=7WV v q $I t 7{YBjs } B` { }B tb n(( w1((1d *ezen!_ewq!3 V *ypyqvn 7ypWVN _i!]e77!i w*7_d V7e* ]<V!qy] ]!=Wy]Vqy!W 7O7qe Gyq< e_<v7y7!w ynyqvio V Ny]Vqy!W7 Ak $IRY$}8st WBsY 3 i II jj ]jsrr BP 1((1 =t$ I 7s R Ws%sj V{sI 8k Vtts}Bj$R s kjsti ] $h{s$bt BP VI%$R R V}} B%sj VRRB{$s _ BP RRB e $, Bjj sy 8s${R * }s 8 t ]*i qysii ZR G j{y yyy =7W ej { ${sj et$t $t * }s 8 t V{{ }st{ PB Y q $I t 7{YBjs ]B88$ _ BP RRB FBk{ e 7YsI * }Zk *$ {B BP i R s {Y m 7{YBjs RY$} =7WVTdxndT1
REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE Form Approved OMB No. 0704-0188 Public reporting burder for this collection of information is estibated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing this collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burder to Department of Defense, Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports (0704-0188), 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington, VA 22202-4302. Respondents should be aware that notwithstanding any other provision of law, no person shall be subject to any penalty for failing to comply with a collection of information if it does not display a currently valid OMB control number. PLEASE DO NOT RETURN YOUR FORM TO THE ABOVE ADDRESS. 1. REPORT DATE (DD-MM-YYYY) 07-05-2002 2. REPORT TYPE 3. DATES COVERED (FROM - TO) xx-xx-2002 to xx-xx-2002 4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE 5a. CONTRACT NUMBER Development of a digital signal processor (DSP) based chaotic Communication System 5b. GRANT NUMBER with Emphasis on Military Applications 5c. PROGRAM ELEMENT NUMBER Unclassified 6. AUTHOR(S) Reddell, Noah F. ; 5d. PROJECT NUMBER 5e. TASK NUMBER 5f. WORK UNIT NUMBER 7. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME AND ADDRESS U.S. Naval Academy Annapolis, MD21402 9. SPONSORING/MONITORING AGENCY NAME AND ADDRESS, 12. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY STATEMENT APUBLIC RELEASE, 13. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES 14. ABSTRACT See report. 15. SUBJECT TERMS 16. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF: 17. LIMITATION OF ABSTRACT Public Release a. REPORT Unclassified b. ABSTRACT Unclassified c. THIS PAGE Unclassified 18. NUMBER OF PAGES 111 8. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION REPORT NUMBER 10. SPONSOR/MONITOR'S ACRONYM(S) 11. SPONSOR/MONITOR'S REPORT NUMBER(S) 19. NAME OF RESPONSIBLE PERSON email from USNA, Annapolis, MD, (blank) lfenster@dtic.mil 19b. TELEPHONE NUMBER International Area Code Area Code Telephone Number 703767-9007 DSN 427-9007 Standard Form 298 (Rev. 8-98) Prescribed by ANSI Std Z39.18
REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE Form Approved OMB No. 074-0188 Public reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including g the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of the collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burden to Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington, VA 22202-4302, and to the Office of Management and Budget, Paperwork Reduction Project (0704-0188), Washington, DC 20503. 1. AGENCY USE ONLY (Leave blank) 2. REPORT DATE 7 May 2002 3. REPORT TYPE AND DATE COVERED 4. TITLE AND SUBTITLE Development of a digital signal processor (DSP) based chaotic communication system with emphasis on military applications 6. AUTHOR(S) Reddell, Noah F. (Noah Freeman), 1981-5. FUNDING NUMBERS 7. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 8. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION REPORT NUMBER 9. SPONSORING/MONITORING AGENCY NAME(S) AND ADDRESS(ES) 10. SPONSORING/MONITORING AGENCY REPORT NUMBER US Naval Academy Annapolis, MD 21402 Trident Scholar project report no. 300 (2002) 11. SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES 12a. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY STATEMENT This document has been approved for public release; its distribution is UNLIMITED. 12b. DISTRIBUTION CODE 13. ABSTRACT: Chaotic systems are aperiodic, deterministic, and sensitive to slight variations in initial condition. The latter property presents the problem that behavior of the system cannot be predicted for a significant period of time, even though for the next instant, it is completely predictable. The frequency domain and time domain properties of chaotic systems have generated interest in the military communications field. This paper explores the advantages of a communication system based on a chaotic carrier for military purposes. Digital signal processing techniques are used to implement the system, perform frequency domain analysis, and generate system performance curves. A series of computer simulations were used to enhance system performance. A digital transmitter was developed that is difficult to localize and detect by exploiting some of the natural properties of chaotic systems. A new dual synchronizing receiver scheme is demonstrated that works by storing samples over an entire bit period prior to estimation. Results show significantly better bit error probability performance in comparison to previously published methods. Research concentrated on developing a system that works effectively without a comspicuous signature in the frequency domain. Such a system should be extremely useful for cover wireless communications. 14. SUBJECT TERMS: Chaos communication, digital signal processing, Lyapunov exponent, dual synchronizing response system 15. NUMBER OF PAGES 111 16. PRICE CODE 17. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF REPORT 18. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE 19. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF ABSTRACT 20. LIMITATION OF ABSTRACT NSN 7540-01-280-5500 Standard Form 298
d! " # $! % " " & ' % ( )! ' % ' ) ' * $ ' % ) +! $ ' *, ' " -! '. / 0 1 2 3 4 +! )
1! " # # # $ % & ' ( ) * * * +! # " $,! -!! $ #! "! ( $ #.! # & ( /! $ 0 1 2 $ 3! # $ 3 #! ( ( $ 4 ' 5, 6 & & 7 8 9 ( (. $!! : $ 3 ; " & & + $ # ( $, 8 4! 1 <! 8 - #! ; $ = #!!! - (! / > # #! (! $ 8!! & ( +! $ 0 -? 8 4 (!! ( $, = = '! &? $ 2 < &!! $ ' < ( - ; & + / ( & ( ; " $,! $
n ]Bt tr d yt BIZ{$Bt E dd GYk ]YsBR2 E d1 _ B` { pbsjr 1 ]YsBR 1d * 8$t$R${ 7kR 8R 11 7 tr$$% * } ti t{ Bt yt$$sj ]BtI$$BtR dd 1n * tr! A$R dd 1; ]YsB${ V s{b R d1 n ]B88Zt${s$Bt 7{Y 8 dx nd _s s8 BIZjs$Bt dx n1 *$R{ y8}j 8 ts$bt de nn y8} B% 8 tr de ; 7kt{Y Bt$9s$Bt 1( ;d * $% T i R}BtR ]BZ}j$t AsR I Bt _s s8 7 s{y B $R8s{Y 1d ;1 Nks}ZtB% 3Zt{$Bt VtsjkR$R BP 7sA$j$k 1n x qy Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t 7 s {Y 1x xd er$8s$t Y Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t Ak Y zs $s$btsj ejzs$bt YBI 1E x1 pbsjr PB Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t 7 s {Y 1 xn i RZjR BP Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t 7 s {Y 1 E _s s8 7}s{ 7 s {Y PB y8} B% I $ et k nn Ed y8} B%$t $ e B _ BAsA$j$k nn E1 ]B% _ PB 8st{ ]BtR$I s$btr nx ]Ysjj t R BP s *$R{ <s Ibs 7kR 8 nm d q -sr ytr Z8 tr :]Edd *$$sj 7$tsj _ B{ RRB nm 1 q R ejz$}8 t n
