DAFTAR LAMPIRAN Lampiran 1 Gambar Editor Input Speimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia Lampiran 2 Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Speimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia 107
Lampiran 3 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Cumbia Lampiran 4 Gambar Editor Input Speimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia 108
Lampiran 5 Gambar Hasil Momen Curvature Speimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia Lampiran 6 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Cumbia 109
Lampiran 7 Gambar Editor Input Speimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia Lampiran 8 Gambar Hasil Momen Curvature Speimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia 110
Lampiran 9 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Cumbia Lampiran 10 Gambar Penampang dan Geometri Properties Speimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Response-2000 111
Lampiran 11 Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Speimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Response- 2000 Lampiran 12 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan Response-2000 112
Lampiran 13 Gambar Penampang dan Geometri Properties Speimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response-2000 Lampiran 14 Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Speimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response- 2000 113
Lampiran 15 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response-2000 Lampiran 16 Gambar Penampang dan Geometri Properties Speimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Response-2000 114
Lampiran 17 Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Speimen US_SP00_R0_100 dengan Response- 2000 Lampiran 18 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan Response-2000 115
Lampiran 19 Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Speimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan XTRACT 116
Lampiran 20 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen DN_SP50_R0_230 dengan XTRACT 117
Lampiran 21 Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Speimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan XTRACT 118
Lampiran 22 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen DL_SP00_R0_100 dengan XTRACT 119
Lampiran 23 Gambar Hasil Moment-Curvature Speimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan XTRACT 120
Lampiran 24 Gambar Hasil Momen Axial Speimen US_SP00_R0_93 dengan XTRACT 121
Lampiran 25 TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN CURVATURE DENGAN CUMBIA Charateristis o Test Speimen Hinge Length (m) Bi-Fator First Yield Curvature Moment EI Eekti Ultimate Ultimate/Yield First Yield Ultimate Ultimate/Yield Yield Moment/Yield Curvature 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0.258 0.009 0.00760 0.08968 11.800 482.060 528.240 1.096 63428.947 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0.258 0.009 0.00799 0.07544 9.442 624.690 672.900 1.077 78183.980 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0.258 0.016 0.00772 0.16105 20.861 488.470 639.000 1.308 63273.316 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0.258 0.016 0.00768 0.13986 18.211 485.820 618.720 1.274 63257.813 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0.258 0.015 0.00772 0.22738 29.453 489.370 696.910 1.424 63389.896 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0.258 0.016 0.00769 0.14967 19.463 486.700 628.770 1.292 63289.987 Lampiran 26 TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN CURVATURE DENGAN RESPONSE 2000 Charateristis o Test Speimen Hinge Length (m) Bi-Fator First Yield Curvature Moment EI Eekti Ultimate Ultimate/Yield First Yield Ultimate Ultimate/Yield Yield Moment/Yield Curvature 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0.258 0.009 0.00766 0.07543 9.848 421.866 467.149 1.107 55073.890 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0.258 0.009 0.00796 0.07543 9.476 529.475 597.304 1.128 66516.960 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0.258 0.009 0.00775 0.13144 16.960 428.468 495.249 1.156 55286.194 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0.258 0.009 0.00763 0.11765 15.419 425.862 474.449 1.114 55814.155 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0.258 0.009 0.00776 0.19322 24.899 429.361 505.649 1.178 55330.026 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0.258 0.009 0.00768 0.12575 16.374 426.760 487.849 1.143 55567.708 