2. Presentations and discussions

Transcript

1 CODE 3 rd SE Europe Regional Workshop Nicosia, Cyprus 25 May 2010 WORKSHOP REPORT Table of Contents 1. Aims Presentations and discussions Conclusions... 4 Annexes: Aims The CODE project is an EU wide independent assessment of the progress of the Cogeneration Directive. The project partners and COGEN Europe members will encourage the rapid and effective implementation of the Directive and independently review the Member States progress and the success of implementation. CODE will highlight and publicize clear best practice where it occurs and draw attention to areas of poor performance or practical difficulties in implementation. The CODE SEE Regional meeting in Nicosia on 25 May 2010 is part of a Europe wide initiative to accelerate the implementation of cogeneration across Europe. This Cypriot event is targeted at monitoring further the implementation process of the Cogeneration Directive in Member States in SEE, namely Bulgaria, Cyprus, Greece, Romania and particularly to the Cypriot Energy audience. Involving in workshop format experts and interested parties are encouraged to put their views, making sure that their interests are 1

2 represented in this Europe wide programme. It should be added that this Workshop was co-organised by Cyprus Energy Regulatory Authority (RAEK) and HACHP, with the support of Electricity Authority of Cyprus, which offers its Conference Room for the Workshop and the Cyprus Energy Office. The working language of the Workshop was Greek as the participants were from Cyprus and Greece. 2. Presentations and discussions 1. Welcome address by G. Siammas, President of RAEK After welcoming all participants of the workshop on cogeneration in Cyprus, Mr Siammas mentioned that this is the first one organised in the country and expressed the great interest of the Regulator in cogeneration and how these type of systems are treated in other countries. 2. Cogeneration in SEE Results from CODE project By: C. G. Theofylaktos, Hellenic Association for Cogeneration of Heat and Power Mr Theofylaktos presented an extensive data for each of the four Member States, based on the results from a standard qualitative template, designed during the course of the implementation of WP2. This template in its initial stages presented general data of each Member State (Member State area and population, Member State GDP, installed electricity capacity and production, etc). Also it included relevant information regarding their economic development, their natural resources (oil, gas, fossil fuels, etc), the existing energy prices, the regional cooperation in energy issues and the existing interconnections as well as the recent status of the liberalisation of their energy markets with attention to Cyprus and Greece. This was due to the fact that only representatives from these two counties attended this regional meeting. 3. Cogeneration in Cyprus Existing situation By: Marilena Delenta, Officer, RAEK Organisation Ms Delenta explained the current situation of cogeneration in Cyprus, with focus on smallscale cogeneration systems, using as fuel biomass mainly wastes from pig and chicken farms, as those are the most common cogeneration systems in the island, except the one large scale cogeneration plant in the cement industry of about 5 MWe. 2

3 4. Legal framework for cogeneration in SEE Focus on Greece and Cyprus By: C. G. Theofylaktos, Hellenic Association for Cogeneration of Heat and Power Mr Theofylaktos presented an extensive data for each of the four Member States, based on the results from a standard qualitative template, designed during the course of the implementation of WP2. This template in its initial stages presented general data of each Member States (i.e. Member State area and population, Member State GDP, installed electricity capacity and production, etc). Also it included relevant information regarding their economic development, their natural resources (i.e. oil, gas, fossil fuels, etc), the existing energy prices, the regional cooperation in energy issues and the existing interconnections as well as the recent status of the liberalisation of their energy markets with attention to Cyprus and Greece. This was due to the fact that only representative from these two counties attended this regional meeting. 5. Methodology for calculating the electricity, related to fuel consumption and primary energy savings due to cogeneration By: Christos Frangopoulos, Professor at Department of Naval Engineering National Technical University of Athens. Professor Frangopoulos gave a lecture titled A method for performance evaluation of cogeneration systems, based on the newly-published Ministerial Decree 1420/ of Greek Ministry for Development, on the methodology for calculating the CHP electricity and the harmonised reference values. The lecture was divided into 5 parts. The first one was on the fundamental definitions of the terms and it was based on those in Directive 2004/8/EC. The second one was on the calculation of the electricity from cogeneration P, based on the method for calculating C, the PHR. The third chapter was dealing with the calculation of the Primary Energy Savings (PES) both for cogeneration and noncogeneration part of a cogeneration system. Next, the lecture presented cogeneration systems with auxiliary or supplementary firing. Finally, Prof. Frangopoulos gave two examples of cogeneration systems; one with gas engine and the other a combine cycle where the PES were calculated and vital conclusions were obtained. 6. Presentation of cogeneration systems with biomass in Cyprus 3