M $ e B _ PB 8st{ ;; Md Bt ]s jb e B ]BZt$t ;; Mdd $ et k sti WB$R _Bb 7} { sj * tr$k ;x Md1 $ e B is ]BthI t{ ;E M1 ]Ystt j 7$8Zjs$Bt ;E Mn i RZjR BP $ e B _ BAsA$j$k 7$8Zjs$BtR ;M Mnd =t -} { I 7BZ { BP e B R s <$Y ;M ]Ys s{ $9$t 3 JZ t{k *B8s$t _ B} $ R x1 d 7$tsj ]s8bz4s x1 1 3 JZ t{k *B8s$t srz 8 tr $t <s Ibs x1 d( NBb 3 JZ t{k V tzs$bt ]Ysjj t R Ed d(d W s T*] V tzs$bt BI j E1 d(1 <s Ibs 7kR 8 V tzs$bt E1 ; dd ]Bt{jZR$Bt ddd ]YsB${ ]B88Zt${s$Bt 7kR 8 _s $sjjk y8}j 8 t I dd1!z!% sjj _s s8 7 j {$Bt YBI ddn _ BAj 8R PB Y PZZ d d d 1 V WZ8 ${sjjk 7Bj%$t *$& t$sj ejzs$btr Vd WZ8 ${sj YBIR B 7Bj% *$& t$sj ejzs$btr M V1 3BZ Y! I izt T Zs M( =R$t ]B8}$j I ] ]BI $t Y VqNV et%$ Bt8 t M1 d V $ P * R{ $}$Bt BP e 3Zt{$Bt * % jb}8 t M1 1 V 7$8}j - 3Zt{$Bt M; ] BIZjs$t PB _ B}ss$Bt M ]d qy <$ja q strpb 8 sti Y Vtsjk${ 7$tsj M ]1 7$tj 7$I AstI BIZjs$Bt M * _ B` { ]BI 1 *d sr${ *7_ * $% 7kR 8 1 *dd ]BI PB *$$sj B VtsjB ]Bt% 1 *d1 i T;x VjB $Y8 n *dn NB t9 7kR 8 x *1 sr${ *7_ i R}BtR 7kR 8 E *1d ]BI PB ]!*e] E *11 NB t9 7kR 8 b$y ]BZ}j$t M *n ]BI PB VqNV R$8Zjs$BtR *nd V p t ${ NB t9 7kR 8 3Zt{$Bt *n1 Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t Ak zs $s$btsj ejzs$bt YBI d(1
*nn $ et k 7 s {Y d(e *n; $ e B _ BAsA$j$k 7$8Zjs$Bt d( x
E ]Ys} d yt BIZ{$Bt ]YsBR YsR sjbskr -$R I AZ $ BB, s t b } R} {$% B % sj $ yt } B{ RR R P B8 R{$ t$h{ -} $8 tr B % k Isk j$p Y srrz8}$bt $R BP t 8sI Ys $P s RkR 8 $R Rs I ZtI R$8$js $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR $ b$jj } BIZ{ R$8$js RZjR yt Ps{ b 8s, Y$R srrz8}$bt BP t tbzy PB $ B A s, t PB st I 3B -s8}j Y 8} sz BP s {Y 8${sj s{st {st t % A 8 srz I -s{jk V {Y 8$R s{{ }R Y$R j$8$s$bt srrz8$t JZsj$$ R j$, s{$bt $8 b$jj %s k Btjk Rj$Yjk IZ B 8 srz 8 t B yt Y de(:r eibs I NB t9 $I t$h I s {sr by Y$R srrz8}$bt I$I tb bb, sti A {s8 Bt BP Y h R %$R$Bts $ R $t Y t b h ji BP ]YsBR B -}jb byk yt {YsB${ RkR 8R R8sjj %s $s$btr $t $t$$sj {BtI$$Bt {st j si B RZARst$sjjk I$& T t BZ{B8 R 3B Y$R srbt by t % 8 srz 8 t B -$RR Y Rs BP % t b jj ZtI RBBI {YsB${ RkR 8R {sttb A } I${ I R$t$h{stjk $tb Y PZZ GY$j RZIkT $t b sy 8BI jr eibs I NB t9 PBZtI } Ys}R Y 8BR b jjt,tbbt sti {B88Btjk -} $ t{ I -s8}j BP Y$R $I s G sy PB {sr R Ys% s I$^{Zjk 8s,$t s{{z s PB {srr 8B Yst s P b IskR $tb Y PZZ qy$r $R Z tb 8s YBb 8stk BAR %s$bt Rs$BtR s s%s$jsaj B YBb BP t 8 srz 8 tr s {B I I qy b sy RkR 8 $R BB {B8}j - sti BB R tr$$% B R8sjj {Yst R >dh NB t9 I R{ $A I $ sr Y Z 4k e& { qy$r $I s $jjzr s R Ys s AZ 4k 4s}}$t $R b$tr Y s Y Ws%sj V{sI 8k 8sk % tzsjjk sti % t js$% jk JZ${,jk s& { Y b sy s{ BRR Y jba dd GYk ]YsBR2 qy $I s Ys stky$t {st A {sj{zjs I $t {jbr I PB 8 b$y tbzy $tpb 8s$Bt sti {B8T }Z$t }Bb IB R tb s}}jk B {YsB${ RkR 8R qy PB s }s si$8 RY$P P B8 Y {Bt% t$btsj s}} Bs{Y BP R{$ t{ $R JZ$ I B {B8}Z$t }Bb sti 8B RB}Y$R$T {s I 8 srz 8 t {Yt$JZ R Btjk $8} B% t s T 8 } I${sA$j$k qy jbtt 8 Rs BP {YsB${ RkR 8R R$jj {sttb A {sj{zjs I qy$r $R tb sjbskr s } BAj 8 WBb Ys 8sY 8s${$stR sti BY R{$ t$rr s jbb,t $t PB sti RZIk$t {YsBR s tz8a BP $t R$t } B} $ R BP Y R RkR 8R s A $t I$R{B% I VR {BZt $tz$$% sr $ h R R 8R Y s s tz8a BP srbtr byk {YsB${ RkR 8R 8sk s{zsjjk A ZR PZj $t Y h ji BP {B88Zt${s$Bt
yt R $t Y h ji BP {YsBR $R Bb$t $t s{si 8${ {B88Zt$$ R sti 8$j$s k R s {Y BZ}R yt Ps{ Y V 8k i R s {Y!^{ wvi!d YsR Bt sr Ps sr B { tjk ts8 {B88Zt${s$Bt b$y Ikts8${sj RkR 8R Bt BP $R R % t s sr BP {Bt{ t s$bt >1H VjRB Y!^{ BP Ws%sj i R s {Y w!wid ZtR s {Bt$tZ$t } B s8 $t% R$s$t Y ZR BP tbtj$t s Ikts8${R $t{jzi$t {B88Zt${s$Bt Bt {YsB${ {s $ R ]YsB${ RkR 8R Ys% s tz8a BP R} {$sj } B} $ R Ys s bb Y $t% R$s$t PB {B88Zt${s$Bt T V}}s t istib8t RR $t Y q$8 T*B8s$t T ]YsB${ RkR 8R jbb, stib8 $t $8 A {szr Y k s ABY s} $BI${ sti ABZtI I qy$r } B} k $R bb Y -}jb $t PB {B% t RR T WsZ sj 7kt{Y Bt$9s$Bt T qbb {YsB${ RkR 8 {st A 8sI B Rkt{Y Bt$9 b$y s{y BY js$% jk sr$jk 7kt{Y Bt$9s$Bt Z tr BZ B A PB Z$BZR PB { s$t s {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 sti $R s PZtIs8 tsj JZ$ 8 t PB BZ RkR 8 B bb, T yt R$t ]Bt Bj V}}j${s$BtR T 78sjj $t4z t{ R s}}j$ I $t jj$ tjk {st I st 8s${sjjk $t4z t{ s {YsB${ RkR 8 s,$t R8sjj si`zr8 tr s B}}B Zt 8B8 tr 8sk sjjbb PB Y sa$j$k B {Bt Bj js s8bztr BP t k qy$r {BZjI A % k ZR PZj PB s Y$YT}Bb str8$ GY$j Y$R $I s $R tb I$ {jk -}jb I $t Y$R } B` { RB8 {Yt$JZ R b I % jb} {st A sis} I!t JZ R$Bt Ys P JZ tjk {B8 R Z} $R YBb IB R Y$R RkR 8 {B8}s B R} si R} {T Z8 {Yt$JZ R2 VP sjj Y s RB8 s}}s t R$8$js $$ R BY RkR 8R ZR }R ZIBT stib8 {Yt$JZ R sti str8$ b$y t k I$R $AZ I B% s b$i P JZ t{k st qy } $8s k I$& t{ $R Y 8 YBI Ak by${y Y {s $ R$tsj $R t s I G -}jb Y js$btry$} A b t Y R bb {Yt$JZ R PZ Y y:r sjbskr BBI B k t b s}} Bs{Y R B Y Rs8 } BAj 8 7} si R} { Z8 RkR 8R Ys% RB8 I$RsI%sts R _ Ys}R s {YsB${ RkR 8 b$jj sii RR Y 8! sr b RZRT } { {YsBR 8$Y A A R PB R} {$h{ s}}j${s$btr srrt8s, } RBtsj {B88Zt${s$BtR $R } BAsAjk tb Bt BP Y 8 d1 _ B` { pbsjr!z $t$$sj PB{ZR $t I % jb}$t BZ {YsB${ {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 bsr B $8} B% Y strt 8$ :R {B% t RR yt % k 8$j$s k {B88Zt$k Y $R RB8 ZtstRb I t I B } % t st B}}Bt t P B8 jb{s$t Bt :R str8$ G$Y RstIs I str8$rr$bt RkR 8R j {T Bt${ bs Ps {Yt$JZ R Ys Ys% A t $t ZR PB 8stk k s R {st sr$jk }${, BZ s si$b str8$rr$bt P B8 Y RZ BZtI$t tb$r sti I IZ{ $R }BR$$Bt qy R RkR 8R s sjrb j P 8B %Zjt saj B `s88$t R$t{ Y k {Bt{ t s Y $ t k s BZtI Bt {s $ P JZ t{k err t$sjjk sjj $ s, R B `s8 s str8$rr$bt $R B B% }Bb Y sj str8$ qy 8 {B88Btjk ZR I PB Y$R RskR $ sjj Y t k JZ$ I B `s8 $R {sjj I AZ ty BZY
G s 8} B Y$I s str8$rr$bt Ak Aj ti$t $ b$y Y As{, BZtI qy$r JZs R B Y$I$t Y str8$rr$bt t k A jbb B {jbr B Y -$R$t tb$r 4BB VtsjkR$R sti %$RZsj$9s$Bt BP Y$R } B{ RR b$jj 8s, Y $I s 8B {j s $t {Ys} G I R$t sti $t% R$s BZ RkR 8 b$y Y $I s BP {s8bz4s $t 8$tI yt Y ti 8B $8 $R R} t sti 8B BP BZ $t R$t RZjR js B Y {Ysjj t R BP I$R{ jk t s$t {YsBR $8} B%$t RkR 8 } PB 8st{ sti {Ys s{ $9$t Y & {R BP I$& t }s s8 R M
]Ys} 1 ]YsBR Fs8 R OB, B& I st $t $Z$t ts8 Ys BB, YBjI PB Y I$R{$}j$t } %$BZRjk P I B sr tbttj$t s Ikts8${sj RkR 8R qy ZR BP Y bb I {YsBR B $$ts I P B8 Y$R dx }s} X_ $BI qy y8}j$ R ]YsBR">nH qy 8s$tR s P b I$& t $B BZR I ht$$btr BP Y 8 YBb % 7 % t 7 Bs9 B& R s b$i jk s{{ } I {BjjBJZ$sj I ht$$bt < -T }js$tr X{YsBR $R s} $BI${ jbtt 8 A Ys%$B $t s I 8$t$R${ RkR 8 Ys -Y$A$R R tr$t $% I } ti t{ Bt $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR">;H ]YsB${ RkR 8R I % jb} s{{b I$t B I 8$t$R${ js$btry$}r AZ s}} s B A Ys% stib8jk qy JZs$BtR Ys I R{ $A RZ{Y RkR 8R {st jbb, I { $%$tjk R$8}j qy s jbbt B I {YsB${ RkR 8R sr b jj sr Y$YTB I Bt R 7Z } $R$tjk % t jbbtb I {YsB${ RkR 8R -Y$A$ ${Y %s $ k sti A sz$pzj {B8}j -$k 7$8}j JZs$BtR {st Ys% {B8}j${s I A T Ys%$B R qy RkR 8 I }${ I $t 3$Z 1d PB -s8}j $R,tBbt sr Y NB t9 V s{b qy$r {YsB${ RkR 8 $R RB Ps8BZR $t Y h ji Ys st $8s BP Y AZ 4k b$tr: {st A PBZtI $t tz8 BZR }ZAj${s$BtR st$t P B8 R} {$sj$9 I }s} R B }B}Zjs 8ss9$t R qy NB t9 RkR 8 $R Y s%$jk ZR I Y BZYBZ Y$R } B` { y $R bb YbY$j B -}js$t s{y BP Y } B} $ R Ys 8s, Z} {YsBR 1d * 8$t$R${ 7kR 8R!t PZtIs8 tsj {Bt{ } PB s}} {$s$t {YsB${ RkR 8R $R Ys Y k s tb AsR I Bt stib8 } B{ RR R GY t {YBBR$t A b t bb }syr s s PB, s stib8 B RB{YsR${ } B{ RR bbzji {YBBR Bt AsR I Btjk Bt RB8 } BAsA$j$k WB I ht$ } I${$Bt {st A 8sI!t Y BY YstI B h Y I ht$$bt sab% {YsB${ RkR 8R 8ZR A I 8$t$R${ yp Y k -$R $t s I$R{ R}s{ s 8s} {st js Bt Rs B Y t - yp Y k s {Bt$tZBZR s PZt{$Bt {st I R{ $A Y 4Bb qy PB,tBb$t tbzy sabz s RkR 8:R Rs sti YBb $ I % jb}r b {BZjI -s{jk } I${ bys }sy $ b$jj s, B P JZ tjk b t{bzt {YsBR b$ybz,tbb$t s PZt{$Bt B 8s} Ys I R{ $A R YBb $ I % jb}r =R$t Y b sy sr st -s8}j ss$t Y RkR 8 $R BB A$ sti YsR BB 8stk %s $saj R B A b $ t IBbt $t Y PB 8 BP st JZs$Bt NB t9:r RkR 8 $R 8 jk s 8BI j PB Bt BP 8stk } B{ RR R qy NB t9 JZs$BtR 8BI j Y {Bt% {$Bt sti Bjj$t BP s 4Z$I A $t Y s I s Y ABB8 BP s {Bts$t sti {BBj I s Y B}