Lampiran 27 TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN CURVATURE DENGAN XTRACT Charateristis o Test Speimen Hinge Length (m) Bi-Fator First Yield Curvature Moment EI Eekti Ultimate Ultimate/Yield First Yield Ultimate Ultimate/Yield Yield Moment/Yield Curvature 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0.258 0.003 0.00590 0.07061 11.968 363.010 470.600 1.296 61527.119 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0.258 0.005 0.00608 0.06326 10.405 462.800 607.600 1.313 76118.421 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0.258 0.005 0.00600 0.07027 11.712 368.120 475.500 1.292 61353.333 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0.258 0.004 0.00598 0.07020 11.739 365.200 474.700 1.300 61070.234 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0.258 0.005 0.00605 0.07146 11.812 369.600 477.300 1.291 61090.909 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0.258 0.005 0.00595 0.07132 11.987 366.460 475.600 1.298 61589.916 122
Lampiran 28 TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN AXIAL DENGAN CUMBIA Charateristis o Test Speimen Max. Compression Load Max. Tension Load Maximum Moment Moment (Mxx) at P = 0 P (kn) M3 P (kn) M3 M3 P at Max. Moment (kn) M3 P (kn) 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 8802.190 0-1630.080 0 690.620 3435.330 386.520 0 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 9552.730 0-2445.120 0 801.570 3435.330 531.480 0 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 8789.760 0-1630.080 0 703.790 3435.330 400.230 0 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 8792.580 0-1630.080 0 699.510 3817.040 400.330 0 5 US-SP00-R0-50 8781.340 0-1630.080 0 718.210 3817.040 402.500 0 6 US-SP00-R0-93 8791.580 0-1630.080 0 703.440 3435.330 399.410 0 Lampiran 29 TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN AXIAL DENGAN RESPONSE-2000 Charateristis o Test Speimen Max. Compression Load Max. Tension Load Maximum Moment Moment (Mxx) at P = 0 P (kn) M3 P (kn) M3 M3 P at Max. Moment (kn) M3 P (kn) 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 9137.303 0-2222.641 0 628.615 2747.194 373.058 0 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 9784.070 0-3309.718 0 729.569 2707.314 514.578 0 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 9087.300 0-2222.641 0 600.910 2747.194 390.158 0 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 9097.700 0-2222.641 0 599.510 2747.194 390.050 0 5 US-SP00-R0-50 9077.500 0-2222.641 0 618.610 2747.194 385.058 0 6 US-SP00-R0-93 9097.800 0-2222.641 0 600.410 2747.194 383.058 0 Lampiran 30 TABEL HASIL PERHITUNGAN MOMEN AXIAL DENGAN XTRACT Charateristis o Test Speimen Max. Compression Load Max. Tension Load Maximum Moment Moment (Mxx) at P = 0 P (kn) M3 P (kn) M3 M3 P at Max. Moment (kn) M3 P (kn) 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 9544.000 0-1624.000 0 650.500 3236.000 349.400 0 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 10290.000 0-2436.000 0 749.000 3278.000 504.900 0 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 9673.000 0-1624.000 0 651.400 3237.000 369.500 0 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 9658.000 0-1624.000 0 650.300 3237.000 369.500 0 5 US-SP00-R0-50 9698.000 0-1624.000 0 671.600 3238.000 359.500 0 6 US-SP00-R0-93 9663.000 0-1624.000 0 661.300 3237.000 355.500 0 123
Lampiran 31 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA Charateristis o Test Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0.004311 0.039175 0.045964 0 297.736 308.619 305.475 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0.005648 0.035054 0.040824 0 390.021 404.611 400.601 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0.004443 0.067307 0.074274 0 306.814 343.965 340.625 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0.004379 0.059042 0.064907 0 302.392 339.514 336.176 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0.004428 0.093240 0.100201 0 305.787 362.162 358.441 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0.004436 0.062865 0.069736 0 306.329 341.360 338.079 Lampiran 32 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000 Charateristis o Test Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0.004211 0.033542 0.041718 0 290.777 300.372 297.395 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0.005490 0.034981 0.041551 0 379.097 399.732 395.729 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0.004211 0.055217 0.063393 0 290.777 300.372 297.395 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0.004211 