University of Groningen Essays on political instability Jong A Pin, Richard IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite from it. Please check the document version below. Document Version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Publication date: 2008 Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database Citation for published version (APA): Jong-A-Pin, R. (2008). Essays on political instability: Measurement, causes and consequences Enschede: PrintPartners Ipskamp B.V., Enschede, The Netherlands Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). Take-down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum. Download date: 13-11-2017
!!! $ # 2$ 0##%# ##$ #'# 1# ' 2#%1'1#(#0###%# #0 1# # #2 %# ##$ '2#G4%#(.**L(.**.L#.**KL##(.**KL ;(.**H! # '%'# 2# 0 ##%0##%###$ ' 2# G #(.**KL & '(.**KL )0(.**+L <0 9(.**+L <$(: 6# (,-L 4#(:8&(,L$()#'(,H 20(# 1'2& 2# # #2%# ##$ '2# $5 #$ ' ##& <G,H('#(##'$1#0# '% $ ' 2#( %# ##$( ' 2# 1 (# 0$ 11## 0#$ 1 # #'#''#(##%###1#G %0###0H###0##'%$ #% G;'% "#(,,H # %#( 2 1 # ''#1%###$'# %###$'2#! 0 0 ##'%# # #& # %' 1 ''#6####01#'%#1%# ##$ ' 2# 0 ## ' %% '%# $ G;H G##(.**KH( '# 4 This chapter is based on JG,KH G,+H 15
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
.*-=,1##'%#2 4 #1'###$1#%#'#' 2#7#'(21'01#22$#$#2 '2####$2##1##' 2#'%#%#0!'1#%#512#,,( 2 1$ # 1# $' #,( 2 # # 1# $ # #,-( 2 %0 ' %#0 ### 1# 11# ' 1%# ##$ #,( 2 '# 11# 1%# ##$ ' 2#! #0#$ 1 #'# # ' #,K)#, 3 #'#'#'#1%###$2 '%$1#$##'#&#%%'%# $(##11#######'## ##'1#0##1#(21# $'##$#1'#''# #921$#1#$' K (# ' 1# 1# $' # %## 1'### ''# # 1'# 1'###?# # $ '### 0 # @#A $ '# 1 0 1# ' 0#'('%'##'%#0 '# 1# # 9 0# %'' %1(#1#$##%#1# 0 1 # 0 ## 0 G# ' 1 %# ##$H!1#$'2#'#%1#2## 12 yn = Bξ n + ε n G.H 2##0G'H#10#(# '# 1 1# ( R 0# 1 ## 0 S ' #' '# # 2## ## 0 2 K ##'#11#$19&63G,H 17
#2##>#'%#(#0'# 1#' Σ = BΦB' +Ω G,H 2T#%'#50'#(U#0'#1 #1#V#GH0'#1##'! 1# #' # # 1?# G,H 1# # 0 % $# '# 1# 1# # #' 1##0?##0#!##22 '''### 9 #'## 1# #? 0 2## '# 1 6'':& ># '#$ '%#( 2 2##&1# L = log Σ + tr( Σ 1 S) GH 2#'%0'#1## 0 %#'5# & 1#( # %### 1#1#G#5H#1#'11###%# ##(2'&1#1######1## %#1#($##'#1 1# # #1!# ( # '#% 2# $ #''# 2## 11## ## 1# # #2#1#'#%###($# ##'$ # #%# #'# '% ## $( # # 2# 12 1# %! ###?##2##%##1##'##( 2 21#'#1#''5## 1# ' 1# 1# '# #( #$% # 2 01#1#(2#2# #1# 9#'#$#'##%#(#%## 0 1# $ 1#( (# %# ' 1%# ##$!01#'1%###$ #0###2#0#(# '%%%###'#'#1#1%# #2###?01#?.@##$1# #A!#$1#1#2 2 ##%$# 1#!#(##?1#1###1# 18
