A Germans dilemma: save the euro or preserve their socio-economic model. Luigi Bonatti and Andrea Fracasso n. 07/2012
! " # $% &% '! ( " ) # # &* " $ " '" +*"!,"'-." #" # " /&! " / #" $ '! #&* ' $ #" # ' ) " " # % " " " / &-$" ' # /! /$! " " #&-$ #! # # # #$ "! +* $ '!, $.&! " $" " "" ( &* /% # 0 #/ / / &- $ (! & " " "# #! & $ / " )# " #! " 1! #& / ( #& % 23 # )2 2* 24 /& 5$5$56$7 8 & 9&$ + % $:#; $# - 7$ 6< $-,.8 & 9&$+ % $:#; $# - 7$6<$-
-:4$= ' $,!.%!%,4 $.& % % % :) #$!% 1! $ &" # " "$ $ % 0 %! "/$ $ $ $! "!& - $! $ /! $,. ( $ # # $ # # $ #, />!"/.$ /!, #. $ # #&! " '!! &!$ # $ '!" ",?@@A. "",* -.&!$ /" /$ " 0 (&.,* -.$.! # %,* --.$. 1 %: -3,* ---.$! "!)' # $%:!" "! /& " # / / 0 % & $ )
, / #.$ ' # $ ( ( ""#! &3 " /"! / %3:8 # # #;# &-" "$" # #$#! $ /" 0 &!" # " "$"%& '" # #'!#$ $#! @@$ " (!BB-- &, # B %/ 4. 1 "=," /0! /#" <<. /,.& @5<=,.$ 7 C$ " 1,4$7$.& - $ / 1 (, " 3D! /. / #, &/& & #."! $, "."# "/& 3 $ # " / " # # # #
#"!& -$ ( /"!! # $ ( '! " $ # #$,# #. $ # $ 0 "/0 #$ /! $ # " #& $$ / ":4&- $ " #',#.$ $ #$ " $ ( " 1 &E $$ # & -" / 0 " &3% ( " %: % ## # $ /! '! # 8 "#" / $" ) #& 4 $ / :4$" $ -3 F%=+,:4!. $# $ #!/) $ # / &"1 $",. " /&G $ " '$ # ', +-. & $",. # % &- # " -" / /!" B H, 6 5.$ " ' " &
),.,.!/!" & " # # %: & $"("!)*' ###" B " # ", $ $=. & # '& '> 1 ## ' 2 5 $"" & # '#,#! #.$ " #! # 1 " ) #, 6.& 4,C.$ (,". " "/!&! # $ # ' "+3 / % %3:$ "!6$ " $ # # " & B " I/ %J%$! # 46 #I J #, " 6 7. /," $"/ $ '"$. ) $# " 0'& / / E/" K$&&? (& 6 +,. & 6 4?,.? ( &
- " " / "/ #$ ' " '" /&" $ "$ $" 4 &$ 8 / # #2 2 " # / # '! "2 " ",7$C$A. /2 /! 2 " 2 # /,!#.2 "/!',"/!!! "/!. ' )'2 '!$,< @."# # & 5 B # # # $ # $ # $! ( $ # & B " " $ $ / " " & # '$"> #>" # ",7$C$A.2$ "/"& 7 H $"# # 0, ($.$ " #!! # # '! "!1,.& " &6$" " "% &- #(:", :4 "., = 5 4,7.$ $ $ $ &" $ '$! #& 7 $" " " # "/$# (!1 &
.&# $ " 8 " # #& C! -3 &" * --$ " $-3 #" ' &3$ -3 " " $## $# # 0 $ / $ "!,-34 -E=.&4" /* --$" &- & A "+"!,''# $, $""'# $" /.& -$! %,&&$ $- $- $* $4. $ # '$ # # &B - #C$ # &$ " * --$ '!, "$ # ((. $ %&= # # # " ##! $ & 4"".# # " # C - LB 4 J@$MB $ + /@@ @$"8I"0!? # # "" & $ # &4" >/>"'! $" / " '&$ $ $",&& " 7.&J A = $F%=+ -3 " &N # -3! # " 8 $ "/$ "#' /&3* ---&
%. '$&&" ' )& < F $ $M $ # # & = $" # # # %& " $ ) " "% $#$ ' & #" 0# $!% & # "# "% &M ' " #, #. O7 >O5 ',$AP@@C!@@<$@&7P@@@!!5$6&7P 7!A$<P<!$ 5&AP> :M=.&6 " - " " $"4 ",#!;!# ).& C$A <& C"" ' # &B - / #$ M & @ 7 #" / " &C$ $# :4,%. / H-= 4Q & A ' " % 8" '= H " # $ " %: F%=+ #& < # $ 4"$Q &$E$ = BRR$ & @ % ""! - # #&
