University of Huddersfield Repository Theocharakis, S., Katsougkrakis, I., Goulidakis, B., Papalexi, Marina and Tsigkas, A. Lean Hospital and study of implementation to a provincial hospital Original Citation Theocharakis, S., Katsougkrakis, I., Goulidakis, B., Papalexi, Marina and Tsigkas, A. (2009) Lean Hospital and study of implementation to a provincial hospital. In: 5th National Conference on Management, Economics and Health Policy, 2-5 December 2009, Athens, Greece. This version is available at http://eprints.hud.ac.uk/19048/ The University Repository is a digital collection of the research output of the University, available on Open Access. Copyright and Moral Rights for the items on this site are retained by the individual author and/or other copyright owners. Users may access full items free of charge; copies of full text items generally can be reproduced, displayed or performed and given to third parties in any format or medium for personal research or study, educational or not-for-profit purposes without prior permission or charge, provided: The authors, title and full bibliographic details is credited in any copy; A hyperlink and/or URL is included for the original metadata page; and The content is not changed in any way. For more information, including our policy and submission procedure, please contact the Repository Team at: E.mailbox@hud.ac.uk. http://eprints.hud.ac.uk/
.,, ι ι,,
1.ι -ι ι!ι 2. "!ι
1.ι -ι ι!ι.ι #.ι ι.! ι-!ι- #. ι$ ω 2. "!ι
&!$ ι ιι ι!$!'ι : - ιιι - # : (ι ωι ) #ι "ιι )(ι ιω )ι -! " *ω ι!ι$! ι! (ω TQM,reengineering.)
+ ω ) *ι ι ' ι$ ι )ω * "ιι, ι ) 'ι ι ι!ι *$ ι ι!ι " ι ι#
ι ι!ι lean management ω o #'ι ) ω &-& ( Toyota production system- T.P.S) Spears S., Bowen H.K, Harvard Business Review, Sep-Oct 1999 Sobek D.K et al, Harvard Business Review, Jul-Aug 1998 + lean management #ι "!$ ι ι lean healthcare ι lean hospital Womack J. et al, IHI Calls, Jan-Feb 2005 Bahensy J.A et al, Journal of Healthcare Information Management, 2005
Lean hospital ι lean healthcare ι! ω ι ) ι, ι *$ ' ι!$! ι$ ι ι $ ω ι*$ ι)ι ι ι ι ι ι" ι
Lean hospital ' ι)ι 8.700.000 2.832
Lean healthcare ' ι)ι 579.000 306
Lean healthcare ι ι ι (lean) ι!ι;
Lean healthcare υ! "#$%#& υυ!"#$%&'()*+,-.v%.0,a#a2%".*3445
1.ι -ι ι!ι.ι #.ι ι.! ι-!ι- #. ιω ω 2. "!ι
. ι / ι #ι!! 1902- Sakichi Toyoda, ) ι ω ι ι (Jidoca). 1930- Taiichi Ohno, ι ι ω * ω ι ω!ι, "!ι Just In Time (JIT). Jidocaι JIT $ Toyota Production System ι lean management. Womack J., Jones D., Roos D., The machine that changed the world: the story of Lean production, NY,1990 www.lean.org/whatslean/history.cfm