d( 45 40 35 30 z(t) 25 20 15 10 5 40 20 y(t) 0 20 40 20 15! 10 5 x(t) 0 5 10 15 20 * ht$$bt 1dd W b \?",?#, 3 3 3 i W {YsB${ d \?",?#, 3 3 3 i _?" * ht$$bt 1d1 3$ %% % P % %% ; b& 3$ %% {YsB${ d 3$ %%, 0 ( 3$ %% %%
11 7 tr$$% * } ti t{ Bt yt$$sj ]BtI$$BtR dd qy R {BtI sti JZsjjk $8}B st } B} k BP {YsB${ RkR 8R $R R tr$$% I } ti t{ Bt $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR qy {BtR JZ t{ BP Y$R } B} k $R Ys % t $P s } P { 8BI j PB Y jbasj b sy RkR 8 Ys BB, $tb s{{bzt % k }BRR$Aj %s $saj bsr,tbbt $ bbzji R$jj tb A ZR PZj PB jbt 8 b sy } I${$Bt qy$r $R A {szr R8sjj B R $t 8 srz 8 t {st t % A {B8}j jk j$8$ts I V b sy Rs$Bt 8$Y }B Y 8} sz B A 1x3(( g3 $tr si BP 1x3((((d g3 yt {YsB${ RkR 8R Y R R8sjj B R sjk s& { Y PZZ A Ys%$B BP s RkR 8 3$Z 11 $jjzr s R Y$R {Bt{ } 7 tr$$% I } ti t{ Bt $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR 8 str RBjZ$BtR BP s RkR 8 s I s8s${sjjk & { I Ak R8sjj {Yst R $t Y $ $t$$sj {BtI$$Bt BZtI I RkR 8R b$jj -Y$A$ {B8}j - s} $BI${ A Ys%$B b$y ZtRsAj B A$R 7Z{Y RkR 8R s P I B sr {YsB${ Ns b t I s 8 ${ B `ZI by Y B tb s }s ${Zjs RkR 8 $R {YsB${ VR s 8s BP 8$tBjBk s {YsB${ RkR 8 YsR s {YsB${ B A$ B 4Bb V Rs$R${ {sjj I Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t 8 srz R Y -}Bt t$sj s s by${y Y B A b t bb t s Ak RBjZ$BtR BP s RkR 8 BbR B I { sr R yp Y$R B BbR Bt s% s B Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t $R }BR$$% Y t R tr$$% I } ti t{ Bt $t$$sj {BtI$$Bt $R -Y$A$ I yp Y B I { sr R sti ABY $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR R j $tb Y Rs8 RBjZ$Bt Y t Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t $R t s$% sti Y RBjZ$Bt $R RsAj * ht$$bt 11d A jbb PB 8sjjk I ht R R tr$$% I } ti t{ Bt $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR PB s 8s} B I$R{ RkR 8 >xh yt {Ys} x b } B%$I 8B I s$jr sabz Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t PB s 4Bb sti YBb $ {st A {sj{zjs I PB s,tbbt RkR 8 * ht$$bt 11d N W A s 8s} Bt b V }B$t? YsR R tr$$% I } ti t{ Bt $t$t $sj {BtI$$BtR $P Y $R s tbt9 B I$Rst{ Q RZ{Y Ys RB8 }B$tR s A$ s $jk t s? s % tzsjjk 8s}} I s j sr Q Zt$R P B8 Y {B R}BtI$t $8s BP? B } T {$R jk Y -$RR Q k ( RZ{Y Ys stk t $YAB YBBI ] BP? {Bts$tR s }B$t? RZ{Y Ys /W w?d W w? D/ Q PB RB8 tbtt s$% $t > 1n * tr! A$R 7$t{ s {YsB${ RkR 8 $R ABZtI I RBjZ$BtR 8s$t $t s {BtR s$t I }YsR R}s{ qy NB t9 RkR 8 PB -s8}j -$RR $t s h- I Y TI$8 tr$btsj R}s{ Ys jbb,r j$, s }s$ BP b$tr 7$t{ Y RkR 8 $R ABY s} $BI${ sti I 8$t$R${ % k }B$t $t Ys R}s{ 8ZR % tzsjjk A BZ{Y I sr Y 4Bb %Bj% R yp Y Rs8 }B$t bsr % %$R$ I Ak s 4Bb Y t Ys 4Bb bbzji A } $BI${ V I tr B A$ 8 str Ys A b t bb t s Ak }s R BP st B A$ tb 8s YBb {jbr B Y Y s B b$jj A $tht$ jk 8stk BY }s R B Y Rs8 B A$ RstIb${Y I $t A b t 3$Z 1n $jjzr s R bys Ys}} tr sr Y NB t9 RkR 8 $R sjjbb I B %Bj% PB } B RR$% jk jbt } $BIR BP $8 qy $I s BP s I tr B A$ A $tr B I % jb}
d1 20 10 0 10 20 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 (a) 20 10 0 10 20 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 (b)! "! # $! "! " # % & ' $ 1; ]YsB${ V s{b R ]YsB${ s s{b R b( * ht$$bt 1;d W?) PB bs I j$8$ R \W*?) i?) \? ] 6 z k ] /W*?)?/ c 6i3
dn y(t) x(t)! " # $ % & ' ( )?*?+ \W?* i?+ s s{ I B?+?+?* st B A$ B 4Bb $R {YsB${ $P $:R tb srk8}b${sjjk } $BI${ $R ABZtI I sti Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t BP Y RkR 8 $R s Yst 9 B
d; z(t) x 1 x 0 x(t) y(t)
dx ]Ys} n ]B88Zt${s$Bt 7{Y 8!Z RkR 8 PB R ti$t s 8 RRs ZR$t s {YsB${ R$tsj sr s {s $ $R js jk AsR I Bt bb, RYBbt Ak ]ZB8B sj $t >H!Z $8} B% 8 tr s 8B$%s I Ak Y I R$ B I$R{ jk $8}j 8 t Y $ RkR 8 sti B $8} B% $:R } PB 8st{ P B8 s {B88Zt${s$BtR } R} {$%!Z Bsj by$j IB$t Y$R $R B { s s RkR 8 R} {$sj$9 I PB {B% str8$rr$btr B R$tsj {s8bz4s 7 % sj R{Y 8 R PB {B88Zt${s$Bt ZR$t {YsBR Ys% A t $ I 7 >H>MH >H >d(h >ddh sti >d1h qy Bt b I 8$t I bbzji A 8BR ZR PZj PB I$R{ $8}j 8 ts$bt sti {B% str8$rr$bt $R }s s8 8BIZjs$Bt nd _s s8 BIZjs$Bt _s s8 8BIZjs$Bt bb,r Ak h R Ys%$t bb $I t${sj {YsB${ RkR 8R u Bt Ztt$t $t Y str8$ sti Bt $t s { $% k Rkt{Y Bt$9$t Y bb Y $ $trstst BZR Rs R s % k {jbr w7kt{y Bt$9s$Bt $R I$R{ZRR I $t {Ys} ;D V A$ts k 8 RRs $R R t Ak $Y 8s$ts$t$t Y Rkt{Y Bt$9s$Bt B A s,$t $ GY t Y { $% $R Rkt{Y Bt$9 I b$y Y str8$ B% RB8 I ht I A$ } $BI Y$R $R $t T } I sr s 9 BTA$ yp B% Y Rs8 A$ } $BI Y { $% $R BZ BP Rkt{Y Bt$9s$Bt b$y Y str8$ Y$R $R $t } I sr s Bt TA$ yt s sj {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 Y { $% $R R }s s I Ak s R$t$h{st I$Rst{ P B8 Y str8$ Vjj $ {st,tbb PB RZ $R $R Bbt Rs sti s R$tj $t4z t{ { $% I P B8 Y str8$ $Y Ak b$ B b$ j RRjk qy PB Y I 8$ts$Bt BP by Y Y RkR 8R s Rkt{Y Bt$9 I B tb YsR B A 8sI ZR$t Btjk Y$R $tpb 8s$Bt qy$r {st A IBt Ak ZR$t st B 8 {B8}s $t Y { $% I $t4z t{ R$tsj b$y bys Y RkR 8 bbzji -} { w0d )?? 3 wndd qy? 8 bbzji A Y BZ}Z BP Y str8$ sj I Ak tb$r sti BY {Ystt j & {R qy? 8 $R bys Y { $% $R -} {$t B { $% AsR I Bt $R Bbt }s s8 R sti Rs
qy$r $trstst BZR B 8ZR A %sjzs I B% st t$ A$ } $BI!t bsk B IB Y$R $R B %sjzs Y $t sj BP Y sarbjz %sjz BP Y B 8 de $ e B ) 8 w0dq03 wn1d qb IB Y$R $t st j { ${sj {$ {Z$ sti I 8$t Y { $% I A$ bbzji JZ$ RB8 k} BP jbb }srr hj sti s {B8}s $RBt BP Y A$ B b$y s Y RYBjI %sjz G$Y Y Zts%B$IsAj } R t{ BP tb$r % t bb } P {jk 8s{Y I }s s8 R R bbzji R$jj j si B RB8 BAR % I B!Z $8}j 8 ts$bt Bt I$R{ Ys Ibs B& R RB8 si%sts R PB Y$R {B8}s $RBt } B{ RR n1 *$R{ y8}j 8 ts$bt G {BZjI $8}j 8 t s I$R{ RkR 8 stsjbbzr b$y Y Bt I R{ $A I sab% ytr si BP s {Bt$tZBZR {B8}s $RBt BP Y $t4z t{ R$tsj b$y Y {B R}BtI$t { $% Rs Y {B8}s $RBt bbzji A IBt s s h- I Rs8}j s 3 $ e B ) >zh3 wnnd <Bb % Y$R bbzji tb s, si%sts BP Y sii I 4 -$A$j$k BP Ztt$t Y RkR 8 Bt s 8${ B} B{{ RB!Z I$R{ {YsB${ str8$ B} s R $t Y Rs8 PsRY$Bt sr Y {Bt$tZBZR % R$Bt I R{ $A I } %$BZRjk V Y A $tt$t BP % k A$ } $BI Y str8$ {YBBR R A b t bb }s s8 R R AsR I Bt Y 8 RRs A$ B A R t!t 8 BP Y {YsB${ RkR 8 $R R t Y BZY Y 8 I$Z8 B Y { $% qy h R I$R{ {YsB${ { $% b I % jb} I sjrb B} s R % k R$8$js jk B Y {BtT $tzbzr Bt I R{ $A I qy B s s{y Rs8}j $R RB I $t Y } B{ RRB :R 8 8B k B% Y IZ s$bt BP s A$ } $BI V Y ti BP s{y A$ Y RB I B %sjz R s RJZs I sti RZ88 I qy$r RZ8 $R {B8}s I B s } I 8$t I Y RYBjI %sjz $ e B j RR Yst Y Y RYBjI {szr R Y R$tsj B A $t } I sr s 9 BTA$ sti s Yst Y Y RYBjI $R $t } I sr s Bt TA$ qy Y RYBjI %sjz {st A R YsjPTbsk $t A b t Y B -} { I IZ B {Ystt j tb$r sti Rs8}j$t B R by t Y RkR 8R s } P {jk Rkt{Y Bt$9 I sti Y$R B $t sii$$bt B B -} $ t{ I by t Y bb RkR 8R IB tb Ys% 8s{Y$t }s s8 R R nn y8} B% 8 tr 7$8$js B 8BR } B{ RRB R Y I$$sj R$tsj } B{ RRB R ZR I B $8}j 8 t Y {YsB${ strt 8$ sti { $% $t Y$R } B` { Ys% 8 8B k B RB Rs8}j R sti {st } PB 8 {B8}j - jb${sj B} s$btr G s, si%sts BP Y R {s}sa$j$$ R
