,,/ V Aurthur Allen Leff M. P. Ellinghaus John E. Murray, Jr. Robert A. Hillman VI. Duty to read VII U. C. C. U. C. C.

Transcript

1 ,,/ V Aurthur Allen Leff M. P. Ellinghaus John E. Murray, Jr. Robert A. Hillman VI Duty to read VII V U. C. C. U. C. C.

2 ,,0 Aurthur Allen Leff M. P. Ellinghaus Leff John E. Murray, Jr. Robert A. Hillman Aurthur Allen Leff Leff process of contracting procedural substantive U.C.C. U. C. C. U. C. C. Leff per se unconscionability per se unconscionability

3 ,,1 Leff procedural unconscionability unconscionability drama substantive Leff oppression unfair surprise so onesided as to be unconscionable clause oppression unfair surprise Leff Leff Leff form contract quasifraud

4 ,,2 quasiduress Leff overall imbalance Leff overall imbalance unconscionable Leff gross imbalance lopsidedness quantification clausebyclause Leff

5 ,,3 Leff illiterates specific performance Leff Williams v. WalkerThomas Furniture Co. IV. Y necessity luxury

6 ,-* majority minority Leff M. P. Ellinghaus Ellinghaus meaninglessness Ellinghaus rule standards residual categories shadowy illusory

7 ,-+ Leff Ellinghaus Leff residual illusory Leff Ellinghaus Leff Ellinghaus misleading inequality Leff Leff Ellinghaus insulate Ellinghaus Leff i ii unfair

8 ,-, i ii misleading bargaining conduct Leff Ellinghaus Leff Leff unfair surprise Leff unfair surprise Ellinghaus unfair surprise surprise misleading Ellinghaus

9 ,-- Ellinghaus Ellinghaus Leff underprivileged consumer presumptive sillies Leff exploitation of the underprivileged Ellinghaus Leff class

10 ,-. Ellinghaus Speidel Ellinghaus insulation overall imbalance the question of insulation Leff Leff Ellinghaus per se unconscionability Ellinghaus Leff

11 ,-/ standard residual category Leff Leff overall imbalance Leff Ellinghaus Campbell Soup Co. v. Wentz II. Ellinghaus component Ellinghaus Leff John E. Murray, Jr. Leff Ellinghaus

12 ,-0 Murray Murray Murray circle of assent apparent assent material real assent reasonable man risk surprise

13 ,-1 Murray materiality of risks U. C. C. oppressive onesided unfair unreasonable Murray hardship Murray volition

14 ,-2 oppression Murray Murray Speidel Robert A. Hillman Hillman Hillman manipulate covertly Leff Hillman bargaining unfairness assent

15 ,-3 Hillman Hillman fairness Hillman Hillman

16 ,.* Hillman pure unconscionability VI

17 ,.+ Campbell Soup Co. v. Wentz V U. C. C. U. C. C. V Ellinghaus U. C. C. V Hillman IV U. C. C. Brower

18 ,., Duty to read

19 ,.- Williams consent consent unequal bargaining power Barnhizer Barnhizer UCC

20 ,.. UCC Barnhizer UCC covert hazy Williams classical school neoclassical school formalism

21 ,./ formalistic rigid Samuel Williston Classical contract law S. Williston legal realism context multidisciplinary Arthur Corbin Karl Llewellyn UCC UCC UCC UCC

22 ,.0 Morant Morant context

23 ,.1 distributive justice U. C. C. Morant UCC

24 ,.2 UCC Duty to read Duty to read Joseph Perillo CALAMARI &PERILLO ON CONTRACT

25 ,.3 duty to read duty to read true assent duty to read duty to read duty to read Duty to read

26 ,/* UCC duty to read standardized agreement duty to read CALAMARI & PERILLO ON CONTRACT oppressive unfair indecent duty to read standardized agreement duty to read duty to read

27 ,/+ duty to read CALAMARI & PERILLO ON CON- TRACT duty to read duty to read duty to read VII

28 ,/, Williams duty to read

29 ,/- I unconscionable

30 ,/. doctrine of unconscionability U. C. C.