##$ '!## ( 2 # 1# # %#( 2 0# # %## 1# 1# 0 ## "'!####%$1%###$(2$#0$ $ ## G.**H( G,H( ;' G,H 9 # 1' # 12 ''$ # # <#& ## G,H( ##;#$ & 4 G,H( #$ I G6 (,,H( ## ### G4#( 9 #( &())#(,,H(<#1#### G&(;&(411(F19,.H #1#0$'#0(#0#( # '%# $# 1#'( 2?### %# ##$ # @#A $ 12 ## 0( ###''# #( 2 0 #,%# ##$ # 1 $! #(# 1# #%%, ##%%%##'%1$(21#11 #2#'10###1#%!# (# # 1# ;4 # # '%#%.*+- =,( 2####%0###'$1#! ## $ # % # 1# ( 2%0 #'# # 1#2 '%! 1# $ #%.*+- =, # 1,%# ##$ #! # #%.*- =, # 1,.%# ##$ # # $ $ 0 1 # 0 # +! %2 # '# 1 # %# ##$ #1#,. + 7$(#$01#%$1###1 0#'#&(2#'##1#'.$ 0 G (,KH ## #### # #?##0$1#'% 19
!,.;#'#1#%###$# I I I I I W W W W W WI WI WI WI WI WW WW WW WW WW WWI WWI.,,. -K.. I, *,. I. K.... I, -,,.,. I,,K,. K. I, -K.+.. -.,. W.,..*...,. W. +.K,....,.-. W.K,.. - +.,,. -. W.*,K. -.-.*. +. -. W. +. - K.,.,.* -.,-. WI..,,.. -., -,K. WI.,K,,-.+.K,.,..,K.+,K. WI K *. +,. -.,.*,-.*..+, -. WI,..-.*..K.,,,.-.K -.. WI,+.+ -..-.,-,*,,,,.,* KK -. WW +..-.K...., *.,,- - -.,. WW.,,.,.+ K.*.,*,,.., -. WW..,.,.. -.....+,,.,*.+,.,K,. +. WW.*,,.K..,.,,, + K-.,,.,,*.. WW., *.,.....-.- -.....K.K.K. * K. WWI. K -..,,.,.. - -,,..,, +..,.. WWI K.. + +. *.+.K.. - *.,.,, -+.,, +. *. "#!#2%2#11#!''1#GH#(GH)#&(GH4 21(GIH630'#(GIH(GIH#(GIH0#(GIH <'##(GWH;%D##(GWH63###(GWH;#(GWH;#1#0(GWH"'1#(GWIH#'(GWIH40'###$( GWIH ##(GWIH#(GWIH#1#(GWWHJ1#%#$0'#(GWWH7#5#(GWWH5#(GWWH"'10#%$##%1'11( GWWH601#(GWWIH6'01#(GWWIH02 20
! ### %%%# ' 1 1# # 7( 2 0 ##### 7#( 2 ;# D ## G;# (.*KKH! %'#2#0#0##' 11##5##1,.### 1 1# 0 0 #0## # 1#( ( % #0$ %# 1 # 0 # # (####11#%%%# 7,.;# D##1#'% 5 6 4 5 Eigenvalue 3 2 Eigenvalue 4 3 2 1 1 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 Factor Number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Factor Number "#! 1#% 2;# D ## 1# '% 2#,. # # %.*-,!#%2;# D##1#'%2#,# #%.*+-=, "#( 2%1' :& # G:H##( 2 '% # 1 1#'####01##'## ## 3## $%#### #'#? 10 1# G##H11#' * ###1##5### 3#0##:###0#01##1#'( 20######7#(2'121# ' 2 1# 2# 0 1 &&D 1'# # # )2#5#"#(2%%$##1'##%% $"G,,H7 $(2###1#&G,H (21#''#####G1#&#''H * 7#1#'%G.*-=,(,.#H(#:###K,G%0H( 21#'G.*+-,(,#H:X**G%0H 21
