0.898 LP IP 6000 6500 7000 7500 8000 /h (d) 5 Fg. 5 Senstvty analyss of the external envronment parameters on the optmzed varables LP 3 4 [5] 2 ( ) 6 /($/s) /($/s) 2.70 2.60 2.50 2.40 2.36882 2.36889 2.36887 2.36885 2.36883 2.3688 2.368809 η BO η HP η LP5 η FWP η LP2 0 6 2 2 6 0 /% (a)±0% FWH5 FWH2 FWH6 50 30 0 0 30 50 /% (b)±50% /($/s) 2.3704 2.3700 2.3696 2.3692 2.3688 T=547.6 6 4 2 0 2 4 / (c)±5 6 Fg. 6 Senstvty analyss of the ndependent varables on the objectve functon 5 300MW ( ) () SQP 4% [] Frangopoulos C AThermoeconomc functonal analyssa method for optmal desgn or mprovement of complex thermal systems
26 7 [D]GeorgaGeorga Insttute of Technology983 [2] El-Sayed Y MEvans R BThermoeconomcs and the desgn of heat systems[j]journal of Engneerng for Power97092()27-35 [3] Frangopoulos C A Methods of energy systems optmzaton [C]Optmzaton of Energy Systems and ProcessesGlwcePoland 2003 [4] Von Spakovsky M REvans R BEngneerng functonal analyss-part III[J]Journal of Energy Resources TechnologyTransactons of the ASME9935(2)86-99 [5] Valero ASerra LLozano M AStructural theory of thermoeconomcs [C]Internatonal Symposum on Thermodynamcs and the Desgn Analyss and Improvement of Energy SystemsNew OrleansLA USA99389-98 [6] Uche JThermoeconomc analyss and smulaton of a combned power and desalnaton plant[d] Department of Mechancal EngneerngUnversty of aragozaspan2000 [7] Lozano M AValero ASerra LTheory of the exergetc cost and thermoeconomcs optmzaton[c]proceedngs of the Internatonal Symposum ENSEC' 93. CracowPoland993 [8] [J]200323(5)40-44 hang Xaodong Wang Jaxuan Gao Bo A study on the thermoeconomc margnal costs of steam turbo-generator unt [J]Proceedngs of the CSEE200323(5)40-44(n Chnese) [9] [J] 200424(0)79-82 Chen WelangWang QngzhaoWang JaxuanEnergy consumpton analyss for a margnal exergy cost model[j]proceedngs of the CSEE200424(0)79-82(n Chnese) [0] 300MW [J]200525(8)26-29 Chen WelangWang QngzhaoWang JaxuanThermoeconomc cost dagnoss of 300MW condensng power plant[j]proceedngs of the CSEE200525(8)26-29(n Chnese) [] hang ChaoWang Yanheng Chuguanget alexergy cost analyss of a coal fred power plant based on structural theory of thermoeconomcs[j]energy Converson and Management2006 47(7-8)87-843 [2] [J]200525(24)08-3 hang ChaoLu LmngChen Shenget alperformance evaluaton of thermal power system based on the structure theory of Thermoeconomc[J]Proceedngs of the CSEE200525(24)08-3(n Chnese) [3] [J] ()200634(6)99-02 hang ChaoChen ShengLu Lmnget althermoeconomc approach to dagnosng malfunctons n a thermal power system[j]j Huazhong Unv. of Sc. & Tech. (Nature Scence Edton)2006 34(6)99-02(n Chnese) [4] Hua BChen Q LWang PA new exergoeconomc approach for analyss and optmzaton of energy systems[j]energy997 22()07-078 [5] [D] 2006 hang ChaoThermoeconomc analyss and optmzaton of complex energy system[d]huhaninsttute of Energy and Power. Huazhong Unv. of Sc.& Tech.2006 [6] Valero ASerra LUche JFundamentals of exergy cost accountng and thermoeconomcspart Itheory[J]Journal of Energy Resources Technology200628()-8 [7] Slvera J LTuna C EThermoeconomc analyss method for optmzaton of combned heat and power systems - Part I[J]Progress n Energy and Combuston Scence200329(6)479-485 [8] Gogus Y AThermoeconomc optmzaton[j]internatonal Journal of Energy Research200529(7)559-580 [9] Rodrguez-Toral M AMorton WMtchell D RThe use of new SQP methods for the optmzaton of utlty systems [J]Computers & Chemcal Engneerng20025(2-3)287-300 [20] Spellucc PA new technque for nconsstent QP problems n the SQP method [J]Mathematcal Methods of Operatons Research998 47(3)355-400 2007-04-20 (984)xongjebbz @2cn.com (977) (977) CO 2 (945) ( )