008 6 6 :0006788 (008) 06003008 a,, a, b, c ( a,b,c, 7009 ;, 700) :,,. : ; ;.. : ; ; ; : C9 ;C939 ;F3 ;F83 : A Game analysis of four interest group s coalition in Chinese regulated real estate market HUAI Jianjun,,LIU Xinmei,LEI Hongmei,ZHANG Fan (Xi an Jiaotong University,Xi an 7009,China ;Northwest A&F University, Yangling 700,China) Abstract : To answer how central government resolve the question that interest group coalitions have induced rising price of housing in Chinese regulated real estate market, based on the cooperative game method, we investigate the conditions of single, two and three and fourcoalition, the optimal coalition form and profit distribute vectors maintaining coalitions among local government,central government,land agents and international speculators. We find that : the conditions of regulated or anti regulation coalition are determined with the relationship between net profit from regulation and average net profit from market movement ; the optimal coalition form depends on the comparing the sum of four payoff from the same type of strategy with the sum of welfare waste from anti regulation ; individual profit distribute vectors for maintaining coalition are determined with individual payoff and welfare waste from anti regulation. Central government should build and maintain regulation coalition to overthrough anti regulation coalition. Key words : real estate market ;coalition ;cooperative game ;government regulation 0,,., 007 5 70 06,005 8, [ ]., [ ],, ; [3, ].,,,,,.,, [5 ]. [6 ], :00700 : (707307) ;985 (070070) :(97 - ),,;(96 - ),,,. 99-009 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
6 3 [7 ], [8 ]. () [9 ], [0 ].,. [ ]., [,3 ],. [,5 ] [6 ] [7 ] [8,9 ], [0, ],.,,;, ;. [ ][3 ],, ;, ;, ; ;. : () ( ) ( ),,,,3,. :c,dc, t, t (0 t, t ),p, p (0 p p ). b, b (0 b, b ), r (0 r ), A (0 A ). :,,,3,. A,, A,, ( t c - p, ( t + b ) ( c + dc) ). B,, B,,( t c - p, ( a + t ) ( c + dc) ). C,, C,,( rc, r( c + dc) ). D,, D,, ( Ac,A ( c + dc) ). i (,,3,) a u i, u ( u =,)., ;,, i q i, q i = Q.,, 6., I, S, IS S, V, MIN l, MAX r., MIN l MAX r,,, ; MIN l MAX r,. i, j, k, l =,,3,,, i j k l, i, j, k, l,.. ( ). 99-009 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
S 3 008 6 IS ( ) {,3,} MIN l {} BCD BCD BCD BCD BCD BCD BCD BCD A a a - q a - q 3 a - q 3 - q a - q a - q - q a a - q - q 3 a - q - q 3 - q - q 3 - q - q A a - q a - q - q a a - q - q 3 - q - q 3 a a - q - q a - q - q - q - q - q - q a - q - q a - q 3 - q 3 - q - q - q - q 3 - q MAX r a - a + q,a V = a - q - q - q 3 - q - q 3 - q a - a + q,a - q - q - q 3 - q V = a - q - q - q 3 - q : v ({ i}) = a i - q j, if a i j = - a i + q i 0, ( i j k l ) a i - Q, if a i - a i + q i ; 0, ( i j k l ) a i - a i + q i a i i a i - q i. ( ). S IS ( ) {3,} MIN l {,} CD CD CD CD () AB a + a a + a - q a + a - q 3 a + a - q 3 - q a + a - q 3 - q AB a + a - q - q a + a - q - q - q a + a - q - q - q 3 a + a - Q a + a - Q MAX r a - a + q,a - a + q,, a + a - q 3 - q ; a - a + q,a - a + q,, a + a - Q : v ({ i, j}) = 99-009 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net V = a + a - q 3 - q V = a + a - Q a i + a j - q k - q l, if a i - a i + q i 0, a j - a j + q j 0, ( i j k l ) a i + a j - Q, if a i - a i + q i ; 0, a j - a j + q j ; 0,( i j k l ), a ij - a ij + q ij a ij i j a ij - q ij. 3,, : v ({ i, j, k}) = a i + a j + a k - 3 q l,if a i - a i + 3 q i 0, a j - a j + 3 q j 0, a k - a k + 3 q k 0, ( i j k l ) a i + a j + a k - 3 Q,if a i - a i + 3 q i ; 0, a j - a j + 3 q j ; 0, a k - a k + 3 q k ; 0, ( i j k l ), a ijk - a ijk + 3 q ijk a ijk i j k a ijk - 3 q ijk. () (3)