1 1#' 2# 1 1#( 2 ## ## ##11#'#%%%#.. 9#F#(2####1#2# 0###'#%##(# 1#' 1# 2# 0 ## ( 2# ' 1#2#0##.20(## $2!#('1#?01###'#'#' #5$2G$2(.*.H#1%$%1 'G6(.**H 22
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
$!)! 1# 2 # 1# 11# ' 1 %# ##$###%02&(2####' # #!,( #'# 2 1# 1# %#!,;#'# 1# #1 ' 1%# ##$ )'%.*-, I ## 9# ' I. ##,Z. 9# +. ' Z,+Z.Z. )'%.*+-, I ## 9# ' I. ##,.Z. 9# * -. ' KZ Z K. "## %%% 2# # 11# #2# 1# 1# 1 1#'1#'%.*-=,#;4#!2% 2##11#1#'%.*+-=, 0#Z #1###%#0 ( # ### # 1 # '% 0$ ' 7#'( # ### 1# #'#$( 2 '%###$ 1# 11# ' 1%# ##$( #'#11#1#$111'! 1# # # 11# ' 1 %# ##$(221,,1#11## #2( (#"#( ) 7#'( 2%0 & 1#'# # # #'# # # 1 25
%###$'#,-=,-.,!& #' 0# 1 #$! %# & #11#'%#'&2#& #'''01%###$#'''01%# ##$ # &# 11# #(# 11 #2###0&(##11 $' 7,, ;'% 1 1# #2 2# # # 4 3 2 1 0-1 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 2 3 4 5 6 BWA ISR NLD SDN I ' ## 9# "# ;#$ 9X#2( )X( ":<X# "#( )<"X)! ' # 5# 1 # # $ % #(2.X.*-=.*+(,X.**=.*+(B(KX.***=, # 1 1,, #,- =,-(# 12 0# ' 7#$(# 1 2### ' 1 %# ##$ 0$ # 2# #2 # 7#'( # 1####'?#%##0#')$(# & 1### # % ##%. 1'# GH# # ' # $ % ##%. 1 $ #'!1#021##'#%# #,!$( ### 0 1# #@2#A ' #$% $ ### 0 '$., 1#0?# 26
(2###02#$% $#( # # #2 # @2#A 0 ( 1 #( # '$0G%#$H1'6 G,,H*!,-&'####%# $'#0# 0 Ranking country obs median minimum r min maximum r max 1 Mongolia 5-0.60-0.64 2-0.48 11 2 Russia 3-0.59-0.63 3-0.29 55 Korea, Dem. 3 Rep. 6-0.59-0.60 7-0.55 1 4 Vietnam 6-0.57-0.61 5 1.44 95 5 Albania 6-0.56-0.60 9-0.26 57 6 Bulgaria 5-0.56-0.60 8-0.36 46 7 Singapore 6-0.55-0.57 16-0.51 5 8 Japan 5-0.55-0.59 12-0.50 7 9 Taiwan 2-0.55-0.57 18-0.52 3 10 Ivory Coast 6-0.54-0.56 21 0.09 77 110 Angola 5 1.51 0.92 114 1.82 98 111 Guatemala 5 1.70-0.45 87 3.44 114 112 Cambodia 3 1.87 1.52 117 1.96 100 113 Myanmar 3 1.94 0.54 113 2.38 106 114 Peru 5 2.03 1.09 115 3.16 112 115 Lebanon 3 2.09 1.75 118 2.49 108 116 Colombia 6 2.11 0.36 110 6.19 119 117 Sri Lanka 6 2.14-0.08 104 2.63 109 118 Philippines 5 2.32 1.14 116 3.57 115 119 Afghanistan 4 2.41 1.78 119 3.13 111 Spearman rank correlation with median ranking: 0.83 0.79 "###2#&1# # 1#'1# 2&1###$(&1###$# ' 1 1# 0 1#%# #$(' #' 1# (''' #''' 1# ( ' # & # 1# '''1#6''X#'''1#('#&# 1#''' 1#!)%' & # # 1# ' & # ''' &( # ' & # ''' &( %#0$ 27