!Z t b IZsj Rkt{Y Bt$9$t R}BtR RkR 8 {B {R bb $RRZ R Ys s $R by t ZR$t Y AsR${ R{Y 8 I R{ $A I sab% 3$ R Y sab% R{Y 8 srrz8 R Ys s Y A $tt t$t BP s A$ } $BI Y RkR 8R s Rkt{Y Bt$9 I yt Ys {sr b$ybz stk tb$r s 9 BTA$ bbzji {szr Y A$ B B A 9 B yt sj$k Y RkR 8R bbzji tb Rs B& Rkt{Y Bt$9 I IZ B tb$r B $P Y } %$BZR A$ bsr s Bt TA$ qb 8s, Z} PB Y$R Y A$ } $BI 8ZR A j ty t I RB Ys Y RkR 8R {st Rkt{Y Bt$9 qy$r b$jj RZj $t s jbb Iss s qy R {BtI } BAj 8 $R Ys Y str8$ {sttb ZR si${sjjk I$& t }s s8 R R b$ybz PZ Y j ty t$t Y A$ } $BI =R$t Y }s s8 8BIZjs$Bt R{Y 8 st $I sj R BP }s s8 R bbzji $88 I$s jk {szr } P { Rkt{Y Bt$9s$Bt by t Y str8$ sti { $% }s s8 R 8s{Y I sti $88 I$s jk js B 8 by t Y k b 8$R8s{Y I G tb${ Ys {YBBR$t I$& t }s s8 R R IB R tb Bsjjk A s, Y Rkt{Y Bt$9sT $Bt y {szr R Y RkR 8R B t % -s{jk 8s{Y AZ Y { $% R$jj tir B PBjjBb Y str8$ B RB8 - t qb sii RR ABY BP Y sab% } BAj 8R b Zt bb R}BtR RkR 8R R$8Zjst BZRjk Bt Y Rs8 { $% } B{ RRB!t R}BtR RkR 8 }s s8 R {B R}BtIR B s 9 BTA$ sti Y BY {B R}BtIR B s Bt TA$ BY RkR 8R s 8} B Rkt{Y Bt$9 b$y Y I $% RkR 8 B% Y t$ A$ } $BI qy t Y RZ8 BP B R sr $t Jt nn -} $ t{ I Ak ABY R}BtR RkR 8R s {B8}s I qy RkR 8 b$y j RR B I 8$t R Y { $% I A$ sti ABY R}BtR RkR 8 Rs R s Z}Is I B 4 { Y A 8s{Y qy$r } B{ RR JZ$ R 8 8B k sti {B8}s $RBt sa$j$k tb sr$jk s%s$jsaj $t s R$8}j {B8}Bt t AsR I $8}j 8 ts$bt k s,$t si%sts BP Y sa$j$$ R BP *7_ Ys Ibs b Ys% s{y$ % I A } PB 8st{ Yst Y RkR 8 $t >H 3$Z nd RYBbR Y PBZ {sr R BP BZ IZsj Rkt{Y Bt$9$t { $% RkR 8 qy I $% RkR 8 {YBBR R }s s8 R V B AsR I Bt Y 8 RRs A$ qy }jbr RYBb Y I $% RkR 8 sti YBb Y bb R}BtR RkR 8R wbt ZR$t R V sti Bt ZR$t R D R}BtI G I R$ Ys s 8s{Y I R BP }s s8 R A b t Y str8$ sti { $% {szr s JZ${, sti $Y {BZ}j$t by$j s 8$R8s{Y I R j si B js B 3$Z n1 RYBbR s R$tj A$ b$tibb ZR I $t BZ IZsj Rkt{Y Bt$9$t { $% R{Y 8 qy$r }s ${Zjs b$tibb $R d(( Rs8}j R jbt qy $t4z t{ R$tsj P B8 Y str8$ $R s& { I Ak sii$$% pszrr$st tb$r sti Y bb { $% % R$BtR s 8} B Rkt{Y Bt$9 B Y $t4z t{ R$tsj qy B RJZs I $R }jb I $t Y ABB8 RZA}jB qy RZ8 BP RJZs R BP Y B PB ABY { $% RkR 8R $R ZR I B I 8$t Y A R 8s{Y b$y Y $t4z t{ R$tsj qy$r {B8}s $RBt $R ZR I B R$8s by${y A$ bsr { $% I d
dm Receiver Sys A 1 0.5 0 0.5 1 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 (a) Bit 0 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 Receiver Sys B 0.7 1 0.5 0 0.5 50 100 150 200 250 300 (b) 0.6 50 100 150 200 250 300 (c) Bit 1 1 0 200 400 600 800 1000 (d)
d 0.7 0.6 0.5 SysA SysB Influence 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 (a) 0.2 0.15 SysA Error SysB Error 0.1 0.05 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 (b)! " # $ % & " & # $
1( ]Ys} ; 7kt{Y Bt$9s$Bt G$Y Y } B} $ R BP {YsBR sj sik I$R{ZRR I $ R 8R R st Ys {YsB${ RkR 8R {BZjI A ZR I PB {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8R <Bb {st s 8 RRs A R t $P Y { $% IB R tb,tbb Y Rs Y str8$ 2 qy }s ${Zjs R{Y 8 b ZR B str8$ s 8 RRs YsR A t I$R{ZRR I $t s I s$j $t {Ys} n WBb b stsjk9 s RZ } $R$t } B} k BP RB8 {YsB${ RkR 8R qy$r $R Y tsz sj sa$j$k B Rkt{Y Bt$9 B st $I t${sj RkR 8 Ak RYs $t Btjk Bt Rs %s $saj >dnh>ddh G {BtR$I Y Ps8BZR NB t9 7kR 8U? ) wr?d, r ) '? r?f, w;dd F )?r #F3 qy }s s8 R ' sti # Ys% A t 8B% I P B8 Y $ B $$tsj {Bt - $t NB t9:r {Bt% {$Bt } B{ RR AZ Y k s R$jj R$t$h{st PB BZ }Z }BR R y Z tr BZ Ys Y NB t9 RkR 8 $% t sab% YsR s Ikts8${ st w st BP? r sti F RBjZ$BtRD Ys $R $8} s{${sj PB Y *$$sjtbtvtsjb sti VtsjBTBT*$$sj {Bt% R w]!*e]rd ss{y I B BZ *7_R VII$$Btsjjk Y RkR 8 %Bj% R s s $8} s{${sj s PB Y AstIb$IY BP BZ ]!*e]r 3B Y R srbtr b b$jj ZR s 8st$ZI sti $8 R{sj$t {Yst BP %s $saj R qy _]n((e ]!*e]r $t BZ Ys Ibs s {s}saj BP B} s$t A b t Tdz sti Ldz qy k s, ;M((( I$R{ Rs8}j R } R {BtI k Y WkJZ$R 7s8}j$t qy B 8 wqy B 8 ;(d >d;hd Y k {st s{{z s jk Rs8}j sti {BtR Z{ R$tsjR b$y s 8s-$8Z8 P JZ t{k BP 1;,<9 qy B 8 ;(d N?w0D A s AstIj$8$ I R$tsj b$y wwd ) ( PB /W/ k W qy t?w0d $R Zt$JZ jk I 8$t I Ak $R Rs8}j R?wzx D, z ) (, d, 1, 3 3 3 $P W k 1W by W ) x $R Y Rs8}j$t } $BI sti W $R Y Y$Y R P JZ t{k BP Y R$tsj >d;h G b$jj {YBBR s R{sj$t Ps{B Ak Ys sjjbbr Y? 8 B A R t B Y *$$sjtbt VtsjB {Bt% b$ybz RsZ s$bt qy RkR 8 b$jj A R} I Z} B RjBb I IBbt Ak s $8 R{sj x Ys sjjbbr ^{$ t ZR BP Y s%s$jsaj 1;,<9 ]!*e] AstIb$IY qy R 8R
b$jj t I B A si`zr I AsR I Bt Y }s ${Zjs }s s8 R {YBR t sti Y $8 R{sj$t b$jj A $ I B Y R } R$9 BP Y I$& t$sj JZs$Bt RBj% qy %s $saj `w0d b$jj } R t Y s8}j$zi sti $8 R{sj I R$tsj B A str8$ I d c `w0d c Ld, sti JwWD ) ( PB /W/ k W 1 3 qy Zt$PB 8 R{sj$t $R $% t Ak Y RZAR$Z$BtU 1d ` )? \, 8 ) r \, j ) F \ 3 w;1d qy t q$8 R{sj$t Ak x ` )? \ ) w\8 \`D, \ 8 ) r \ ) d \ w\'` \8 \ `jd, j ) F \ ) d \ w\ `8 \#jd3 $R s{y$ % I Ak Y PBjjBb$t {Yst BP %s $saj RU + ) 0 x sti Q+ Q0 ) d x Q0 Q0 ) d x 3 w;nd =$j$9$t Y {Ys$t Zj Y {Yst BP %s $saj R $t JZs$Bt ;n s& {R Y B $$tsj RkR 8 sr PBjjBbRU Q? Q+ Qr Q+ QF Q+ ) Q? Q0 ) Qr Q0 ) QF Q0 Q0 Q+ ) x Q? Q0, Q0 Q+ ) x Qr Q0, Q0 Q+ ) x QF Q0, qyzr Y $8 sti s8}j$zi R{sj I I $% RkR 8 w str8$ D $RU ` ) x w8 `D, w;;d 8 ) x w'` 8 \`jd, w;xd j ) x w\`8 #jd3 ;d * $% T i R}BtR ]BZ}j$t AsR I Bt _s s8 7 s{y B $R8s{Y yt BZ I$R{ R{Y 8 b PZ Y st $I s $t$$s I Ak ]ZB8B sj >H qy k R t s A$ts k 8 RRs Ak 4$}}$t Y # }s s8 BP Y I $% RkR 8 A b t bb %sjz R qy$r si`zr8 t
Rj$Yjk Z}R R Y Rkt{Y Bt$9s$Bt A b t Y I $% sti R}BtR RkR 8R qy } R t{ B sar t{ BP B s Y R}BtR RkR 8 {BZjI Y t A ZR I B I 8$t Y 8 RRs A$ ]BZ}j$t $R s{y$ % I Ak RYs $t Y ` 8 P B8 Y I $% RkR 8 b$y Y R}BtR RkR 8 WB${ $t JZs$Bt ;E Ys ` s, R Y }js{ BP ` $t Y JZs$BtR PB 8 sti j qy %s $saj ` $R Y $t4z t{ R$tsj qy$r {BZ}j$t {st A sj$9 I R$8}jk sr s b$ B b$y 8B RB}Y$R${s$Bt s b$ j RR {Btt {$Bt G 8s$ts$t Y Rs8 $t4z t{ {BthZ s$bt sr ZR I Ak ]ZB8B sj AZ sii {B8}j -T $k Ak sjjbb$t sjj Y }s s8 R $t Y R}BtR RkR 8 B A $ti } ti t BP Y I $% RkR 8 qy str8$ sj R Y I $% RkR 8 }s s8 R ' sti # AsR I Bt s 8 RRs A$ _s s8 R ' sti # } R tr Y {BZt }s }s s8 R $t Y R}BtR RkR 8 qy R b$jj $Y A $I t${sj B 8$R8s{Y I 3$Z ;d RYBbR Y {BZ}j$t R{Y 8 ZR I 11! qy R}BtR RkR 8 { $% $R ` 8 ` 8 ' ` 8 `j ;E j `8 # j B 8R s ZR I B %sjzs Rkt{Y Bt$9s$Bt ` ` 8 8 ; j j ]BtR$I $t sjj Y B 8R s Bt{ ;
qs,$t Y I $%s$% b$y R} { B $8 k$ jiru ) w ` ` D, ) x w8 `D x w8 ` D, ) x w8 8 w` ` DD3 ) w 8 8 D, w;d ) x w'` 8 \`j ' ` L 8 L \`j D, ) x ww8 8 D \`wj j D L w' ' D`D ) x w \` L w' ' D`D3 ) w j j D, ) x w\`8 #j \`8 L # j D, ) x w\`w8 8 D #j L # j D ) x w\` #j L # j D3 ;1 Nks}ZtB% 3Zt{$Bt VtsjkR$R BP 7sA$j$k Nks}ZtB% PZt{$BtR t sj$9 Y $I s BP }B t$sj t k sti {st A ZR I B {Ys s{ $9 Y srk8}b${ A Ys%$B BP s RkR 8R yp b {st hti s Nks}ZtB% PZt{$Bt PB Y B RkR 8 sab% b {st RYBb Ys $ s}} Bs{Y R 9 B B% $8 sti YZR Y bb NB t9 RkR 8R Rkt{Y Bt$9 >dxh Vs$t b PBjjBb ]ZB8B:R j si sti ZR Y$R Nks}ZtB% PZt{$Bt sr Y AsR$R PB Y PBjjBb$t >H ow,, D ) d 1 w d L L 1n D3 w;d(d qb RYBb Rkt{Y Bt$9s$Bt b bst B hti Ys Y PZt{$Bt ow,, D YsR s jbtt 8 t s$% RjB} sti RB B I { sr R sjbt RBjZ$BtR BP w0d $t JZs$Bt ;M qs,$t Y I $%s$% b$y R} { B $8 U Qo Q0 ) (o ( ) N ( (0 L (o ( L L N ( (0 L (o ( N ( (0 w` ` D ) x \ w8 8 w` ` DD Lw8 8 Dw \` L w' ' D`D Lwj j Dw\` w#j # j DDi3 yp Y I $% sti R}BtR RkR 8 }s s8 R s Y Rs8 w_s s8 7 s{yd ) ' ) ' # ) #