6 33,V ( <) = 0, V ( I) = v ({ i, j, k, l}) = a i, if a i - a i + q i 0, ( i j k l ) a i - Q, if a i - a i + q i ; 0,( i j k l ), a i - a i + q i a i i a i - q i. V,() () : v ({ i}) = v ({ i, j}) = i, j = v ({ i, j, k}) = a i - 3 Q, Π a i - a i + q i 0 a i - Q, Π a i - a i + q i ; 0 3 a i - 6 Q, Π a i i, j = - a i + q i 0, a j - a j + q j 0 3 a i - Q, Π a i i, j = - a i + q i ; 0, a j - a j + q j ; 0,() (7) (8) (9) : 3 a i - 3 Q, Π a i - a i + 3 q i 0, a j - a j + 3 q j 0, a k - a k + 3 q k 0 3 a i - Q, Π a i - a i + 3 q i ; 0, a j - a j + 3 q j ; 0, a k - a k + 3 q k ; 0 v ( i, j, k) i, j = v ( i, j, k) V ( I) V ( I) v ( i, j) V ( I) i, j = v ( i, j, k) v ( i, j, k) V ( I) i, j = i, j = 99-009 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net v ( i, j) v ( i) i, j = v ( i, j) V ( I) v ( i, j) v ( i), Π a i : 3 Q ; v ( i), Π 3 Q v ( i, j), Π a i ; v ( i, j, k) 3 v ( i), Π v ( i), Π a i 3 Q ; 3 Q ; a i Q ; a i ; Q ;, ;,. : ;.. 3 [ I,V ]n, x = ( x, x,, x n ), C() = { x : x X () ; V ( S) - x ( S) 0, S < I}. : n x i = V ( I), i s x i = V ( S). () : () (5) (6) (7) (8) (9)
3 008 6 v ({ i}) = a i - q j j = x i ; (0) a i - Q x i v ({ i, j}) = a i + a j - q k - q l x + x ; () a i + a j - Q x + x v ({ i, j, k}) = v ({ i, j, k, l}) = a i + a j + a k - 3 q l x + x + x 3 ; () a i + a j + a k - 3 Q x + x + x 3 a i x + x + x 3 + x a i - Q x + x + x 3 + x (0) (3) i ( ) : 3 a i - j = a i - Q x i. (3) q j x i a i + 3 q i. () i [ V ] ( i N),. n ( N,V), i ( v),, i i [ V ] = S ( i S) ( S - )!( n - S )! [ V ( S) - V [ S \ { i} ] ], n! S., i ( v) : ( v) = ( v) = 3 ( v) = ( v) = a - Q + 6 q + 6 q 3 a + 6 a + 6 a 3 + 6 a - a - Q - 6 q 3 + 3 q - 3 a + 6 a + 6 a 3 + 6 a - a 3 - Q + q 3 3 a 3 + 6 a + 6 a + 6 a - a - 3 Q - q 3 - ; (5) 7 6 Q 3 q 6 q + q 3 a + 6 a + 6 a 3 + 6 a - ; (6) 7 6 Q ; (7) 7 6 Q. (8) 7 6 Q,,,,.,.,,,., (), (), (3) () :, 99-009 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
6 35,,,,;., a i, a i - q i.,,p, p b, b ;, t, t, dc, c, r,a ; q i.,(8) (9) :,.,,,, ;,,,, ;,,,.,,,, ;,,,.,,,., a i ; 3 Q, :,.,,,,;,,,;, ;,,. 3 Q a i 3 Q, :,.,,; ;,,;,. a i : 3 Q, :,.,, ;,;,,,,;., a i ; Q,:,., ;,,, ;,. a i Q,:,., ;,,,. 99-009 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
36 008 6,() 3 :,., a i - q j x i a i + 3 q i,, a i - Q x i., j = q j i,i ;3 q i j = i,i ; Q., q j,3 q i Q, i j =. a i, a i.,(5) (8) :, ;,., a i, a i,,. 5,.,,. :,,,,.,,, ;,,,.,, :,; ;,.,,. : [ ] [ EBΠOL ].,House.focus. cn,007-06 - 8. Eight Ministries and Commissions Investigate the Reason of Some Continuous Rising Price of House from Nonmarket factors[ EBΠ OL ]. House.focus. cn,007-06 - 8. [ ]. [ EBΠOL ].,http :ΠΠwww. sina. com. cn,005-03 - 7. Sun L P. Building the Mechanism of Differentiation and Game of Benefit Is More Fundamental than Others[ EBΠOL ]. Chinese New Weekly,http :ΠΠwww. sina. com. cn,005-03 - 7. [ 3 ]. [ EBΠOL ].,http :ΠΠwww. eeconomic. com,006 - - 3. Sun L P. The Year of the Game of Benefit[ EBΠOL ]. Economic Review of Eastern Asian. http :ΠΠwww. eeconomic. com,006 - - 3. [ ]. [ EBΠOL ].,005-06 - 7. Sun L P. China Have A Great Time of Benefit Games[ EBΠOL ]. The International Forum of Government Transition and Building Harmonious Society,005-06 - 7. [ 5 ] Sherpherd W G,Wilcox C. Public Policies Toward Business[M]. Homewood Press,979. [ 6 ] Meier KJ. Regulation : Politics,Bureaucracy,and Economics[M]. New York St Martins Press,985. [ 7 ] []. [M]. :,989. 99-009 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net