!,-&'####'0%## Ranking country obs median minimum r min maximum r max 1 Uganda 5-0.56-0.74 1-0.42 10 2 Cuba 6-0.55-0.56 19-0.35 15 3 Mozambique 5-0.54-0.68 2-0.30 19 4 Laos 5-0.54-0.60 6-0.40 11 5 Singapore 6-0.54-0.58 10-0.48 6 6 Angola 5-0.52-0.62 4-0.48 5 7 Namibia 2-0.52-0.56 18-0.48 4 8 Gambia 4-0.51-0.53 40-0.50 1 9 Yemen, Rep. 2-0.50-0.51 48-0.49 2 10 Lesotho 4-0.50-0.54 33 0.01 47 110 China 6 0.81 0.26 113 1.12 96 111 Serbia 6 0.83-0.37 82 2.88 111 112 Poland 4 0.88-0.28 94 3.88 114 113 Argentina 4 1.15 0.32 116 1.95 108 114 Pakistan 2 1.47 1.25 119 1.69 105 115 Israel 6 1.66 0.46 117 3.38 113 116 Korea, Rep. 6 1.94-0.18 100 6.63 117 117 Russia 3 2.59-0.12 105 6.54 116 118 South Africa 6 2.65-0.35 83 6.96 118 119 India 6 3.26 0.00 110 8.38 119 Spearman rank correlation with median ranking: 0.80 0.77 "###2#&1# # 1#'1# 2&1###$(&1###$# ' 1 1# 0 1#%# #$(' #' 1# (''' #''' 1# ( ' # & # 1# '''1#6''#'''1#('#&# 1#''' 1#!)%' & # # 1# ' & # ''' &( # ' & # ''' &( %#0$ 28
!,-&'######$2## %#' Ranking country obs median minimum r min maximum r max 1 Cambodia 3-1.34-1.73 2-1.25 1 2 Iraq 5-1.13-1.25 13-0.45 19 3 Somalia 3-1.13-1.50 6-0.73 6 4 China 6-1.11-1.43 7-0.55 10 5 Myanmar 3-1.05-1.19 18-0.86 4 6 Russia 3-1.05-2.01 1-0.95 2 7 Mongolia 5-1.02-1.33 8-0.27 31 Korea, Dem. 8 Rep. 6-0.99-1.20 16-0.91 3 9 Cuba 6-0.98-1.21 15-0.85 5 10 Romania 5-0.98-1.06 29 0.98 80 110 Sweden 6 1.35 0.94 109 1.66 104 111 Denmark 6 1.38 1.22 116 1.76 110 112 Netherlands 6 1.44 0.90 107 1.69 106 113 Belgium 6 1.52 0.89 106 1.94 113 114 Norway 6 1.54 1.20 115 1.71 107 115 Bolivia 4 1.55 1.17 114 1.76 109 116 Ecuador 5 1.64 1.53 118 2.10 115 117 Israel 6 1.68 1.32 117 2.02 114 118 Italy 5 1.93 0.97 110 2.42 118 119 Pakistan 2 1.97 1.72 119 2.22 117 Spearman rank correlation with median ranking: 0.90 0.85 "###2#&1# # 1#'1# 2&1###$(&1###$# ' 1 1# 0 1#%# #$(' #' 1# (''' #''' 1# ( ' # & # 1# '''1#6''#'''1#('#&# 1#''' 1#!)%' & # # 1# ' & # ''' &( # ' & # ''' &( %#0$ 29