1; Y t Qo Q0 ) x w # D ) x ww d n 1 D ; # D3 w;ddd 7$t{ o $R }BR$$% I ht$ sti o $R t s$% I ht$ b$y x k ( Nks}ZtB%:R Y B 8 $8}j$ R wd s}} Bs{Y R ( sr 7kt{Y Bt$9s$Bt b$jj Y PB B{{Z qy$r stsjkr$r IB R tb $ti${s YBb PsR $ B{{Z R AZ -} $8 ts$bt RYBbR $ B A PsR tbzy B s{y$ % s bb,$t RkR 8 yp Y I $% sti R}BtR RkR 8 }s s8 R tb Y Rs8 w_s s8 7 $R8s{YD Y t W) ' W) ' # W) # Qo Q0 w` ` D ) x \ w8 8 w` ` DD Lw8 8 Dw \` L w' ' D`D Lwj j Dw\` w#j # j DDi3 qy I $%s$% sab% $R $t{bt{jzr$% PB stsjkr$r BP Y RkR 8:R sa$j$k B Rkt{Y Bt$9 qy t - P b {Ys} R RYBb BZ } B{ RR B B}$8$9 Y R j {$Bt BP }s s8 R R PB Y I $% sti R}BtR RkR 8R qy$r A {B8 R s R$- I$8 tr$btsj } BAj 8 sti 8stk {Yt${sj I$^{Zj$ R s $R 3B { s$t }s s8 %sjz R Y RkR 8R IB tb } BIZ{ {YsB${ A Ys%$B yt Ps{ RBjZ$BtR BP Y NB t9 RkR 8 PB -s8}j {st Y si Bbs IR $tht$k s{y s R sik Rs B R j $tb s } $BI${ B A$ $P Y }s s8 R $R {YBR t $8} B} jk WBt BP Y R R{ ts $BR s s{{ }saj A {szr Y k b$jj tb bb, PB s {B% {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8
1x ]Ys} x qy Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t 7 s {Y qy Nks}ZtB% tz8a 8 srz R Y s% s s BP {Yst PB B A b t bb t s Ak RBjZ$BtR BP s RkR 8 V Nks}ZtB% tz8a s Yst Bt $ti${s R Ys s stk }s ${Zjs $8 bb B A$R t s s{y BY b$jj ti B Bb s}s yp $ $R j RR Yst Bt Y t t s Ak B A$R Bb {jbr sti s}} Bs{Y JZsj RBjZ$BtR sr $8 } B RR R Bbs I $tht$k 3$Z xd $jjzr s R Y R bb {sr R qy Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t $R R$8}jk Y tsz sj jbs $Y8 BP Y Nks}ZtB% tz8a V{{B I$tjk $P Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t $R }BR$$% Y t R8sjj B R Bb sti $P $ $R t s$% Y k I$8$t$RY y {st A ZR I $t R % sj stsjkr$r js I B RsA$j$k ZR Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t B Y j} $I t$pk $P s RkR 8 I 8BtR s R {YsB${ A Ys% $B PB s }s ${Zjs }s s8 R t JZ$ 8 t PB {YsBR $R Y } B} k BP R tr$$% I } ti t{ Bt $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR Vt B A$ BP RZ{Y s RkR 8 $R ZtRsAj RB t s Ak B A$R I $% t sbsk yp Y RkR 8 $R ABZtI B s {BtR s$t I R}s{ sti Y B BbR A b t bb B A$R Rs I {jbr B s{y BY Y t Y RkR 8R b$jj A s} $BI${ sti -Y$A$ R tr$$% I } ti t{ Bt $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR qy Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t b$jj A }BR$$% qy Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t $R }s ${Zjs B s R} {$h{ RkR 8 sti R BP }s s8 R sti $ ZRZsjjk {st Btjk A s}} B-$8s I Ak st s% s$t B} s$bt B% s jbt } $BI V}} B-
$8s$Bt BP Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t $R sr$ R PB 8s}R R$t{ $ $R P t{ I sr BbY s } R } BP Y 8s} 1E * ht$$bt x(d N W A s 8s} BP Y sj j$t b qy Nks}ZtB% tz8a Uw? D BP Y B A$ \?,?,?, 3 3 3 i $R I ht I sr Uw? D ) j$8 w/w w? D/ 3 3 3 /W w? D/D $P Y$R j$8$ -$RR qy Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t _w? D $R I ht I sr _w? D ) j$8 wdbzd>jt /W w? D/ L 3 3 3 L jt /W w? D/H, $P Y$R j$8$ -$RR WB${ Ys _ -$RR $P sti Btjk $P U -$RR sti jt U ) _ >xh, 3B 4BbR %sjzs$bt BP Y Nks}ZtB% tz8a sti -}Bt t $R 8B I$^{Zj!t 8 YBI $R B strpb 8 Y {Bt$tZBZR RkR 8 $tb s I$R{ Bt Ak %sjzs$t Y $8 Td 8s} BP Y RkR 8 qy$r 8s} } R tr Y Rs BP Y RkR 8 Bt Zt$ $8 R } js 3B s 8B $t I }Y I$R{ZRR$Bt Bt {B8}Z$t Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t PB 4BbR R >deh G b$jj ZR Y 8B s{{ RR$Aj I ht$$bt $t >xh * ht$$bt x(1 qy 4Bb 3 w%d $R Y }B$t s by${y st B A$ Rs I s }B$t % tir Z} sp x $8 Zt$R qy Nks}ZtB% tz8a sti -}Bt t BP Y 4Bb %w0d s Y Nks}ZtB% tz8a sti -}Bt t BP Y srrb{$s I $8 Td 8s} 3 w%d xd er$8s$t Y Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t Ak Y zs $st $Btsj ejzs$bt YBI 3B Y 4Bb % ) Ww%, 0D b b$ry B R$8s $R Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t PB s t sj R BP $t$$sj {BtI$$BtR!t 8 YBI PB IB$t Y$R $R stsjbbzr B Y -} RR$Bt $% t $t I ht$$bt x(d PB 8s}R G P B Y$R 8 YBI sr Y %s $s$btsj JZs$Bt 8 YBI p$% t s }s ${Zjs 4Bb b b$jj sjrb {BtR$I Y 4Bb Rs I t s Ak % ) Ww%, 0D, K% ) WwK%, 0D3 wxdd G s $t R I $t JZst$Pk$t Y R }s s$bt BP Y R bb B A$ sr $8 } B RR R RB j & w0d ) %w0d K%w0D3 wx1d
1 qy $8 I $%s$% BP & w0d $R & w0d ) %w0d K%w0D, wxnd ) Ww%, 0D WwK%, 0D, ) Ww%, 0D >x CoH, by >x CoH } R tr Y qskjb R $ R -}str$bt BP W wk%, 0D sabz % s}} B-$8s$Bt bb,r PB BZ }Z }BR sr jbt sr K% $R {jbr B % WwK%, 0D Ww%, 0D L W w%, 0DwK%w0D %w0dd, PB K% {jbr B %3 qy h RTB I wx;d ejzs$bt xn sab% {st Y t A b $ t sru & w0d ) Ww%, 0D >Ww%, 0D W w%, 0D& w0dh ) ;Ww%, 0D N & w0d3 wxxd ejzs$bt xx $R,tBbt sr Y %s $s$btsj JZs$Bt y I R{ $A R Y BbY s BP R8sjj B R sjbt st B A$ qb R$8s Y Nks}ZtB% tz8a b t I B RBj% JZs$Bt xx PB Bt TZt$ $8 R }R sjbt b$y RBjZ$BtR BP Ww%, 0D! "!
3B Y NB t9 RkR 8 T z Ww%, 0D ) Z? )? L r r )?F L? r F )?r KF3 1M wxed qy $8 I $%s$% BP Y I$& t$sj JZs$Bt wfs{ba$st 8s $-D $R m ( u ;Ww%, 0D ) t Fw0D d?w0d { 3 wxd rw0d?w0d K3 qy PB Y %s $s$btsj JZs$Bt PB Y NB t9 RkR 8 $R & w0d ) C H & & & I O ) C H Fw0D d?w0d ( rw0d?w0d K3 I O N C H & & & I O 3 wxmd _ PB 8$t Y IB } BIZ{ $t JZs$Bt xm k$ jir Y PBjjBb$t R BP!*eRU & ) w& L & D, & ) & &?w0d & Fw0D &, wxd & ) &?w0d L & rw0d K& 3 WB Ys Y$R R BP!*eR 8ZR A RBj% I b$y RBjZ$BtR BP? r sti F qy t BZ $8 Td 8s} b$jj {B8 P B8 R$8Zjst BZRjk RBj%$t Y R$-!*eR A jbb PB Bt $8 Zt$? )? L r, r )?F L? r, F )?r KF, & ) w& L & D, wxd(d & ) & &?w0d & Fw0D &, & ) &?w0d L & rw0d K& 3 3B BZ tz8 ${sj stsjkr$r Y B $R $t$$sjjk R BU C db $ I C n & w(d ) H db $ n db $ O B stk BY % {B BP Zt$ j ty sti %w(d ) H d I d O 3 n d
x1 pbsjr PB Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t 7 s {Y 1!Z srbt PB {sj{zjs$t Nks}ZtB% -}Bt tr PB Y NB t9 RkR 8 $R B $I t$pk }s s8 R R Ys k$ ji {YsBR G t I Y$R k} BP stsjkr$r PB Y A$ t k R s {Y $t {Ys} E _ B{ IZ sjjk b R$8s Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t BP Y NB t9 RkR 8 Ak %sjzs$t Y BbY BP & w0d B% 8stk $8 Td R }R e-} $8 tsjjk b PBZtI Ys s% s$t B% d((( $8 Zt$R } B%$I R tbzy s{{z s{k PB BZ }Z }BR R =j$8s jk b t I B I T 8$t $P s }s ${Zjs }s s8 R k$ jir {YsBR B RB8 Y$t jr wh- I }B$t } $BI${$k ZtABZtI It RRD!Z Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t R$8s$Bt Btjk t IR B A s{{z s tbzy B {BthI tjk I 8$t $P Y -}Bt t $R }BR$$% B t s$% G 8ZR RsAj$RY sj$r${ j$8$r PB BZ R s {Y yi sjjk b bbzji j$, B R$8s Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t PB % k }s s8 R $t Y Y TI$8 tr$btsj }s s8 R}s{ qy$r $R R$8}jk tb }BRR$Aj VR tb {jbr I PB 8 -} RR$Bt -$RR s A R Btjk 8stk I$R{ }s s8 R R {st A %sjzs I es{y Iss }B$t JZ$ R } PB 8$t Y %sjzs$bt tb I sab% PB tbzy $8 Td R }R Ys Y {sj{zjs I Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t A $tr B j$sajk {Bt% B s %sjz!t Iss }B$t sjbt {st A {B8}Zs$Btsjjk $t tr$%!z {YBR t {sj{zjs$bt j ty $R 8B$%s I Ak 8BI j$t Y {Bt% t{ BP Y {sj{zjs I Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t sr st sj ts$t R $ R e B b$jj I$8$t$RY sti tb -{ I s j$ B R G -} { Ys s %sjz R j$t b jj sp Bt YBZRstI s% s R b$jj tb RZII tjk Bb sbsk P B8 Y s% s xn i RZjR BP Nks}ZtB% e-}bt t 7 s {Y qy BZYBZ Y$R R s {Y } B` { b s 8} B {sj{zjs Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t PB s Bsj BP dx 8$jj$Bt Zt$JZ }s s8 R R qy$r R s {Y s8bzt I B 8stk YBZ R BP {B8}Zs$Bt Bt 8Zj$}j } B{ RRB R 7$jj Y js R %BjZ8 b R s {Y I $t Y }s s8 R}s{ bsr sr PBjjBbRU x3( c c ;(3( x3( c ' c x3( x3( c # c 1(3( wxddd G tb${ I JZ${,jk Ys }s s8 R R b$y Bt B 8B t s$% }s s8 b BZT Aj RB8 _ IB8$ts jk RZ{Y R R I$I tb j si B ABZtI I {YsBR sti $ bsr sjrb 8stk $8 R 8B I$^{Zj B R$8s Y {B R}BtI$t Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t qy }BR$$% st BP }s s8 R bsr j$8$ I PB Y } s{${sj srbtr sj sik I$R{ZRR I G {YBR Y$R }s ${T Zjs st A {szr 8BR bb, Ys YsR A t IBt {Ys s{ $9$t Y NB t9 RkR 8 $t%bj% R }s s8 R $t Y$R st 3B BZ 8BR YB BZY -}Bt t R$8s$Bt b {YBR d(1ed1 }s s8 R R $t Y $Bt (3( c c nx3( 1(3( c ' c E(3( (3( c # c dx3( wxd1d