TOYOTA Production System 'ι,ι!ι'ι 0ιι ι ι " ι 'ι * # # " $ % & ' $ ω ω 1ι ) '! #ι "' Spears S., Bowen H.K, Harvard Business Review, May 2004
1.ι -ι ι!ι.ι #.ι ι.! ι-!ι- #. ιω ω 2. "!ι
ι! ι «&» '( ) *( + υ,( + -( + 6)7%88.9&o".;a$*7o%";6o88%&&%o"7o<9"a$o"=<a$%;>a"?@aA.;>*,a>3445
(# ) 5 & '(./ ) *(. 0 ),( 1υ B*C C D) E F ) #(. υ C GH ) Womack J. and Jones D.T., Lean Thinking, NY, 1996 www.leanuk.org/articles/leanthinking
(# ) 5 &./.0. υ 1υ 1
# $ 2 3/υ4 υυ( 2 2υ 5υ65 //υ 4υ( va9:;<=>;a??a@
7 * (" ) '( A5! *( B 5 5!,( -( 3 C! #( Bυ D/! E( + 5! "( 5FA.! M.Hoel, E.M.Saether, Journal of Health Economics, July 2003 S.Mathieson, The Health Service Journal, March 2003
+ # -&ι -ω ω *$ -,! * - POKA-YOKE - ι*$ - - Just in time - - ι!ι -,! - KAIZEN -" 3 Value stream -2ι ι$ -33 - T -0ι - 5S-TAKT TIME -& ι ι Pavnaskar S.J Gershenson J.K, Jambekar A.B International Journal of Production Research, Sep 2003 www.leanadvisors.com/lean/tools/lean-management
# (- ) 1BGAHI1)AFJK1I L.FJ31B1FI+F MJ1FI1BGFIMI1IBJ3KG +AJK1I 1BN3AGFMK1I1 +ANAOKG 1I+AJLHMI1I1.LOI3I1 3G)G POKA$YOKE BFLA.JOAKMI1I FB.L.LJI1IAMN1J1 BFL+FL$.LJI1I VWXTINTIME 2JF]I NMINLMA1NA1 NIFML.LB 2JHAJMJ1I1 #X$ TAKTTIME 1BGAHI1MLI NANLGLFKAI^EN L+2A13JL+2J3I AMN1J G_LM,$`AaWE XTbEAM
& # ' # ' ( ', " ι,! ι $), ' -) 3 ι $'-' '. $$! ' "# (.!. TQM). (lean) ι ι ι"ι C.Calkins, J. Sviolka, Harvard Business Review, Dec 2007
Lean Healthcare 1"'ι ι # ; (Lean Healthcare)
;
;
' # "!
1.ι -ι ι!ι.ι #.ι ι.! ι-!ι- #. ι$ ω 2. "!ι
, # "! I 5 / υ 6)7J,,!-@KL*+)M!N!-*+)O)@KN!OJJ*7o%";6o88%&&%o"7o<9"a$o"=<a$%;> a"?@aa.;>*,a>3445 L!M,PLO)*7o<9"a$8a"a#.8.";,.?%Q%".*RSST 000)$.a"a?v%&o9&)Qo8U(.a"UV.a$;'Qa9.Ua9;%Q$.&U$.a"W'.a$;'Qa9.W9.&<$;&)QA8)
. Virginia Mason Medical Centre
1.ι -ι ι!ι 2. "!ι
/ 1ιω, * -ι ι *,
. # ι 3,
0 ( 1 0 ι ) $ " 1953 ω ι 21 4!ι ι 4, ι 27!! 382 * " 582-66% )ι ' $ 2
3 ( + 4* ) FL+.LBA]AF1OI3GGAFL1 '-ccc MJO+L11OAGKG '*ccc 'cccc dccc Eccc -ccc *ccc FL+.LB A]AF1OI3G c *cc- *cc# *cce AFL1
0,! 200 382
-#- KATANOMH Y.5+60 23% 65% 12% I.Y.....
/ 1ιω, * -ι ι *,
/ : " ι " ι *ι ιι! ι$ ι ) 3, ι ι ι
/ 1ιω, * -ι ι *,
/ " : &ι *! ) ι" ι * " ι )!.
/ 1ιω, * -ι ι *,
/ "# : 1. 1ω ι ιι 2.,)ι * ι ' ι! ι 09/06 ω 12/07 3. 45 * 25 ' ι 4. 2* # ω MEDLINE ι CINNHALL 5. 1" ω-!ι$ lean healthcare 6. 4 case studies " lean healthcare
!" lean healthcare 4 " ##!ιι!,ι!ι " * )!ι ιω ιι$ (1)
Lean Healthcare ι $ ι ι " ιι!ιι )!