!,- &'# # # # ##$ 1# %#' 30 Ranking country obs median minimum r min maximum r max 1 Indonesia 5-0.86-0.92 10-0.15 17 2 Namibia 2-0.86-0.90 11-0.81 1 3 Cuba 6-0.82-0.83 25-0.43 5 4 Jamaica 5-0.79-0.82 35 0.04 30 5 Germany 5-0.77-1.15 1-0.41 7 6 Singapore 6-0.74-0.84 22-0.06 24 7 Botswana 6-0.73-0.89 13-0.42 6 8 Cyprus 1-0.68-0.68 59-0.68 2 9 Zimbabwe 5-0.67-0.86 17 2.23 111 10 Ivory Coast 6-0.66-0.83 32 1.77 99 110 Ecuador 5 0.72-0.49 84 1.11 78 Central African 111 Republic 3 0.81-0.17 106 0.81 68 112 Cambodia 3 0.91 0.14 112 1.44 90 113 Italy 5 1.02 0.13 111 2.36 113 114 Lebanon 3 1.24 0.76 116 1.79 100 115 Pakistan 2 1.37 0.55 115 2.18 110 116 Afghanistan 4 1.85 0.53 114 2.60 117 117 Niger 2 1.85 1.60 118 2.11 107 118 Bangladesh 1 1.95 1.95 119 1.95 106 119 Burundi 2 2.27 1.32 117 3.21 118 Spearman rank correlation with median ranking: 0.75 0.53 "###2#&1# # 1#'1# 2&1###$(&1###$# ' 1 1# 0 1#%# #$(' #' 1# (''' #''' 1# ( ' # & # 1# '''1#6''#'''1#('#&# 1#''' 1#!)%' & # # 1# ' & # ''' &( # ' & # ''' &( %#0$ 7 $( 2 '% 1# %# 11# ' 1 %###$2#'1G#'#%'#H## # ##! 2 '% # ' 1%# 0# % D## 1 G.**.H(# # 1%# # $G.**.H(#1##G.**KH(2;(# #2 %% $ G.*H G ;H( # %#%#$10'#1#G.**KH(2
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ln( git ) = α i + ϕt + β ln( g i, t 1) + γ ln( Z it ) + λx it + ε it 2 #4<2##%%##$1#$ %##$ [ 1##$111#\ # #'1 11#.-!0# ##%#$01'# )21'2&!0##1##10#'##4<# #1% (#01$'##$. )6&2#G.**,H.- 9##1#%1#'111#7######### ## #'11#?1###3##$%#G#.]1 0H( 2 #' 1 11# #' ## $%# # 3#( 2 '##'111#1'#%1# 32
##1% (%%#2##$% %#1'#0(2#&1':G,H( 01'#9!K,G#()''#(,KH!0# ##1%###$#1 #$%. 7$( '#'%%, #%#0###1 0#$!,K 2# #'# # '.( 2 # #'% 0 1%# ##$ # 1# #1'#.*-=,'%(22#0 ','-212#'%(##2 # 1# # 1' #.*+- =, '%! %1###1##0#1$## ##%#####'1#,K#'%1#. 94#$2#01#%###$ # 33
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
!,)#0#$## <%#04<2#%%# G.H G,H GH G-H GH GKH GH G+H G*H G.H :4<2#%%#...K., -,. - *,.K*..K G+,H G.+H G+H G*H G,H G,H GH G.,H G.H G.KH 0#'# **. *K K. * * *+ -* G,HZZZ G,HZZZ G,+-HZZZ G.KHZ G,HZZ GHZZZ G,,-HZZ G,KKHZZZ GKHZZZ G.KH $'#..,.-,,.K., -,-,.* GKKH G..,H G*H G.H G.H G,H G.*,HZ G...H G..KH G..,H %#2#,.,*,K,,* * -+ -,+,**.,+ + G-KH GKKH GH GKH G.+H G.H G.-KH GKKH G,-H GKH '##$ - - - -+ -. - * - -. G,.HZZ G.*+HZZ G.*HZ G*HZZZ G-*HZZZ GK.HZZZ G,*HZZZ G,*HZZ G,K+HZZZ G,-HZZZ 60%##.,...,.-...+ +.. +. G..,H G*H G.H G.H G*.H G.H G-H G.H G,H G..*H 9###$. -K,..*.,, -, G+H G.--H GK+H GKH G+H GH G,,HZZZ G,*HZZZ G.*HZ G.-H # $'#0#0., *..,..-,.K.K.+ GKH G.H GKH G.+HZ G.+H G.KH G.+HZ G.-H G.,.H G.-H <'$G#$IH G+H <'$GIH -, G*,H #$G52&#H - G-H 12,. G,-HZZ G.*HZ ;%#, G,H 37