=$<" # = H & 8 / $# /, /#. $ " / &-3 ' &7 8" " $ $ #'& - " #! ' # "$ "' %& ($% /"' /8 ' " #, ". #&* ' $ /1! '!"$ # # # # & - #" & " ' " # $, 4.$ "& " " # #& 5 # '# +*# - " # & % #,% =." 57P#" # :4$" "7P P %:A#& MB $ $"8I ""! #" / &B $ $$= / /& #1# #"#""" /&J = $% / $" / ' /, P 0 '!. %&4 # $ $ " # &4$ ("", " '!%3:.&
% " # %:A& $ # "%: # "4 $- $ * &F $ "7$ #" # %:" & " ",.8 $ @$) #!" #& # $ '# # $ " 8 $ " # " " & # " #, H!.8 ' # # # +-," -# #.$ ",$.&4 # "# $ $"! " # ", 4 4.& / $ $" /? ( / * -,?$.& # " # #,.&= $ +-" F%=+$, '$M $ 4"( $:4$:Q.& N$ # % % $ :% 5$ #" +-$ " "", " C.& " +- " $ $!# ##/ #$ ',6.& +-"!, 7 #"!" #!.&
-$ # #/$ +-" #,A6P A.$,5CP.$ "! #, 5.& ( Q,@. # $" ' # $ # # +-,AP A.& $ /!#$+-" ( ( &% :% % ) # #+-" & # $" # " # #" #, = BRR.&- " ' / # $ ' /0 ##!( & - $#+- A 1 +-$, "#$. # +- " F%=+ 8 &7$ #"+-/% % # +- # & 6 "## " +-8 # " / # $" " &* #"/ ## /& $,&& A. # & # # & $$ #" & # $ 8 (2/! # #2 " 6 %&FM$E/" $4$ + $+/$3B$4$ $/$HB%$ &
? (& # / +*$ E # " " # #& "-".# &6 " # & B $'#""@@!7 ) $"#&- $ / " # # "//" & $ '? ( ) " &N# 8 # /"/ $ / /"/ # & M $ ##3 = / %:&# " & $ " +- "$ &-/ +-" ' /, % " /.$ # %& $ " +- " 8 / # $ / ' % $ "" /%: & #$ $ " $ &4% / # # M"!%$ '" &- / ## # 3 /"%& = 'A$ # $
% &-$# " -3, #.#0 # & " $ / :4 # '" # #2 = '$ $ # ' #" $ #"$ # # # ' %: & - # '' ( ' ' # &$" # #$ # " $ " # ", ". & "# O&4$ " * ---$' " " #" #,1. " # &# $ $ ' 8" $ # -3$ & " " & " $ $"/! /$ # # #& # " / # &- $ " " &F $ " $ / ",%:=.$ / ' ##/$ '"/& $ ( #" ) " & 5 " 1 /#% $ P#" "IF 1/$# J$ 66P %:A#,% =.&
- % 3 4" %" # #! &-" $$ ' )" " # 4% " " " $ IJ $ " IJ/ $# ) & $ " ' / '! /$ " # $ " # "" $ # # # & 7 =1$" "# " "" # ($ 1 # /# & - ' $' # ' $ / #", $.$'!#&-$ " ( I!!# J!,% B( @@6.! '! /$ ) " "$ #"( " #"& $" # /! /$! " " #&?"#$ #! # # # #$ "! +*, $-.$ '!, /4.& C 4 #, * -." / ' $ I%0 " 7 *## " @$"%" " "I""J,&&$.& C!" $ &-3 4 $ $'- " #, $ $.,-3.&
J,4$.&/ ' " " # " ) # # & # # $" % = /,%=.$ %: &3 / #! &$%=0 # $4,-.' " #! # & 4 $ ' " # $ #! " " ", + &.& $ # $#!! /0 #, ;. $ # # #= % %,-# #.& $ 4 "* $### $ /- 4! " " " 6 # &- "$ # # ""' $#" #" " )& / # (!'# # K" $"" # #,=.& - " # "" / " #!;!#, = 4 $.&?"#$ ( "" "" ' ', % "* --. # $" " $ +*",4$.& "%/ 0 %# # " "
' $"" ' $ / #," " "%: $ C 3! A.&-! " # " /KI J$ #! * --&F# 0, $$IJ.#/ / / &- $ ( ( # # ($ # & # ", *# 4-##. # / & #",$ &&$ 4$.$ / # # # "# " (! / # $ # / # ) # &=$ ( ( "" " "" ( & -$/ #"#" # " " +*" #&?$ S S # # 1# & "/"$ # " ( &!/ 1 / 0 ", '. %=#& / #!& $ # ' # %$ /- 4