0.049880 0.058056 0 290.777 300.372 297.395 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0.004211 0.079126 0.087301 0 290.777 300.372 297.396 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0.004211 0.053015 0.061191 0 290.777 300.372 297.395 Lampiran 33 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT Charateristis o Test Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0.003982 0.031658 0.041250 0 274.999 299.165 296.130 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0.005364 0.030592 0.037495 0 370.416 421.978 417.751 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0.003985 0.031537 0.041349 0 275.164 299.910 296.896 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0.003984 0.031508 0.041287 0 275.150 299.775 296.761 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0.003985 0.032001 0.041864 0 275.179 300.119 297.107 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0.003984 0.031944 0.041749 0 275.150 299.957 296.938 124
Lampiran 34 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA L sp Jarak 25 m Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0,003071 0,037889 0,038976 0 297,736 308,619 304,153 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0,004022 0,033368 0,034299 0 390,021 404,611 398,768 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0,003164 0,065874 0,067041 0 306,814 343,965 338,993 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0,003119 0,057627 0,058591 0 302,392 339,52 334,611 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0,003154 0,091731 0,092828 0 305,787 362,162 356,928 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0,003159 0,061443 0,062606 0 306,329 341,36 336,425 Lampiran 35 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000 L sp Jarak 25 m Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0,002999 0,03229 0,033644 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0,00391 0,033315 0,034369 0 379,097 399,732 393,965 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0,003509 0,054493 0,056155 0 290,777 300,372 296,662 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0,002999 0,048628 0,049982 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0,002999 0,077874 0,079228 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0,002999 0,051763 0,053117 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 Lampiran 36 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT L sp Jarak 25 m Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0,002836 0,030412 0,031968 0 274,999 299,165 294,842 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0,00382 0,028834 0,02994 0 370,416 421,978 415,893 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0,002838 0,030288 0,031896 0 275,164 299,91 295,576 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0,002838 0,030259 0,031861 0 275,15 299,775 295,443 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0,002838 0,03075 0,03237 0 275,179 300,119 295,782 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0,002838 0,030694 0,032299 0 275,15 299,957 295,622 125
Lampiran 37 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN CUMBIA L sp Jarak 50 m Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0,003071 0,037889 0,040108 0 297,736 308,619 304,153 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0,004022 0,033368 0,03529 0 390,021 404,611 398,768 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0,003164 0,065874 0,06826 0 306,814 343,965 338,993 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0,003119 0,057627 0,059605 0 302,392 339,52 334,611 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0,003154 0,091731 0,09398 0 305,787 362,162 356,928 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0,003159 0,061443 0,06382 0 306,329 341,36 336,425 Lampiran 38 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN RESPONSE-2000 L sp Jarak 50 m Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0,002999 0,03229 0,035043 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0,00391 0,033315 0,035483 0 379,097 399,732 393,965 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0,003852 0,054846 0,057913 0 290,777 300,372 296,991 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0,002999 0,048628 0,051381 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0,002999 0,077874 0,080627 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0,002999 0,051763 0,054516 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 Lampiran 39 