4 By: Anthi Charalambous, Director of Cyprus Energy Office Ms Charalambous presented in details the cogeneration projects with biomass pig/chicken wastes operating in Cyprus. She explained that there are about 10 small-scale cogeneration units in operation of the same kind and she visited almost all of them discussing their operation and possible problems with their owners. 7. Two cases of small scale CHP units with fuel biomass By: George Armenis and Marios Theodorou The two operators of the two cogeneration units explained in details their installations, the existing procedures for obtaining the operation permits, their continuous efforts of accepting these units into UN CDM mechanisms and the existing problems. More details are given in their presentations. 3. Conclusions and recommendations The meeting where more than 50 people participated is considered as a successful one. Especially with the participation of leading parts of the energy sector, e.g. from Regulator, the TSO, the main electricity provider, etc. The meeting has provided good insight in the development of the cogeneration in Cyprus. The cogeneration Cypriot market is new, with many different problems, as for example no existence of NG, no knowledge of the technology by the technical world, so the use of animal wastes can be an acceptable solution for the energy system of the country. The Workshop was concluded with the willing of the majority of the participants to work for the establishment of the Cypriot Association for Cogeneration of Heat and Power in the near future. The Cypriot Energy Efficiency Office is going to organize the future actions. All presentations are on the web sites of CODE and of the HACHP Annexes: Agenda of the workshop List of participants Photos 4

5 AGENDA OF THE WORKSHOP Nicosia, Θέμα Ομιλητής 08:00 08:30 Προσέλευση συμμετεχόντων 08:30 08:40 Χαιρετισμός εργασιών Γιώργος ιαμμάς Πρόεδρος ΡΑΕΚ 08:40 09:10 ΗΘ στη Νοτιοανατολική Ευρώπη αποτελέσματα του Ευρωπαϊκού συγχρηματοδοτικού προγράμματος CODE 09:10 09:40 ΗΘ στην Κύπρο αποτύπωση της υφιστάμενης κατάστασης 09:40 10:10 Νομοθεσία ΗΘ στην Ελλάδα Υποστηρικτικοί μηχανισμοί στην Ελλάδα και σε άλλα κράτη μέλη 10:10 10:30 Διάλειμμα για καφέ 10:30 11:00 Μεθοδολογία ενεργειακής αξιολόγησης μονάδων ΗΘ 11:00 11:20 Μελέτες περίπτωσης ΗΘ στην Κύπρο Κώστας Θεοφύλακτος Πρόεδρος Ελληνικού υνδέσμου υμπαραγωγής Ηλεκτρισμού Θερμότητας Μαρία-Ελένη Δελέντα Λειτουργός Ενέργειας ΡΑΕΚ Κώστας Θεοφύλακτος Πρόεδρος Ελληνικού υνδέσμου υμπαραγωγής Ηλεκτρισμού Θερμότητας Χρίστος Φραγκόπουλος Καθηγητής ΕΜΠ Ανθή Χαραλάμπους Ενεργειακό Γραφείο Κυπρίων Πολιτών 11:20 11:40 Μελέτη Περίπτωσης ARMENIS FARM Ltd 11:40-12:00 Μελέτη Περίπτωσης Mintikkis & Andreou Biopower Ltd Γιώργος και Κώστας Αρμένης Μάριος Θεοδώρου NPRO Engineering Ltd 12:00 12:30 υζήτηση - συμπεράσματα 5