T ) ω ιιι$ ω ιo)ι ι ιιω* ι )ι #* ι #
& # ($) ι ( ( 3-5 ) "ιιω ι ( (2-3 )... ι " ι.. - ι (7-8 ), ω " * ) ι$ (ι "ι$-ι ) (7-9 ) ( ι ι ) ιι (15-17) 1ι)ω ιι * ) " ι ω (3-10 ) * * ) (5-10 ) 1 * ) ι ι ι*ι (15-25) ι " *$ (5-15 )
! "* * 5 +2 +7 + ιι * ι 1 $ ι 2 ω 1 $ ι 42. ι ω ι"ι! ι ι ) *!ιι! ιι!ι ι 5 ω 6 $.
! " ( $) O * ι ι ι.! ι ι ι $ ω ω' ι. 0!ι ιι!$! ι!. &!ω!$ ι ι ι!ι #ι. ιι $ι ι " : ι, $, ),. -!ι "ι.
# * h d(cc((. g J g A d(*c$d(*#(( Dg I3N d(*#$d(-c(( A ( $ 3/ %(#c$''(*#(( N 3 d(#c$%(-c(( d(-c$%(,c(( F 3 'c(cc$''(,c(( + 'c(cc6'c(,c6''(cc 2AGFIMAJFJ.MLFAMJLFIFNJFLB1 ef.ml1a.a+)1iff1oagaj1
. # - J+LI ijj I(3(N(j A]AF1I d(*cf$ d(*#f (( 3FJGL$ NM_J d(-cf$ d(-#f (( $ 3/ d(-#f$ %(-#f(( FL.LOAF I1I1A 3JGI 'c(ccf (( J+LI ijj I(3(N(j A]AF1I d(*cf$ d(*#f (( 3FJGL$ NM_J d(-cf$ d(-#f (( $ 3/ d(-#f$ %(-#f(( FL.LOAF I1I1A 3JGI 'c(ccf ((
Lean Healthcare. -&
! * ' # -&ι -ω ω *$ -,! * - POKA-YOKE - ι*$ - - Just in time - - ι!ι -,! - KAIZEN -" 3 Value stream -2ι ι$ -33 - T -0ι - 5S-TAKT TIME -& ι ι Pavnaskar S.J Gershenson J.K, Jambekar A.B International Journal of Production Research, Sep 2003 www.leanadvisors.com/lean/tools/lean-management
+ " VALUE STREAM MAPPING 35&6 A3 TIME
Value Stream Map (VSM) ι ι!!ι ι ι ι!ι ι ω'ι ι * ι ι ι!ι #ω ω ιιι$
Value Stream Map (VSM) ι ι: 1 5 #ι # 1 * ι! ι (ι,!ι, ) * ι! ι # ) # (* ι) 4ι )ι ιι ω ω ι!ω
Value Stream Map( )
Value Stream Map.MLAFLJ+ 1J I3N$ J1FLMJ3L J+LIiJ 3FJGL$ NM_J NM_AJL 3JGI1I1 3M2JL$ LNL1 GJ1OI1J LLNL1 FL.LOA$ FI1I 1A 3JGI
Value Stream Map,-3&. = /. / &7. /. = 827/ 1097,-3&.&, 76&3&, = 1918 (CYCL1 TIME) 00 & 0.0.,. 1 /. &1&-3 & 82 / 191= 42,9%
!!3 )!ι!ι ι * " ) 3(11*17)
!!3 ()
!!3 +/! (HEME):&ι * ι ιι!ιι )! ) ι ω *$. 8!5(BACKGROUND): ι "ι * ιι!ι *!ι ι ιι!ι ** ι #ι *ω ι! ι ι, ι *.
!!3!5!,!!!. (CURRENT CONDITION) '!%'2/* :%.4$! :%/%2&$1 $%* 7*,%&,/1%8'( 9:#,7%&'#-* +,;#* ( )' *4%*! ( &%):%&:2, '"*2,*% 47%&' ' 7ω,2$*( *-ω!#*%:,4:*'!:%8'(<-)+.*'%,)+.*'% " +.*'%(= >* $?#.* 47%&'(! "#$%&'( %&)' *% +,-*%./%0+ *% ' *$1$*%./%0(,)!'!*$23, % '$ $4, )! *-34"*3,0 *'#ω666 N G
*, @ &$,2$*0$*0 '-%'%$%+%!* +40! +*'2$*0<4' 0!'% '.+&$2, 0= '!%'2!47,*' " $%8'%:,ω) '!%'2< +!1+ * 3,0=$% +*'%.%/*+ '!%'2/* %:%41$1$% +,;#* :1 '%$%+! & : " $"* ι; ι $ 'ι. ι; ι!ι ωι ι ι ιι ι. ι; ι ι ωι!ι ι #ι. & : " ι; ι ) ι (1 " ) ι ) ι " (ι ). ι; ι!ι. ι; ι *ω ιι ι ιιω * )ω ω ) ι ι ι ι. & : ι; ι ι $ ι!. ι; ι $! )! ι. ι; ι # ι ιι.