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS DENGAN XTRACT L sp Jarak 50 m Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0,002836 0,030412 0,033569 0 274,999 299,165 294,842 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0,00382 0,028834 0,03111 0 370,416 421,978 415,893 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0,002838 0,030288 0,03355 0 275,164 299,91 295,576 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0,002838 0,030259 0,033508 0 275,15 299,775 295,443 q5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0,002838 0,03075 0,034034 0 275,179 300,119 295,782 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0,002838 0,030694 0,033949 0 275,15 299,957 295,622 126
Lampiran 40 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSIS L sp Jarak 57,4 m Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 CUMBIA 0 0,004443 0,067307 0,070103 0 306,814 343,965 340,424 2 Response-2000 0 0,002999 0,053965 0,057132 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 3 XTRACT 0 0,002838 0,030288 0,034039 0 275,164 299,91 295,576 Lampiran 41 TABEL HASIL PUSH OVER ANALYSISL sp Jarak 60 m Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 CUMBIA 0 0,003429 0,092057 0,094544 0 305,787 362,162 357,348 2 Response-2000 0 0,002999 0,077874 0,081186 0 290,777 300,372 296,03 3 XTRACT 0 0,002838 0,03075 0,034699 0 275,179 300,118 295,782 Lampiran 42 TABEL LATERAL FORCE-DISPLACEMENT RESPONSE ENVELOPESHASIL EKSPERIMENTAL CHUNG dkk. (2008) Charateristis o Displaement (m) Base Fore (kn) Test Speimen 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 DN-SP00-R0-230 0 0,018 0,04 0,090 0 283 315 190 2 DN-SP50-R0-230 0 0,015 0,024 0,077 0 260 275 135 3 DL-SP00-R0-82 0 0,015 0,030 0,105 0 270 290 180 4 DL-SP00-R0-100 0 0,015 0,030 0,105 0 270 290 180 5 US-SP00-R0-50 0 0,015 0,057 0,105 0 315 365 250 6 US-SP00-R0-93 0 0,015 0,057 0,105 0 315 365 250 127
Lampiran 43 GAMBAR HASIL MOMEN CURVATURE SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL Nilai-nilai momen-kurvatur dapat diperkirakan seara perhitungan manual. Untuk kurvatur pada keadaan leleh φ dapat diperkirakan dengan menggunakan persamaan usulan Park dan Paula (1974) ang dimodiikasi oleh Kunnath dkk. (1992); n0 φ = 1.05 + ( C2 0.05) 3 / Es d(1 k) dimana; 0.45 C 2 = ; At 0.84 + ' bd N n = ; ( bd ) 0 ' 128
129 / 2 1 / 1 ) / 4( 1 0 ' ' 0 ' 2 ' 2 0 2 ' ' t t t bd A bd A bd A d bd A bd A bd A k + + + + = Kurvatur ultimate dapat diperkirakan dengan menganggap kolom berperilaku sama dengan elemen balok sebagaimana persamaan ang diusulkan olehpark dan Paula (1976); t u A A bβ = 1 ' 0.85 φ Momen lentur pada keadaan leleh (M ) dapat diperkirakan dengan persamaan berikut Park dkk. (1987); + + + + = ' 0.7 0 0 ' 0.7 0 0 2 ' 1 0.75 2 1 0.75 1 0.5 t bd A bd N d d bd M... + + bd A d d α ' 0.7 0 0 2 1 0.75 dimana; d d d d α = 0 1 Sedangkan momen lentur pada keadaan runtuh atau batas (M u ) dapat diperkirakan dengan persamaan berikut (Park dkk., 1987); t u M bd N bd A M = ' ' 5 0. 0.15 1.24
Lampiran 44 TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE CUMBIA SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL Charateristis o Test Speimen First Yield Curvature Ultimate First Yield Displaement Ultimate 1 DN_SP00_R0_230 0.00760 0.08968 0.00570 0.06726 2 DN_SP50_R0_230 0.00799 0.07544 0.00599 0.05658 3 DL_SP00_R0_82 0.00772 0.16105 0.00579 0.12079 4 DL_SP00_R0_100 0.00768 0.13986 0.00576 0.10490 5 US_SP00_R0_50 0.00772 0.22738 0.00579 0.17054 6 US_SP00_R0_93 0.00769 0.14967 0.00577 0.11225 Lampiran 45 TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE RESPONSE- 2000 SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL Charateristis o Test Speimen First Yield Curvature Ultimate First Yield Displaement Ultimate 1 DN_SP00_R0_230 0.00766 0.07543 0.00575 0.05657 2 DN_SP50_R0_230 0.00796 0.07543 0.00597 0.05657 3 DL_SP00_R0_82 0.00775 0.13144 0.00581 0.09858 4 DL_SP00_R0_100 0.00763 0.11765 0.00572 0.08824 5 US_SP00_R0_50 0.00776 0.19322 0.00582 0.14492 6 US_SP00_R0_93 0.00768 0.12575 0.00576 0.09431 Lampiran 46 TABEL HASIL DISPLACEMENT DARI MOMEN CURVATURE XTRACT SECARA MANUAL DENGAN MICROSOFT EXCEL Charateristis o Test Speimen First Yield Curvature Ultimate First Yield Displaement Ultimate 1 DN_SP00_R0_230 0.00590 0.07061 0.00443 0.05296 2 DN_SP50_R0_230 0.00608 0.06326 0.00456 0.04745 3 DL_SP00_R0_82 0.00600 0.07027 0.00450 0.05270 4 DL_SP00_R0_100 0.00598 0.07020 0.00449 0.05265 5 US_SP00_R0_50 0.00605 0.07146 0.00454 0.05360 6 US_SP00_R0_93 0.00595 0.07132 0.00446 0.05349 130