6 FINAL LIST OF PARTICIPANTS Εργαστήρι με θέμα τη Συμπαραγωγή Ηλεκτρισμού Θερμότητας (ΣΗΘ) στην Κύπρο Τρίτη, 25 Μαΐου 2010, στα κτίρια της ΑΗΚ στην αίθουσα ELECTRON NAME ORGANISATION POSITION TEL FAX 1. ηέιηνο ΑΖΚ Γεληθόο Γηεπζπληήο ΑΖΚ ηπιηαλνύ 2. Βεληδέινο ΑΖΚ Γηεπζπληήο δηθηύωλ Δπζπκίνπ κεηαθνξάο 3. Αλδξέαο ΑΖΚ Βνεζόο Γηεπζπληήο Πνπιιηθάο Έξεπλαο θαη Αλάπηπμεο 4. Ηωάλλεο ΑΖΚ Ζιεθηξνιόγνο Μεραληθόο Υαηδεπαζράιεο 5. Υξίζηνο Γηαρεηξηζηήο Βνεζόο Γηεπζπληήο Σνπθεμήο πζηήκαηνο Μεηαθνξάο Κύπξνπ 6. Μαξία Λνίδνπ Σκήκα Πεξηβάιινληνο Λεηηνπξγόο Πεξηβάιινληνο

7 NAME ORGANISATION POSITION TEL FAX 7. Γξ Πάξεο Παλεπηζηήκην Δηδηθόο Δπηζηήκνλαο Φωθαϊδεο Κύπξνπ 8. Γξ Αιέμαλδξνο Σκήκα Λέθηνξαο Υαξαιακπίδεο Πεξηβάιινληνο ΣΔΠΑΚ 9. Υαξάιακπνο Γξαθείν Δπηηξόπνπ Δπίηξνπνο Πεξηβάιινληνο Θενπέκπηνπ Πεξηβάιινληνο 10. Γηώξγνο Αλδξένπ Αθνί Αλδξένπ Υνηξνζηάζηα Ληδ Γηεπζπληήο Γεκήηξεο G & AF Energy Ltd Γηεπζπληήο d.f.afxentiou@cytanet.com.cy Απμεληίνπ ηαύξνο Λαγόο. Π. Λαγόο Φαξκ Γηεπζπληήο iaco@cytanet.com.cy Ληδ 13. Γξ. Κπξηάθνο Εελίζ ύκβνπινη Γηεπζπληήο / Μεραλνιόγνο tsiftes@cytanet.com.cy Σζηθηέο Μεραλνιόγνη Μεραληθνί Μεραληθόο 14. Διέλε παλνύ Εελίζ ύκβνπινη Μεραλνιόγνη Μεραληθνί Μεραλνιόγνο Μεραληθόο tsiftes@cytanet.com.cy 7

8 NAME ORGANISATION POSITION TEL FAX 15. Γεώξγηνο Τπνπξγείν Λεηηνπξγόο ΜΣΔΔ/ Καθνπιιήο Παηδείαο θαη Πνιηηηζκνύ Μεραλνιόγνο Μεραληθόο νθία Δκκαλνπήι Τπνπξγείν Δθπαηδεύηξηα Κωηνύια Παηδείαο θαη Πνιηηηζκνύ Μεραλνινγίαο Αλαζηάζηνο Ζιηνθώηνπ, Γηεπζπληήο ηαζήο Εηληέξεο, ηαζήο πλέηαηξνη Κπξηάθνο Ζιηνθώηνπ, Γηεπζπληήο Εηληέξεο Εηληέξεο, ηαζήο πλέηαηξνη 19. Πέηξνο Σκήκα Γεωξγίαο Α. Αλ. Πξνϊζηάκελνο Μαπξνκάηεο Κιάδνπ Υνηξνηξνθίαο - Πηελνηξνθίαο Θενδώξα Ηωάλλνπ Σκήκα Πεξηβάιινληνο Λεηηνπξγόο theioannou@environment.moa.gov.c y 21. Κώζηαο Αλδξένπ ΣΔΠΑΚ Δηδ. Δθπ/θηθό Πξνζωπηθό andreou.kostas@gmail.com 22. Γηώξγνο Κνύξηεο ΑΖΚ Ζιεθηξνιόγνο Μεραληθόο georgekourti@eac.com.cy 8