qy R }s s8 R R s I$R $AZ I $t s Zt$PB 8 8s $- d1n d1n En 3$Z R xn sti x; s 8st$}Zjs$BtR BP Y %BjZ8 xd1 3$Z xx RYBbR Y RZjR PB 1((((( }s s8 R R I$R $AZ I stib8jk B% s R8sjj }s s8 R}s{ qy 8s`B $k wsabz 1\nD BP Y }s s8 R R R I RZj $t t s$% -}Bt tr sti s tb I$R}jsk I qy RZjR BP Y Zt$PB 8 I$R $AZ$Bt s 8Z{Y sr$ B ZR $t %$RZsj$9s$Bt PZt{$BtR <Bb % $ $R $8}B st B sjrb {BtR$I Y stib8jk I$R $AZ I }B$tR $t B I B s$t RB8 j % j BP {BthI t{ Ys b s tb B% jbb,$t $t R$t A Ys%$B $t A b t Y Zt$PB 8jk R}s{ I Rs8}j R n(
nd 2.5 2 15 1.5 1 10 0.5 0 β 5 0.5 1 1.5 0 60 50 40 ρ 30 20 0 10 σ 20 30 2 2.5
n1!! " #
nn ]Ys} E _s s8 7}s{ 7 s {Y PB y8} B% I $ et k 3B Y NB t9 RkR 8 Y Y }s s8 R ' sti # sj Y A Ys%$B BP Y RkR 8 >EH 3B BZ IZsj Rkt{Y Bt$9$t { $% R{Y 8 I$R{ZRR I $t {Ys} n Y str8$ sti { $% ZR bb R }s s R R BP Y Y }s s8 R!t R } R tr s 9 BTA$ sti Y BY s Bt TA$!t JZ R$Bt Ys b 8ZR -}jb $R YBb B {YBR bb R R BP }s s8 R Ys k$ ji Y A R RkR 8 } PB 8st{ PB b {st % t Rs BZ stsjkr$r b 8ZR I ht bys b 8 st Ak A R: } PB T 8st{ 3B BZ {B% {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 bb R }s s } B} $ R 8ZR A {BtR$I I!Z } $8s k BA` {$% $R B { s s str8$ Ys $R I$^{Zj B jb{s qb IB Y$R b I R$ Ys Y str8$rr$bt P JZ t{k R} { Z8 A b$i sti 4s wbp t P I B sr b$i T AstID *$R$tZ$RY$t } s,r srrb{$s I b$y s } $BI${ str8$rr$bt w$ R$tZRB$IRD s sr$jk I {saj!z R {BtIs k Bsj $R B B}$8$9 Y RkR 8:R } PB 8st{ $t Y } R t{ BP tb$r VR b$y stk {B88Zt${s$BtR RkR 8 by t Y {Ystt j tb$r Ys BZ RkR 8 str8$r Y BZY $t{ sr R Y s$b BP RZ{{ RRPZj A$R B A$R $t B I si R GY t b {Yst Y }s s8 R B $8} B% Bt } B} k stby Bt RZ& R 3B Y$R srbt b 8ZR R$8Zjst BZRjk {B8}s ABY BP Y } B} $ R I R{ $A I sab% by t R s {Y$t PB bb BBI }s s8 R R Ed y8} B%$t $ e B _ BAsA$j$k G hti Ys Y B } PB 8st{ BP Y RkR 8 $R RR t$sjjk AsR I Bt Y t k BP Y I$& t{ A b t Y Bt TA$ sti 9 BTA$ R$tsjR N o I$& ) 8 /` w0d ` w0d/ Q03 wedd =tj$, st$}bisj {B88Zt${s$Bt R{Y 8 R RZ{Y sr A$ts k }YsR RY$P, k w _7 D Y t k $t s A$ $R tb {BtRst G {sttb RBj% PB Y$R t k $t {jbr I PB 8 b {st
Btjk BAR % st s% s B% 8stk A$R qb $8} B% Y RkR 8R B } PB 8st{ by t RZA` { I B tb$r b b$ry B 8s-$8$9 Y$R s% s o I$& B% sjj str8$ I A$R {szr Y *7_ Ys Ibs $% R ZR Y sa$j$k B {B8}s bb { $% % R$BtR ss$tr Y { $% I R$tsj b IB tb Ys% B bb k sabz {B8}j jk I R Bk$t Y Rkt{Y Bt$9s$Bt Ak s }s s8 8$R8s{Y by${y $R BB s qy }s s8 8s{Y I % R$Bt b$jj R Y Rs BP ABY R}BtR RkR 8R sp Y A$ } $BI VR s RZj BP BZ RkR 8:R sa$j$k B {Bt$tZ b$y Y A R h RkR 8 b s saj B 8s$ts$t Rkt{Y Bt$9s$Bt b$y st s RR$% }s s8 8$R8s{Y!Z $t$$sj }s s8 R s {Y bsr B% jk R$8}j$h I G Btjk sjjbb I Y si`zr8 t BP Y # }s s8 sti Btjk jbb, I s Y s% s A$ t k I$& t{ o I$& 3$Z Ed RYBbR Y RZjR BP Y ZI$8 ts k R s {Y qy RZj bsr tb RZ } $R$t B 8 tibzrjk Y j}pzj BRjk Y hz RYBbR Ys B 8s-$8$9 o I$& #w(d sti #wdd RYBZjI A sr Ps s}s sr }BRR$Aj qy } BAj 8 $R Ys Y R }s s8 R 8ZR A ABZtI I B Y k {szr Y RkR 8 B B} s ZtI R$ sajk w$ h- I }B$tR } $BI${ B A$R sti ZtABZtI I A Ys%$B D qy $t$$sj }s s8 R s {Y I$I $% ZR st s}} {$s$bt PB Y {B8}Zs$Btsj {B8}j -$k BP Y } BAj 8 n; 80 70 60 50 40 E diff 30 20 10 0 20 15 β(1) 10 5 0!! " # # 0 5 10 β(0) 15 20
!Z R {BtI 8 YBI PB $I t$pk$t }s s8 R R sjjbbr PB 9 BTA$ sti Bt TA$ }s st 8 R R B A 8$R8s{Y I $t sjj Y }s s8 R qb sjk R$8}j$Pk Y R$8Zjs$Bt b h- Y 9 BTA$ }s s8 R B ) de3(, ' ) ;x3e sti # ) ;3( qy$r 8 str Ys s Y I$8 tr$btsj %BjZ8 BP Y ' sti # }s s8 R 8ZR A R s {Y I PB s BBI Bt TA$ }s s8 R 3$Z E1 $R Bt bsk B %$ b Y - $B BP Y %BjZ8 $t JZ R$Bt nx! "! # $ # # # # # % & ' ( ) * E1 ]B% _ PB 8st{ ]BtR$I s$btr V Y Rs8 $8 b R, B $8} B% A$ t k b b$ry B 8s$ts$t B tyst{ Y {B% t RR } B} $ R BP BZ RkR 8 *Z B s js R$-TI$8 tr$btsj }s s8 R}s{ BZ R s {Y YsR B A szb8s I G Ys% {BtR$I I bb s}} Bs{Y R VR Bt B}$Bt b {BZjI I %$R st sjb $Y8 B jbb, s Y RYs} BP Y RkR 8:R s% s P JZ t{k R}BtR PB s{y }s s8 R qy$r b$jj $% ZR s 8 srz BP 4st RR ]YsB${ RkR 8R ti B Ys% R8BBY t k I$R $AZ$BtR $t Y P JZ t{k IB8s$t Vj ts$% jk b {BZjI {sj{zjs Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t PB Y RkR 8 ZR$t s{y }s s8 R
G Asjst{ ABY JZsj$$ R B trz Ys PB s }s ${Zjs }s s8 R Y RkR 8 $R R$jj {YsB${ sti $R t k $R R8BBYjk I$R $AZ I B% s b$i P JZ t{k st G sr$jk $I t$pk {sr R by s }s ${Zjs }s s8 R {szr R Y RkR 8 B s{y s R sik Rs wtbtt{ysb${d B RB8 jbbtb I } $BI${ B A$ Ak -s8$t$t Y Nks}ZtB% -}Bt t G sjrb -}jb 8st$ZI sti $8 R{sj$t B trz Ys bb I $% RkR 8R B} s$t RBj jk b$y Bt B Y BY }s s8 R R Ys% R$8$js BAR %saj } B} $ R $t Y P JZ t{k IB8s$t V8}j$ZI R{sj$t $R AsR I Bt {sj{zjs$t Y BB 8 st RJZs I wi7d %sjz PB Y I $% RkR 8 ZtI % k }s s8 R ZR I sti si`zr$t B trz Ys tb 8s bys }s s8 R $R ZR I s% s }Bb BZ}Z 8s$tR Y Rs8 q$8 R{sj$t bbzji s& { Y {YsB${ R$tsj:R t k I$R $AZ$Bt $t Y P JZ t{k IB8s$t yi sjjk bb RkR 8R b$y I$& t }s s8 R R b$jj jbb, R$8$js $t Y P JZ t{k IB8s$t B IZ{ Y {Yst{ BP A$ {B% k Ak s Y$ I }s k qb s{{b8}j$ry Y$R ABY RkR 8R 8ZR I$R $AZ R$tsj t k $t s R$8$js 8stt G I$I tb $8}j 8 t Y$R R {BtI k} BP R{sj$t 3$Z En RYBbR Y RZj BP BZ htsj A$ t k R s {Y ZR$t s8}j$zi R{sj$t PB sjj BP Y R I }s s8 R R qy B% sjj RZjR s JZ$ I$& t P B8 YBR } R t I $t hz E1 qy js A$ t k I$& t{ R } R t I $t hz En s srrb{$s I b$y R$t$h{st I$& t{ $t P JZ t{k IB8s$t } B} $ R qy$r $ti${s R Y sii I t I PB $8 R{sj$t $t sii$$bt B Y s8}j$zi R{sj$t b } PB 8 ne
! " # n
nm ]Ys} ]Ysjj t R BP s *$R{ <s Ibs 7kR 8 Vjj BP Y I$& t$sj JZs$BtR I$R{ZRR I s {Bt$tZBZR RkR 8R sti {st s, Bt stk %sjz G 8ZR {BtR$I bys t IR B A 8BI$h I $t B I B Zt Y R RkR 8R Bt I$R{ Ys Ibs sti sjrb $P stk PZtIs8 tsj {Yst R B{{Z! I$ts k I$& t$sj JZs$BtR w!*erd j$, Y Bt R b s ZR$t PB Y NB t9 RkR 8 {st A RBj% I tz8 ${sjjk Ak R % sj sjb $Y8R G R j { Y izt T Zs wi D PBZ Y B I sjb $Y8 A {szr $ k$ jir s{{z s RZjR js$% B $R } B{ RR$t JZ$ 8 tr >;H ytr si BP RBj%$t Y RkR 8R PB % k $trst BP $8 Y izt T Zs sjb $Y8 Btjk RBj% R Y RkR 8 Rs s h- I $t %sjr qy {Y$ P $RRZ b Ys% Ps{ I by t strpb 8T $t Y {Bt$tZBZR RkR 8R B s I$R{ t%$ Bt8 t $R I 8$t$t bys Y R } R$9 BP Ys $t %sj RYBZjI A w7 s}} ti$- V PB 8B $tpb 8s$Bt Bt Y izt T Zs ;Tx VjB $Y8D qy str8$rr$bt RkR 8 s, R Bt R } %$s Y i sjb $Y8 % k $8 Y I$$sjT BTstsjB {Bt% $t Z} R %${ BZ$t $R {sjj I qy$r s $R h- I s ;M,<9 Ak BZ ]!*e]r qy RkR 8 8ZR A R} I Z} B RjBb I IBbt Ak si`zr$t Y i R } R$9 B Ak si`zr$t Y $8 R{sj x by${y s s js I }s$ qb 8BR & {$% jk Z$j$9 Y s%s$jsaj AstIb$IY BP Y ]!*e] b$ybz sj$sr$t b Ys% PBZtI Ys Y j$8$$t Ps{B $R Y$R R } R$9 T x }s$ wqy bb s {jbr jk js ID qy$r $R A {szr s,$t s R } Ys $R BB A$ {szr R Y i sjb $Y8 B Ps$j sti Y I$R{ RkR 8 IB R tb 8Zjs $R {Bt$tZBZR 8BI j yt Y ti b Ys% s RkR 8 Ys $R Rs8}j I s s s s Yst bys WkJZ$R bbzji JZ$ AZ $R t { RRs k PB Y tz8 ${sj RBj% B k$ ji s{{z s RZjR G IB tb -} $8 t b$y I$R{s I$t Ztt { RRs k Rs8}j R IZ B Y {B8}j${s$BtR $ bbzji sii s Y { $% d q -sr ytr Z8 tr :]Edd *$$sj 7$tsj _ B{ RRB 3B Y$R } B` { b ZR bb Y$YTR} I I$$sj R$tsj } B{ RRB R w*7_rd B tz8 ${sjjk RBj% Y NB t9 7kR 8 sti {BB I$ts $t}z P B8 sti BZ}Z B Y ]!*e] qy R } B{ RRB R s Y$Yjk R} {$sj$9 I PB } PB 8$t 8st$}Zjs$BtR Bt R$tsjR sti B} s$t Bt s skr BP