# " / & / "" #! #! & -/ # " " ## # $" % ## & ' $ " / ## "$! ( # "! &%# " " %! "( / "4 % - 3((,B.& # " 1 I # J$ " " "" " &-# # " / 8 # % " $ "/ ) ' ' " '& #" " &-/ #"! " # #$" "#! * -&-$ '! "( #"! "/ $"4*+& $, *. " 1% $"" # " # $ % " #":4 0 " &H '' " # " ' %$ ) &* $ ' "" #
## $ * -$! '! )" " "/ ## & $ " :&4& " # 1!(! #$ ') / #"!" )/"/&! "$' $ # / $ ' " / -3# ## &?"#$ " $#'!$ # / #!;!# $ # """" '&- )# $ * -$ # &-/ "" #! &. #& % ) / % & %3:! % B $ " 1 ) '&""$" # // "$ " & " * --$ # $ +-"&- # %3:"/," '-.$, "'-. & B " $" # &3 / (/ &- $#" " " #1! &- $" #. # $."! $./ '#"& M " # #
! # 3 # & A " # #$ $ '! " $ ) /#" "! # & / ' $ ' / /!,." # /& 4 "*,4 *.$"## # "'# $" # &+ " " # %:, " # IJ -3 C!3 =.& < / % " % :" % & # ' ' M" 3 / # & -$)" $ " " # 2 #$ # #$ & M $ # " #" # "% :& $$%: # ( 1# % )/ ",&&$ $ $.& " " # A # # / #!" ## /&4 ) #$ "# %: :4 "8! / #!# '$ # $ / ' & < 3 #$ $ 4 * # ) $ (! # 3 & * ' "%3:" ) 1 &
/ ' % 8 " #,# '# '.&? " # #/ " # /&$,&&$. '!!,* -. ##//', #!.$"' '! " # & @ # ' $" '#" #& $% " #" " / # " / & '# 4 "* * %, " $ /. " % #& &,." # # # $ ' " ' $ 0 "!&- #", #. ) $ @ F $ # # 1!! " $ # ( &F $ (# 1 " $ &-"/ " " / ) # #! )#& M" %"" /&$! /$ " / #&- " #! "$ $ " )&B,#".$ " (! )&
$! # # # & #% $ #& =!, /. 0 # T ' % T # ", #. T B "/"!! " # " T "$ "1IJ&-$ " # $ "!& &# B E 3 %4 H &- $""/ /+ $* $ 3$ BRR& & ' $ &$+ $ / 3$&I - $= 3$ -=#&J$5,7<.85!67 $4 $ "$ H ("$&I=- % 8= #*#JF%=+%+ B/* <C "$H &CI 8,.J- % $4 %=$*30F8?/ -/ "ACP "I J$ C6P /$7<P*$7AP4 &,% =.&,-" " >77P!"- - >A6P&./ %:$4 $* / ",". " 2 #"",".2- - 1 " &,G G5$% =.& M $ "$ ) 4 *,A7P<P. $ /$ / % #"" 7AP," %: # C5P.&
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
! 2000-2002 2003-2005 2006-2008 2009-2011 Portugal -9.6-8.3-11.1-9.1 Ireland -0.7-1.4-4.8-0.8 Greece -7.2-6.6-13.6-10.3 Spain -3.7-5.4-9.5-4.3 Italy -0.1-0.7-1.9-2.9 France 1.5 0.2-1.1-1.8 Austria 0.4 2.0 3.7 2.5 Netherlands 2.4 6.8 6.8 6.8 Finland 8.2 4.8 3.7 0.8 Germany 0.1 3.9 6.6 5.9!"#$%$ 2000-2002 2003-2005 2006-2008 2009-2011 Portugal -9.8-8.1-8.4-5.6 Ireland 14.6 13.7 9.7 18.4 Greece -8.6-6.1-10.8-6.8 Spain -2.4-3.7-6.1-1.3 Italy 1.1 0.4-0.6-1.3 France 1.5 0.3-1.5-2.3 Austria 2.3 3.1 4.4 3.2 Netherlands 4.2 7.6 8.7 7.8 Finland 9.6 6.0 4.6 1.1 Germany 2.0 4.7 6.3 5.2 &!"#$%$
!!"#$%&'
()*+,&!$+-"'+$
.!&/!+/&/+""& 0/"12223 22
45"&"/& 67 85"&/!&/!+9+""- /!+9+""- 67
:-/!+/!+/$/!+/22; 0'.(0'0.+ 67 ;'//!+/$/!+/22;</= 67
2>7/!!?1#=& 67 =&@A5 <B,
C&&$ "!!"+$%7D22 3 22 B)<"$4! (B/"!1!&)+" 17/
.)$/! &/ & /!! & "!"18$ 0$&
47+E/"/,"! 17/ 8/!&E"/! 17/
:E"C7"/! 17/ ;$/ $/!
2/)&1@+ 67 /),1@+ 67
/),1@+/' 67 (/),/&1@+' 67
./),$1@+' 67