9 NAME ORGANISATION POSITION TEL FAX Έξεπλαο θαη Αλάπηπμεο 23. Διέλε Βαξβάθε ΑΛΑ Υεκηθόο Μεραληθόο Βίθηωξαο ΑΛΑ, πκβνύιην Αλώηεξνο Σερληθόο Κωλζηαληηλίδεο Απνρεηεύζεωο Λεκεζνύ Ακαζνύληαο Δπζύκηνο Α. Μηληίθθεο Φαξκ Οηθνλνκηθόο Γηεπζπληήο Μηληίθθεο Ληδ 26. Παύινο Σζηάξηαο Ηλζηηηνύην Κύπξνπ Δξεπλεηήο Αλζή Δλεξγεηαθό Υαξαιάκπνπο Γξαθείν Κππξίωλ Πνιηηώλ 28. άββαο Βιάρνο Δλεξγεηαθό Γξαθείν Κππξίωλ Πνιηηώλ 29. Μαξία Ηωαλλίδνπ Δλεξγεηαθό Γξαθείν Κππξίωλ Πνιηηώλ Γηεπζύληξηα / Δλεξγεηαθόο Λεηηνπξγόο / Δλεξγεηαθή Γηαρείξηζε θαη / Δθπαίδεπζε 9

10 NAME ORGANISATION POSITION TEL FAX 30. Γηώξγνο ηακκάο ΡΑΔΚ Πξόεδξνο Κωλζηαληίλνο ΡΑΔΚ Αληηπξόεδξνο Ζιηόπνπινο 32. Κύπξνο ΡΑΔΚ Μέινο Κππξηαλίδεο 33. Μαξία-Διέλε ΡΑΔΚ Λεηηνπξγόο Δλέξγεηαο Γειέληα 34. Νίθνο Γξάθνο ΡΑΔΚ Λεηηνπξγόο Δλέξγεηαο Παλίθνο Κειίξεο ΡΑΔΚ Λεηηνπξγόο Δλέξγεηαο Κξπζηάιιω Εωκελή- Παληειίδνπ 37. Δπζύκηνο Κωλζηαληίλνπ 38. Υξήζηνο Νηθνιαϊδεο 39. Μηράιεο Φαζνπιίδεο ΡΑΔΚ Λεηηνπξγόο Δλέξγεηαο ΑΖΚ Ζιεθηξνιόγνο Μεραληθόο y ΑΖΚ Β.Γ.Δ.Π

11 NAME ORGANISATION POSITION TEL FAX 40. Γηώξγνο ΑΖΚ Δθηειεζηηθόο Γηεπζπληήο Πεηνύζεο Κώζηαο Διιεληθόο Πξόεδξνο Θενθύιαθηνο ύλδεζκνο πκπαξαγωγήο H Θ Γξ Υξίζηνο Δζληθό Μεηζόβην Καζεγεηήο caf@naval.ntua.gr Φξαγθόπνπινο Πνιπηερλείν Θενθάλεο Γ../ΔΖΘ Μεραληθόο Πεξηβάιινληνο fanis@moumtzis.gr Μνπκηδήο Δηδηθόο Γξακκαηέαο 44. Α. Αβξακίδεο ΑΖΚ Δθηειεζηηθόο Γηεπζπληήο Γηθηύωλ 45. Βεληδέινο ΒΔΝΗΕΔΛΟ Ληδ Γηεπζπληήο venizelos@cytanet.com.cy ηαύξνο 46. Κξίζηεο Τπνπξγείν Μεραλνιόγνο Μεραληθόο giallouros@hotmail.com Γηάιινπξνο Δκπνξίνπ, Βηνκ/αο θαη Σνπξηζκνύ 47. Υαξάιακπνο ΑΖΚ Γηεπζπληήο Αλζξωπίλνπ cpericle@eac.com.cy Πεξηθιένπο Γπλακηθνύ 48. Μάξηνο NPRO Engineering Γηεπζπληήο/ύκβνπινο mt@npro-engineering.com 11

12 NAME ORGANISATION POSITION TEL FAX Θενδώξνπ 49. Υξίζηνο ΑΖΚ Βνεζόο Γηεπζπληήο Υξηζηνδνπιίδεο Οηθνλνκηθώλ 50. Αλαζηάζηνο ΔΖΘ/ Μεραλνιόγνο Μεραληθόο Σόζηνο Γξακκαηέαο 51. Κπξηάθνο Θενράξνπο Kruger-Cybarco Υεκηθόο Μεραληθόο

13 Photos from the Workshop 13