31 ,//

32 ,/0 U. C. C. Brown, supra note at. U. C. C. Philip Bridwell, The Philosophical Dimensions of the Doctrine of Unconscionability, U. Chi. L. Rev., ; Leff, supra note at, note. Leff Ellinghaus Murray Hillman

33 ,/1 Leff, supra note. Unconscionability Leff, id. at Id. at per se unconscionability Leff, supra note at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at M. P. Ellinghaus, In Defense of Unconscionability, Yale L. J.. Ellinghaus, id. at Id. at Id. at Leff, supra note at Ellinghaus, supra note at Id. at Id. at Leff, supra note at Ellinghaus, supra note at Id. at

34 ,/2 Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at. Id. at, note Id. at Richard E. Speidel, Unconscionability, Assent and Consumer Protection, U. Ptt. L. Rev.. Ellinghaus, supra note at Leff, supra note at Ellinghaus, supra note at Id. at Id. at Id. at John E. Murray, Jr., Unconscionability : Unconscionability, U. Pitt. L. Rev.. Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Speidel, supra note at..speidel Murray U. C. C.

35 ,/3 materiality reasonable man reasonable Murray assent Robert A. Hillman, supra note. UCC A Hillman, id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at Id. at VI. Spanogle, supra note at. Spanogle

36 ,0* WHITE & SUMMERS, supra note at Brown, supra note at Hillman ROBERT A. HILLMAN, PRINCIPLES OF CONTRACT LAW nd ed., UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE : WITH ANNOTATIONS FROM STATE AND FEDERAL COURTS, Prior Art., to ; A, unequal bargaining power Daniel D. Barnhizer, Inequality of Bargaining Power, U. Colo. L. Rev., Id. at consideration

37 ,0+ FARNSWORTH, supra note at n. Farnsworth Samuel W. Williston Arthur L. Corbin FARN- SWORTH, supra note at BRIAN A. BLUM, CONTRACTS : EXAM- PLES AND EXPLANATIONS th ed., Section.. at ;JOHN EDWARD MURRAY, JR., MURRAY ON CONTRACTS TH ed., section at ;FARNSWORTH supra note at ;JOSEPH PERILLO, CALAMARI & PERILLO ON CONTRACT, section. at th ed., ; NICHOLAS MERCURO & STEVEN G. MEDEMA, ECONOMICS AND THE LAW : FROM POSNER TO POSTMODERNISM AND BEYOND ded. Princeton Univ. Press Hillman neo formalism contextualism ROBERT A. HILLMAN, THE RICHNESS OF CONTRACT LAW : AN ANALYSIS AND CRITIQUE OF CONTEMPORARY THEORIES OF CON- TRACT LAW, Chap. BLUM, supra note at. Blake D. Morant, The Salience of Power In The Regulation Of Bargain : Procedural unconscionability And The Importance Of Context, Mich. St. L. Rev.,,. Ralph James Mooney, The New Conceptualism in Contract Law, Or. L. Rev.,. Mooney

38 ,0, wellbeing Morant, supra note at. Brooke Overby, Contract, in the Age of Sustainable Consumption, J. Corp. L.,. Morant, id. at. Bridwell, supra note at note. Morant, id. at., note,. Morant crudely awkwardly Richard H. McAdams, Cooperation and Conflict : The Economics of Group Status Production and Race Discrimination, Harv. L. Rev.,,. crude misconception Morant Morant, id. at Id. at note ;Mooney supra note at. Mooney

39 ,0- Morant, supra note at Anthony T. Kronman, Paternalism and the Law of Contracts, Yale L. J.. Anthony T. Kronman, Contract Law and Distributive Justice, Yale L. J.. Morant, supra note at Id. at Id. at Schmitz, supra note at Id. at John E. Murray, Jr., Contract Theories and the Rise of Neoformalism, Fordham L. Rev.,. David Horton, Flipping The Script : Contra Proferentem And Standard Form Contracts U. Colo. L. Rev., ; Carol Van Sambeek, The Four Corners Approach To Judging The Enforceability Of Arbitration Agreements, Which Waive Statutory Rights To Litigate Employment Discrimination Claims appalachian J. L., ;Daniela Caruso, Symposium : Aals Section On Contracts : New Frontiers In Private Ordering : Contract Law and Distribution in the Age of Welfare Reform, Ariz. L. Rev. Schmitz, supra note at. Duty to read PERILLO, supra note ; Alan M. White and Cathy Lesser Mansfield, Literacy and Contract Stan. L. & Pol y Rev

40 ,0. duty to read duty to read PERILLO supra note at PERILLO supra note at. Weaver v. American Oil., Ind., N.E.d ; Williams v. WalkerThomas Furniture Co. ; Henningsen v. Bloomfield Motors, N.J., A.d PERILLO supra note at. White and Mansfield, supra note at. I

41 ,0/

42 ,00