, (ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS)!# ' ι!ιι! " ι ι. + #* * ι ω *$ $. ' 9 ι.
(TARGET CONDITION)! ) *$ ιι!$. ι ι$. ι ι! ι ιι ι "., ι! ι ι ) * ' ι ι ι ) # ι ι ι.
# ( (IMPLEMENTATION PLAN): FJk.LJL1k.LFAk.LFAA1+ XYZ[IX \][^_`^Y]abYc[I ^d^_`[i ey^izifba `^Y][I]_Yca cdyfyca RRUD bxib[`][fa ^gi\a]^baa\xfh X\[^fXfXZ^fa 3 [ XcbYf[d[_Yc[ ey^izifba XcbYf[d[_Yc[I 3RUD XcbYf[_]XiYX XZ^fhf`h]Y XfXj[fa \][_]XjjXbYj[ cdyfhf \][kbxj^fa cdyfyca RRUD _]a_[]ab[\[z^baa XZ^fhfb[ c]^lxbyb[i 3L1FI ^g[exeyxj[]ihameajy[i]_yx XYZ[IX^d^_`[I \][h\yc[cxy3ja`xfajx R)444*44j^n)444*44o e^fi\x]`^y^\y\d^[fc[b[ 3AM2I1A*FL.LBKMA1LJ1OAGAJ1OAHLBGFAAJK1AJABHMJ1FI+AGLJg FLJ2JL3JFL.ML1K.J3L(
Follow up,! ι "ι * )!ι * #ι. ι 2 2,5 $ ) *ω ι # ι ι!. : * ι follow-up! * * ι.
!, /+!ι ' ) ι ι!, TIME = (!+/ 450/!5/!+060, ω : 60*4/6=40/"
!, /+ TAKT time ) ι ) ι ι *ωι ι()!ι' ι.!= 4 ## /!, 2!=82 /40=2,5 2
!, /+ I_c]Ya`][f[IbXcbj^`][f[Ij^cXY`h]YXgYXb[I \][^_`^Y]abYc[I^d^_`[Ipb)c)q3D4 UsqD4 t 70 60 450 + +! 50 40 30 20 10 0 38 20 10 37,5 6,5 5,5 6&1&.,..3&&.& 651.&.3,, 60.&&&, 3.,:,.&&&, 20 30 7,5 16 &&:1,,1.3 7;6., /. 1 /.
!, /+. 0ιι$* ι 3 ι 5 # 1 # ι ω ι!. * 1, 2 ι 4 # 1 )! 1 ω:ιι ) ω )!* ) ι ιι $ # ι )ι!
!, /+ 0ι!ω # ι $ + " 0ιι$ " " ι* * '
/ 1ιω, * -ι ι *,
! /! 30 3 ' 25 125% ω 50% "ι ιι ι * ι ι ι #ι ω ω *$ιω ω, $ 2 +$ * ι! ωι ) ι!
!'. "*, ι ). *, ) ι * ω ω!ω ι$ ω ιι - 3
/ 1ιω, * -ι ι *,
ι ( " ι ι ιι "ι ) ι!ι!ω ι$! &ι, ι * ι ι " ι!ι #
«- ι "ι, ι ι ι ιωι ι!ι *ι».&.- 1958 ω ι ι! ω *$ω # ι #ι ω ι$ ω ι ι $ι ιι$ #ι$ω!$ - www.who.int/library/collections/historical RODOLFO SARACCI, BMJ, May 1997
$2 #' #* ' #.
!ιω 1υ5