n n n n n n 1 q R ejz$}8 t n
;( # ' $ # ( ) ) # % " * % "! $ ' # #! & #
;d! "
;1! " " # $ % & ' ( & ) &
! " # ;n
;; ]Ys} M $ e B _ PB 8st{ 3B stk I$$sj {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 s A$T B } BAsA$j$k stsjkr$r $R Bt BP Y 8BR PZtIs8 tsj bskr B {Ys s{ $9 RkR 8 } PB 8st{ $T B } BAsA$j$k I R{ $A R Y j$, j$ybbi Ys s str8$ I A$ b$jj A { $% I $t B s Y { $%!P t Y } $8s k srbt s { $% b$jj 8$R$t } s { $% I A$ $R tb$r t{bzt I $t Y {B88Zt${sT $Bt {Ystt j *Z B $8 {BtR s$tr Y$R $R Y Btjk I $8 tsj & { b b$jj RZIk *Z $t BZ $t$$sj R s {Y b PBZtI Y$R k} BP stsjkr$r YsI A t }Z RZ I $t % k P b } %$BZRjk }ZAj$RY I bb,r Bt {YsB${ {B88Zt${s$BtR RkR 8R VR $ bsr $t$$sjjk Zt{j s YBb BAZR s {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 AsR I Bt {YsB${ }s s8 8BIZjs$Bt bbzji A Y {Ys s{ $9s$Bt BP A$ B } BAsA$j$k A {s8 s R$t$h{st }s BP BZ $t% R$s$Bt srz $t Y A$T B } BAsA$j$k BP s {B88Zt${s$BtR RkR 8 {st A s jbt sti 8 ${T ZjBZR } B{ RR qb IB Y R 8 srz 8 tr $t Ys Ibs JZ$ R R} {$sj$9 I JZ$}8 t Ys bsr tb s%s$jsaj PB Y$R } B` { 7$8Zjs$t Y Rs8 } B} k $R 8B s{{ RR$Aj AZ {s 8ZR A s, t B trz stk RZjR s$t I b$jj A jssaj B sj Ys Ibs } PB 8st{ VjRB Y R Bt ]s jb R$8Zjs$BtR ti B A {B8}Zs$Btsjjk $t tr$% Ak Y $ tsz Md Bt ]s jb e B ]BZt$t qy 8BR {B88Bt 8 YBI B {Ys s{ $9 A$T B } BAsA$j$k $R Ak t s$t A$T B s w eid {Z % R qy R {Z % R js A$T B } BAsA$j$k B Y s$b BP A$ t k B tb$r }Bb R} { sj I tr$k w8 srz I $t I D 3B s P b R} {$h{ R{Y 8 R RZ{Y sr A$ts k }YsR TRY$P, k w _7 D s {jbr I PB 8 -} RR$Bt PB Y A$T B s {st A I % jb} I qy RkR 8R PB by${y {jbr I PB 8 -} RR$BtR -$R s Y -{ }$Bt 3B 8BR RkR 8R RZjR 8ZR A BAs$t I P B8 R$8Zjs$BtR B -} $8 tsjjk {B8}s $t A$R str8$ I B A$R { $% I $t Y Ys Ibs RkR 8R qb I % jb} A$T B s {Z % R Y BZY R$8Zjs$Bt s PZjj 8BI j 8ZR A I % jb} I PB Y str8$ { $% sti {B88Zt${s$Bt {Ystt j V js tz8a BP A$R s R t Ak Y str8$ $t s Bt T]s jb PsRY$Bt Y BZY Y R$8Zjs I {Ystt j sti $t } I Ak Y { $% $ B R {st A {BZt I Ak {B8}s $t Y R $ R BP A$R str8$ I B Y R $ R { $% I qy$r s$b $R {sj{zjs I Y BZY R$8Zjs$Bt PB R % sj I$& t %sjz R BP
Mdd $ et k sti WB$R _Bb 7} { sj * tr$k qy tz8 sb o $R Y t k str8$ I B% s A$ } $BI yt 8stk {B88Zt${s$Bt R{Y 8 R o $R {BtRst yt BZ {YsB${ {B88Zt${s$Bt R{Y 8 $ $R tb qb s{{bzt PB Y$R b {YBBR B h R {sj{zjs s j$saj s% s A$ t k o yt t sj t k PB s {Bt$tZBZR $8 %Bjs R$tsj `w0d B% $t %sj 0 0 0 $R -} RR I Ak ;x 8 /`w0d/ Q03 3B s I$R{ R$tsj `>zh B% Y $8 $t %sj z z z t k $R -} RR I Ak 3 /`>zh/, sti s% s }Bb $R Y sab% -} RR$Bt I$%$I I Ak Y tz8a BP Rs8}j }B$tR $t Y $t %sj qy I tb8$tsb ] $R Y tb$r }Bb R} { sj I tr$k _Bb R} { sj I tr$k w_7*d I R{ $A R Y s8bzt BP }Bb } R t s s }s ${Zjs P JZ t{k * ht$$bt Mdd qy }Bb R} { sj I tr$k PB s I 8$t$R${ }Bb bs% PB 8 $R fwwd ) j$8 w D by j w0d sti P wwd s 3BZ $ q strpb 8 }s$ R sti fwwd YsR Zt$R BP GsR } < 9>dMH qy }Bb R} { sj I tr$k BP s pszrr$st tb$r R JZ t{ {st A PBZtI $t {jbr I PB 8 y $R {BtRst PB sjj P JZ t{$ R Ys $R fwwd ) ] 1 3 wmdd G s saj B t s s pszrr$st tb$r R JZ t{ B sii B BZ R$tsj IZ $t R$8Zjs$Bt sr PBjjBbR ]YBBR s }s ${Zjs wq4d PB Y A$ B } BAsA$j$k {sj{zjs$bt o ] wq4d ) d( jbw o o ] ) d( ] D,, ] ) o 3 wm1d
N A Y RstIs I I %$s$bt sti A Y %s $st{ BP s pszrr$st stib8 R JZ t{ qy PBjjBb$t js$btry$} A b t tb$r }Bb R} { sj I tr$k sti %s $st{ YBjIRU ;E ] 1 ) 3 wmnd 3Zt{$BtR Ys } BIZ{ s pszrr$st R JZ t{ b$y tb 8sj %s $st{ w ) dd s {B88Bt $t s}}j${s$btr RZ{Y sr VqNV qb {Yst Y %s $st{ BP s R JZ t{ 8Zj$}jk Y R T JZ t{ Ak Y RstIs I I %$s$bt N />zh A s pszrr$st I$R $AZ I R JZ t{ b$y tb 8sj %s $st{ qy t />zh { s R s pszrr$st tb$r R JZ t{ b$y %s $st{ G ZR Y$R } B} k $t BZ A$ B } BAsA$j$k R$8Zjs$BtR qy s% s A$ t k o $R Y ji {BtRst by$j Y RstIs I I %$s$bt $R si`zr I B s{y$ % Y I R$ I s$b Md1 $ e B is ]BthI t{ qy Z A$ B s$b js R Y tz8a BP B R t{bzt I $t st $tht$ R JZ t{ BP A$R yp ] $R Y tz8a BP A$R R t sti { $% I sti z $R Y tz8a BP YBR A$R { $% I $t B Y t Y A$ B s$b ƒz $R ƒz ) j$8 z ] 3 wm;d yt R$8Zjs$Bt Y$R j$8$ sti YZR Y s$b ƒz {st Btjk A s}} B-$8s I Ak R$8Zjs$t s js tz8a BP A$R G bbzji j$, BZ {sj{zjs I s$b B A {jbr B ƒz sti sjrb B,tBb b$y$t bys st Y sj s$b b$jj A!Z R$8Zjs$Bt {Bt$tZ R str8$$t sti %sjzs$t A$R Zt$j 1(( B B{{Z 3B js Bsj tz8a BP A$R R t ] Y$R tz8a BP B R } B%$I R 8B Yst s{{ }saj {BthI t{ $t Y {sj{zjs I A$ B s ]BthI t{ $R tb sr BBI PB R8sjj ] j si$t B B s R Bt Y B I BP d( M1 ]Ystt j 7$8Zjs$Bt ]B88Zt${s$Bt {Ystt jr {st A }jsz I b$y 8stk I$& t k} R BP $t P t{ R qy R BP t %s k b$i jk I } ti$t 8stk R$Zs$BtR $t{jzi$t by Y str8$ sti { $% s }YkR${sjjk jb{s I Y s8bzt BP }Bb A $t str8$ I sti Y tz8a BP ZR R s 8}$t B ZR Y Rs8 sti t s Ak {Ystt jr qy 8BR R s$ypb bs I {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 {st A {Ysjj t I Ak Y PBjjBb$t & {R $t Y {Ystt ju du _Bb V tzs$bt T y $R -} { I Ys Y { $% b$jj tb { $% sjj BP Y }Bb 8$ I Ak Y str8$ 3B s b$ I RkR 8 jbrr R s IZ B s tzs$bt $t Y str8$rr$bt j$t 3B b$ j RR RkR 8R Y } BAj 8 BP }Bb s tzs$bt {st A 8Z{Y 8B R %!P t Btjk s P s{$bt BP }Bb si$s I Ak Y str8$ s{zsjjk -{$ R Y { $% st tts 7$8}j s tzs$bt {st A {B { I b$y s$t s Y { $%
1U 7$tsj * jsk T qy R$tsj {sttb } B}ss $trstst BZRjk ej { B8st ${ R$tsjR } B}ss Y BZY s 8 I$Z8 s RB8 R} I j RR Yst Y R} I BP j$y 3B BZ RkR 8 by${y $R Zt$I$ {$Btsj sti JZ$ R tb P IAs{, P B8 Y { $% R$tsj I jsk $R tb R$t$h{st B BZ 8BI j nu _YsR * jsk T qy$r & { $R 8 st$tpzj Btjk B R$tsjR 8BIZjs I b$y {s $ R$tsjR 7B8 8BIZjs$Bt 8 YBIR JZ$ s {BY t { $% qy$r 8 str s R$tZRB$Isj BR{$jjsB $t Y { $% 8ZR Ys% ABY Y Rs8 P JZ t{k sti }YsR sr s {B R}BtI$t BR{$jjsB $t Y str8$ ;U pszrr$st WB$R T!P Y PBZ Y$R $R Y 8BR $8}B st & { Bt s b$ j RR str8$rr$bt RkR 8 y $R -} { I Ys Y { $% b$jj { $% t k BY Yst Ys by${y $R t s I Ak Y str8$ qy$r -{ RR t k $R Ztbst I sti {st {B8 $t 8stk PB 8R =RZsjjk tb$r $R 8BI j I sr st sii$$% } B{ RR b$y s pszrr$st I$R $AZ$Bt qy$r 8BI j $R P I B sr sii$$% by$ pszrr$st tb$r wvgpwd ]B88Zt${s$Bt {Ystt jr 8sk $t{jzi s {B8A$ts$Bt BP Y PBjjBb$t & {R Ys s 8B I$^{Zj B B% {B8 >dh!z AsR AstI str8$rr$bt RkR 8 $R RZA` { I B s P JZ t{k R j {$% {Ystt j xu WBtbY$ WBtTpsZRR$st sti WBtTsII$$% *$RZ Ast{ R T ]BjB I pszrr$st tb$r IB R tb Ys% {BtRst R} { sj I tr$k qy$r $R 8B sj$r${ Yst R$8}j VGpW sr tb sjj P JZ t{$ R {st }srr Y BZY s {Ystt j b$y {BtRst s tzst $Bt B s$t yt P t{ wzt$t t$btsjd sti `s88$t w$t t$btsjd {st A % k I$^{Zj B B% {B8 et k $R 8$ I Ak stby str8$ Ys B% js}r Y P JZ t{k AstI ZR I Ak Y {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 WB$R {st sjrb A $8}ZjR$% $t tsz u B{{Z $t js$% jk $tp JZ tjk sti }BB jk 8BI j I Ak s pszrr$st } B{ RR EU 3 JZ t{k 7 j {$% ]Ystt jr T qy R {Ystt jr IB tb }srr sjj P JZ t{$ R b$y Y Rs8 j % j BP s tzs$bt G$ R s tb t sjjk s& { I Ak Y$R & { -{ } s % k Y$Y P JZ t{$ R 3B b$ j RR RkR 8R s8br}y ${ sti $BtBR}Y ${ & {R s R$t$h{st VjRB ts Bb AstI st ttsr 8sk tb R}BtI Zt$PB 8jk B Y PZjj AstIb$IY BP s str8$rr$bt 7 {Ys} d( PB s I R{ $}$Bt BP BZ I$^{Zj$ R t{bzt I b$y s P JZ t{k R j {$% {Ystt j $t BZ AsR AstI RkR 8 U q$8 Tzs k$t ]Ystt jr T qy R {Ystt j & {R s 8BR R$t$h{st PB 8BT A$j b$ j RR RkR 8R *B}}j RY$P {st A R$t$h{st PB s 8B%$t { $% B str8$ 3B R} IR 8Z{Y RjBb Yst Y R} I BP j$y *B}}j RY$P $R } BT }B $Btsj B Y js$% % jb{$k A b t Y str8$ sti { $% *B}}j $tiz{ I PsI$t $R BP {Bt{ t PB jbb Iss s RkR 8R!P t s str8$rr$bt s% jr B s { $% B% 8Zj$}j }syr qy R 8Zj$ }sy {Ystt jr s R} {$sjjk R$t$h{st $t Z Ast s sr by 4 {$BtR B& BP R Z{Z R {szr s R$tsj B A { $% I R % sj $8 R b$y I$& t $8 I jskr Zj$ }sy PsI$t $R BP Y$Y {Bt{ t PB Y$Y Iss s RkR 8R ;