6 37 Stigler GJ. Industrial Organization and Government Regulation[M]. Shanghai : Shanghai San Lian Press, 989. [ 8 ] Ginsburg D. A new economic theory of regulation : rent extraction rather than rent creation[j ]. Michigan Law Review, 999,97 (6) :77-779. [ 9 ] Baron D P. Serviceinduced campaign contributions and the electoral equilibrium[j ]. Quarterly Journal of Economics,989,0 :5-7. [0 ] Laffont JJ, Tirole J. The politics of government decisionmaking : A theory of regulatory capture [J ]. Quarterly Journal of Economics,99,06 :089-7. [ ] Laffont JJ, Tirole J. A Theory of Incentives in Procurement and Regualtion[M]. Cambridge : MIT Press,993. [ ] Crew M A,Kleindorfer P R. Regulatory economics :Twenty years of progress? [J ].Journal of Regulatory Economics,00, :5 -. [3 ],. [J ].,006,6 :57-63. Huai J J, Liu X M. The application of principalagent model in regulation research[j ]. Economic Review,006,6 :57-63. [ ],. [J ].,003,5 :0 -. Peng F P,Fang Q Y. The game analysis between real estate agency and local government[j ]. The Engineer of Value,003,5 :0 -. [5 ],. : [J ].,006,3 :7-75. Chen G,Fan Y. The price of real estate rising under asymmetrical information : The theoretical analysis of a dynamic game model based on the asymmetrical and incomplete information[j ]. Economic Master,006,3 :7-75. [6 ],. [J ].,005,0 :3-30. Ma H J,Mu L L. Control and analysis on nonlinear house price game model[j ]. Complex Systems and Complexity Science,005, 0 :3-30. [7 ]. [J ].,005,8 :3-7. Zhou J K. Asymmetric information, belief and financial supportive excess - A game theory analysis of real estate bubble [J ]. Finance & Trade Economics,005,8 :3-7. [8 ]. [J ].,006, : - 3. He Y B. The game analysis among developer in the real estate market[j ]. Inquiry into Economic Issues,006, : - 3. [9 ],. [J ].,006,6 :7 -. Yang Y Q, Sun Y Y. The feasibility analysis of small and middling size corporation coalition s loan based on the game theory[j ]. Market Modernization,006,6 :7 -. [0 ]. [J ]. (),006,3 :98-0. He Y B. A game theory analysis on developer, local government and consumers in real estate market [J ]. Journal of Beuing Technology and Business University(Social Science),006,3 :98-0. [ ],. [J ].,00, :30-0. Yang J R,Sun B Y. Development path for policy factors and the real estate market in China - government, developer and customer[j ]. The Study of Finance and Economics,00, :30-0. [ ] ().. [M]. :,000. An analysis with game theory on Nash J. The Corpus of Game Theory From Nash[M]. Beijing :Capital Economic & Commerce University Press,000. [3 ],,. [J ].,007, :3 -. Huai J J,Liu X M,Lei H M. The game analysis of the four person alliance and attack in Chinese regulated real estate market[j ]. Systems Engineering,007, :3 -. 99-009 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. All rights reserved. http://www.cnki.net