Elenco dei papers del Dipartimento di Economia pubblicati negli ultimi due anni 2011.1 Leaving home and housing prices. The Experience of Italian youth emancipation, Francesca Modena e Concetta Rondinelli. 2011.2 Pareto versus lognormal: a maximum entropy test, Marco Bee, Massimo Riccaboni e Stefano Schiavo. 2011.3 Does a virtuous circle between social capital and CSR exist? A network of games model and some empirical evidence, Giacomo Degli Antoni e Lorenzo Sacconi 2011.4 The new rules of the Stability and Growth Pact. Threats from heterogeneity and interdependence, Roberto Tamborini 2011.5 Chinese reserves accumulation and US monetary policy: Will China go on buying US financial assets? Luigi Bonatti e Andrea Fracasso 2011.6 Taking Keller seriously: trade and distance in international R&D spillovers, Andrea Fracasso e Giuseppe Vittucci 2011.7 Exchange Rate Exposure under Liquidity Constraints, Sarah Guillou e Stefano Schiavo 2011.8 Global Networks of Trade and Bits, Massimo Riccaboni, Alessandro Rossi e Stefano Schiavo 2011.9 Satisfaction with Creativity: A Study of Organizational Characteristics and Individual Motivations, Silvia Sacchetti e Ermanno Tortia 2011.10 Do Monetary Incentives and Chained Questions Affect the Validity of Risk Estimates Elicited via the Exchangeability Method? An Experimental Investigation, Simone Cerroni, Sandra Notaro e W. Douglass Shaw 2011.11 Measuring (in)security in the event of unemployment: are we forgetting someone? Gabriella Berloffa e Francesca Modena 2011.12 The firm as a common. The case of accumulation and use of common resources in mutual benefit organizations, Ermanno C. Tortia 2012.1 The implications of the elimination of the multi-fibre arrangement for small remote island economies: A network analysis, Shamnaaz B. Sufrauj 2012.2 Post Mortem Examination of the International Financia Network, Matteo Chinazzi, Giorgio Fagiolo, Javier A. Reyes, Stefano Schiavo 2012.3 International R&D spillovers, absorptive capacity and relative backwardness: a panel smooth transition regression model, Andrea Fracasso and Giuseppe Vittucci Marzetti
2012.4 The Impact of Financialization on the WTI Market, Sergio Galli Lazzeri 2012.5 Business change in Italian regions. A spatial shift-share approach to plant-level data, Giuseppe Espa, Danila Filipponi, Diego Giuliani and Davide Piacentino 2012.6 A Trick of the (Pareto) Tail, Marco Bee, Massimo Riccaboni and Stefano Schiavo 2012.7 A Germans dilemma: save the euro or preserve their socio-economic model, Luigi Bonatti and Andrea Fracasso
PUBBLICAZIONE REGISTRATA PRESSO IL TRIBUNALE DI TRENTO