Mn i RZjR BP $ e B _ BAsA$j$k 7$8Zjs$BtR ;M VR A$ B } BAsA$j$k $R R$t$h{st B stk {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 b } R t RZjR P B8 R % sj I$& t R$8Zjs$BtR Vjj A$ B } BAsA$j$k R$8Zjs$BtR Zt $t VqNV b$y BZ IZsj Rkt{Y Bt$9$t { $% R{Y 8 qy h R R BP R$8Zjs$BtR Y$Yj$Y Y } PB 8st{ BP BZ IZsj Rkt{Y Bt$9$t { $% R{Y 8 b$y }s s8 R R Ys Ys% A t ZR I $t stby }ZAj$RY I bb, %$t ]ZB8B sj } R t s {B88Zt${s$Bt R{Y 8 AsR I Bt {YsBR $t >H qy $ {Bt$tZBZR RkR 8 $R AZ$j sr st stsjb {$ {Z$ yt Y $ R$tj }s s8 8BIZjs$Bt R{Y 8 Y # 8 $R Y Btjk }s s8 {Yst I AsR I Bt Y 8 RRs A$ B A str8$ I ]ZB8B sj I$I tb }B A$ B } BAsA$j$k } PB 8st{ PB Y $ RkR 8 qy B} t RJZs R $t 3$Z Md RYBb Y } PB 8st{ BP BZ RkR 8 by t 8BIZjs$t Btjk Y # }s s8 AsR I s 8 RRs A$ #w(d ) ;3( sti #wdd ) ;3; qy BY bb }s s8 R s {BtRstU ) de3( sti ' ) ;x3e G Z$j$9 Y 8 8B k BP BZ I$R{ } B{ RRB AsR I RkR 8 $t BZ IZsj Rkt{Y Bt$9$t { $% R{Y 8 qy$r sjjbbr PB s 8B RZARst$sj }s s8 R 8$R8s{Y A b t s Bt T A$ sti s 9 BTA$ k Ztt$t bb { $% R Bt PB s{y }s s8 R Y str8$ Rs sti { $% Rs b$jj sjbskr srbtsajk 8s{Y s Y ti BP stk A$ } $BI qy sr $R,R $t 3$Z Md RYBb Y } PB 8st{ BP BZ RkR 8 ZR$t s 8B RZARst$sj 8BIZjs$Bt BP # w#w(d ) ;3( sti #wdd ) ;3;D qy BY bb }s s8 R s {BtRstU ) de3( sti ' ) ;x3e qy B} t {$ {j R $t 3$Z Md RYBb Y A$ B } BAsA$j$k RZjR }ZAj$RY I $t s }s} Ak ]s Bj sti _ {B s PB {B8}s $RBt>d1H qy R b Y Btjk A$ B } BAsA$j$k RZjR b {BZjI hti PB s {YsB${ {B88Zt${s$Bt RkR 8 G s ZR$t s I$& t R{Y 8 Ys b -} { B A 8B {B% sti BZ RZjR RYBb A A$ B } BAsA$j$k } PB 8st{ qy A$ } $BI $R s { Z{$sj Ps{B PB A$ B } BAsA$j$k R$8Zjs$Bt A {szr $ s& {R YBb 8Z{Y $8 Y bb { $% R Ys% B Rkt{Y Bt$9 B B I$% P B8 Y $t4z t{ R$tsj qy$r sjrb I$ {jk & {R RkR 8 Iss s!z Rs8}j {BZt PB Y R R$8Zjs$BtR $R d(( Rs8}j R } A$ V ;M((( Rs8}j R } R {BtI Y A$ } $BI $R x ) 13(MEX3 3B {B8}s $RBt Y A$ } $BI PB Y B} t {$ {j R $R }B I B A 1(( R { Mnd =t -} { I 7BZ { BP e B R s <$Y G Ys% I$R{B% I by$j k$t B sr{ s$t Y {szr BP A$ B R st $t R$t RZj 3B js$% jk js s$br BP A$ t k B tb$r }Bb R} { sj I tr$k w8 srz I $t I D A$ B R s js jk IZ B {Ys s{ $R${R BP Y {YsB${ RkR 8 $tr si BP tb$r 3B AsR${ str8$rr$bt R{Y 8 R j$, _7 Y t k $t s A$ $R sjbskr Y Rs8 sti B R B{{Z by t Y tb$r t k $R js qy$r $R tb Z PB BZ {YsB${ R{Y 8 i {sjj Ys b ZR I s% s A$ t k o PB BZ {sj{zjs$btr BP tb$r }Bb R} { sj I tr$k y Z tr BZ Ys Y NB t9 RkR 8 B{{sR$Btsjjk B R $tb $BtR by Y t k BP `w0d $R R$t$h{stjk j RR Yst $R s% s GY t Y A$ b$tibb {B R}BtIR B Y R $BtR Y t k $t YBR A$R $R R8sjj Yst -} { I qy j % j BP pszrr$st tb$r $t4z t{ $R tb si`zr I $t BZ R$8Zjs$BtR B s{{bzt PB jbb R$tsj t k G I {$I I B 8BI j RkR 8 A Ys%$B $t Y$R bsk sr tb$r $R tb RB8 Y$t Ys {st ZRZsjjk A si`zr I $t s
- ; 10 0 10 1 Bit Error Probability 10 2 10 3 10 4 (a) (b) (c) (d) 10 5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Eb/No (db)! " #! # $ % &! $ ' &! ( ) * - +.,
x( Number of Bits 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Eb Avg = 10.29 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 Energy over bit (a) 15 NoiseE Avg = 0.648 Number of Bits 10 5 0 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 (b) Energy over bit $ % & '! #
xd
x1 ]Ys} ]Ys s{ $9$t 3 JZ t{k *B8s$t _ B} $ R!P t $ $R ZR PZj B {Ys s{ $9 s R$tsj ZR$t 8B Yst `ZR $8 TIB8s$t BAR %s$btr ZR$t st BR{$jjBR{B} V R} { Z8 stsjk9 $R s R} {$sj$9 I }$ { BP JZ$}8 t Ys 8 srz R Y I$R $AZ$Bt BP R$tsj }Bb sr s PZt{$Bt BP P JZ t{k qy$r k} BP stsjkr$r $R ZR I Y s%$jk $t j { Bt${ bs Ps yt RZ}}B BP BZ Bsj B %sjzs Y$R RkR 8:R s}}j${sa$j$k PB {B% {B88Zt${s$Bt b 8 srz RB8 P JZ t{k IB8s$t {Ys s{ $R${R BP BZ RkR 8 d 7$tsj ]s8bz4s yt$$sjjk BZ Btjk {s}sa$j$k B jbb, s BZ RkR 8:R } PB 8st{ $t Y P JZ t{k IB8s$t bsr Ak VqNV R$8Zjs$BtR >1(H G tbb Ys% s Ys Ibs RkR 8 Ys {st A stsjk9 I ZR$t R$tsj stsjkr$r JZ$}8 t qy } $8s k I %${ PB IB$t Y$R $R s Rb }$t R} { Z8 stsjk9 qy$r RkR 8 R s {Y R $t s Rb } }s t Y BZY 8stk P JZ t{$ R B 8 srz Y s8bzt BP t k A $t { $% I s s{y }s ${Zjs P JZ t{k qy$r $R Bt 8 YBI Ak by${y s str8$rr$bt 8$Y A I { I Ak st j { Bt${ bs Ps }jspb 8 3$Z d RYBbR RB8 RZjR BP VqNV R$8Zjs$BtR {B8}s $t Y P JZ t{k R}BtR BP BZ {YsB${ str8$ b$y Y tb$r 4BB qy Ps{ Ys BZ str8$ $R A jbb Y tb$r 4BB $R BBI PB {B% t RR i RZjR I }${ I $t hz d s % k } B8$R$t PB s}}j${s$btr BP {YsBR B {B% 8$j$s k {B88Zt${s$Bt qy RkR 8 s}} s R saj B R} si $R t k $t RZ{Y s bsk Ys R$8}j BAR %s$bt BP }Bb $t Y P JZ t{k IB8s$t b$jj tb I { Y R$tsj G t - } R t RB8 Ys Ibs BAR %s$btr Ys RZ}}B Y$R $ti${s$bt 1 3 JZ t{k *B8s$t srz 8 tr $t <s Ibs =R$t BZ Rb }$t R} { Z8 stsjk9 b 8 srz $t Ys Ibs Y I$R $AZ$Bt BP t k $t Y P JZ t{k IB8s$t G {Bth 8 Ys Y stib8tj$, A Ys%$B $t$$sjjk BAR % I $t
xn 1 Lorenz System 0.5 Voltage, V 0 0.5 1 0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 Time, (sec.) 1.5 Frequency content of signal Noise Floor 1 FFT 0.5 Transmission Energy 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 frequency (khz) & ' ( )! " # $ % {YsB${ RkR 8R IB R $t Ps{ j si B R8BBY sti b$i t k I$R $AZ$Bt $t Y P JZ t{k IB8s$t 3$Z 1 RYBbR Y t k BP BZ str8$ I R$tsj BAR % I Ak Y R} { Z8 stsjk9 B% Bt Rb } qy t k I$R $AZ$Bt BP Y$R hz {Yst R RZARst$sjjk P B8 Rb } B Rb } BP Y JZ$}8 t `ZR j$, $ bbzji PB s stib8 R$tsj 3$Z n $R Rs8 R} { Z8 b$y %$I B s% s$t Z t I Bt sti R B t s% s R qy$r sjjbbr ZR B R Y t sj RYs} BP Y t k I$R $AZ$Bt srrb{$s I b$y Y$R {YsB${ RkR 8 y $R } B8$R$t Ys Y R} { Z8 $R js$% jk R8BBY b$ybz stk I$R$tZ$RY$t } s,r BP t k GY$j j$, jk BB R8sjj B A BP {Bt{ t PB BZ {B% t RR $t% R$s$Bt b s, $t R $t Y bb tb{y R Ys s}} s sti 8s$t $t Y s% s I RkR 8 R} { Z8 qy R s RYBbt $t hz n s s}} B-$8s jk E,<9 sti d1,<9 y Z tr BZ Ys by t BZ str8$ s{zsjjk A $tr 8BIZjs$t $R }s s8 R B R ti s 8 RRs Y R8sjj tb{y R s bsry I BZ $t Y Rs8 s8bzt BP s% s$t qy$r $R I }${ I $t hz ; yt sii$$bt B Y AsR${ P JZ t{k R} { Z8 Rts}RYBR sti s% s R I }${ I $t hz R 1 Y BZY ; b ZR R} { B s8r B stsjk9 BZ RkR 8R {B% } PB 8st{ 7} { BT s8r sjjbb s YkA $I stsjkr$r BY $8 IB8s$t sti P JZ t{k IB8s$t $tpb 8s$Bt {st A
x; 0 10 20 Signal Magnitude, db 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Frequency, Hz x 10 4 x
xx 0 10 20 Signal Magnitude, db 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Frequency, Hz! " # $! " % x 10 4
xe 0 10 20 Signal Magnitude, db 30 40 50 60 70 80 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Frequency, Hz! "! #! $ % & '!! $!!!!! $!!!!! (!!!! #!!!!! $!!!!!! x 10 4
! " # $ %! " & ' $ & ( ) ) ) ) * x
xm
! " # $ % & x
! " # $ % E(