9?#$., G-H 45#, G..-H 1# K- GKK,HZZZ GKHZZZ 40'#4<.* G-KH ;##.,..* **.,,..+ + ** G.-H G.-H G**H G*KH G-H G.KH G,H G.-H G,H G*H 0#.K.-.,*+,*+.*,*.,+* ;# * * *, ++ ++ + + *, *- + 7###'111# *.+ * +K. *K, + - KK -+. 0., -,.-..* ##1 ## K K. - K K +K +, 0, -, K. *, - * - -. ##10#1$ ## *,, *. K.+ K,.- -K, ++ 0 K,* K K, - K - 9## *-* *- +**- +,-,...K-.-- -,.KK 0 "##'#'#)$#'466G (.**+H(;#5###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1## ]LZZZ1##.] 38
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
!,+ #'##2%11'#'% <%#04< 2#%%# ))1 )## 6 #^"#1 :#' '##$ -. -, - G,.-HZZ G,,HZZ G.+*HZ G,,KHZZ 60%##.K.+., * G.HZ G.H G..H G+H 9###$.,, --,. GH G+*H G.HZ G+,H # $'#0#0 *., G.H GH G-*H G..H 0#,,+-,*,- ;# K + +, "##'#'#)$#'466G (.**+H!'%1##' ',#,70#$&(##'##1###0#%1### %%;#5###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.] 41
!,* '#10#$ G.H G,H GH G-H <%#0 I ## 9# ' :4<2#%%# ++.+ K. - G.HZ G+H G,,HZZZ G.,H # $'#0#0 KK* G+HZZZ 60%## K+ G*+HZZZ 9###$.K G,+HZZZ '##$.*, G,-*HZZ ;##..-.... GH G*HZZZ G-HZZZ G-*KHZZZ 0#,.,.,.,. ;#.,.,.,., 7###'111#.-,,K-,- 0., ##1## -- *K 0 KK - -+ - ##10#1$##,-K,,..K.,,. 0,,. K+ 9## +*. -,.+ -+ 0 "##'#'#)$#'466G (.**+H(;#5 ###%#(Z1##.]LZZ1##]LZZZ1##.] 42
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
%%,;#. 60 1# "'1 # 5# J1 %#$11 <''$0(.1###,### #%$10$$#%1# #2#0'#1### %%#%(2##1#0# #2!'1#1#21 ##0$ 6''%5##2##0%#$ #1%%%#1## "'1$###%#$1#1#0 11 "'1$#'#%G'#H$ 3#1%#%%#2##& 1#'#%%# ' <''$0(.1#0 # %#$I##(2'##2' #######$(#2 # '#1#1#2##$ 2####0 0# $ 1##%0'# #($##'%##($1 1' 2'% 1'##0'# # "'10# %$2% 1'11 )#& $0#'##1'#. #500#1%$1!%#10#%$##%1'# 0'#0### $#&1.('#02& ##00'#'%$##' ##0'#%##$ 4## G,,H &G,H &# G,.H &# G,.H &G,H 6 G,,H ;4G,H &G,H &G,H &# G,.H &G,H 44
%%,<%#0### 5 6 ) 7 '2# K.,. *! "#$%&'())* # $'#0#0 -K. * K, 60%## -K K.. +- ##$1#%#' -K +., K ##$2##%#' -K - *,,,K! #$+&'())* # $'#0#0 K. ** *, 60%## K...K - ##$1#%#' K +,.- * ##$2##%#' K *-.K.,- 4<%%# K +.*K- *,,K*K..- +--+, 0#'#4<# K*.K+ *-, KK %#2# +. * )$'# K,,K*+.K** -,.,- <'$G#$IH +,+ K.. <'$GIH -K. #$G52&#H +, + -*. 45# K-,.++ +K K.,. 12 -+ K..+ K ;%# -+,*.-. K 9?#$ -* K ++ 1# + +..-.-,-+,KK,, 40'#4< K,., *+.,. 45
46